Why do baristas frequently break down and fight with customers? The story behind this is full of bitter tears

In a decent and bright office building, with a clean countertop all to yourself, using a coffee machine worth hundreds of thousands of dollars to brew cup after cup of coffee that is praised as top-notch in the industry, is this job really flawless and pure?

Last month, when the coffee powder spilled onto the counter, some preconceived fantasies were shattered.

Not long ago, similar conflicts occurred in several Manner stores in Shanghai. The conflicts arose from customers' urging for orders, making things difficult and the store clerks' emotional outbursts.

After some time had passed, we observed the direction of public opinion and the views of people with different standpoints, and came to the conclusion that:In such accidental conflict events, there is one inevitability – baristas of chain brands cannot escape the fate of having to take on multiple roles, nor can they escape the pressure from both customers and the company.

Unlike a tea shop, where a store is staffed by many employees and there is someone specifically responsible for cutting the fruit, it is also not like a restaurant where the chef is responsible for cooking and the waiters are responsible for serving the food.

Many baristas from chain brands joke on social media that they are “button pressers,” “cleaners,” and “robots.” In addition to making coffee, they also have to take care of other matters personally.

On the one hand, they have to accept the company's expectations of standardization, praise rate, etc. On the other hand, they also have to accept that coffee consumers have instant and functional needs. Customers' requirements for taste and cup-making efficiency far exceed those of tea drinks.

In 2023, the scale of China's coffee industry will reach 265.4 billion yuan, and the average annual compound growth rate of the coffee industry in the past three years has reached 17.14%. It is expected to increase to 313.3 billion yuan in 2024. This is data from the “2024 China Urban Coffee Development Report”.

As the Chinese coffee market is booming, people are always paying attention to data:Market size, number of stores opened, cup production speed, repurchase rate…

However, few people pay attention to the most important role in this business, the people at the forefront of the coffee market. Today, let's press the pause button and get to know the barista.

A barista from a chain brand confessed to Zhiwei:“Making coffee is the easiest and simplest thing in a barista’s job.”

In the existing mainstream coffee shop chains, the coffee making tools in the stores are divided into two types: fully automatic coffee machines and semi-automatic coffee machines. The difference in production tools will naturally bring different challenges to productivity, that is, baristas. But tracing back to the essence of coffee production, chain coffee shops are still mainly based on memorizing recipes.

Therefore, as long as you remember the recipe, no matter what coffee machine you use, there will be basically no difficulty in producing the coffee. Problems often arise in things related to making coffee.

Luckin Coffee store employees often joke that they are “cleaners” because Luckin Coffee pays great attention to store hygiene. There are clear requirements on the order in which employees should pick up materials, when to wash their hands, etc. The company also conducts frequent spot checks, and many employees complain that “the skin on their hands is peeling after washing.”

Junjun (pseudonym) worked at Tim's Coffee for two years and is used to peeling hands.

“Because I have to use a rag soaked in disinfectant to wipe the table, and my hands will definitely peel after soaking in disinfectant several times.”

She told Zhiwei that the most uncomfortable season is winter. Although you can wash your hands with hot water in winter, the rag is still soaked in cold disinfectant. “My hands are drier in winter, so I usually have to use hand cream. My hands hurt a lot when I apply hand cream after get off work in winter.”

Later, everyone started to bring their own gloves to avoid direct contact with disinfectant. Junjun said that some employees did not come to work the next day because they were allergic to disinfectant.

Why are baristas willing to spend so much time and energy on repeatedly washing their hands and wiping the countertops? Because according to the requirements of most coffee brands, everything from small things like hand washing to big things like whether bread crumbs are scattered are included in the content of the inspection.

Compared with the points deducted from the store, the cracks on my hands seem insignificant.

Junjun introduced that the position responsible for spot-checking the hygiene conditions of each store at Tim's is called an auditor. “If an audit of a region is coming, all stores will be informed, and everyone will pay attention in advance. Sometimes they will stand still and dare not move. The audit usually checks whether your operating procedures are in compliance, such as washing hands after leaving the bar.”

Junjun said that she had to attend an audit shortly after she started working. She was so nervous that she kept her hands on her chest, “like a surgeon.” She didn't dare to push her glasses even though they were about to slip off, for fear that she would be deducted points if she didn't pay attention. “Deductions will affect the store manager's performance, and the store itself will be shameful.”

In addition to strict inspections, Junjun said there is also a force called “mysterious customers.”

She introduced,Ordinary consumers can sign up to become “mystery customers” through an application called “Dairenlaiyaya”. After the application is successful, they can go to the store and pretend to be a customer to order food to see whether the service attitude, operating procedures, polite greetings, etc. are up to standard. After the completion, the system will also give cash rewards.

“Mysterious customers” do not only exist in coffee brands. Junjun's friend who works at Haagen-Dazs has also encountered this situation. The point is that in chain coffee companies that already focus on standardization and are in a rising stage, the company will pay more attention to this kind of public evaluation, and this tension is also directly transferred to the barista.

With recipes memorized by heart and materials well classified, it is not difficult to understand why baristas are most relaxed when making coffee, but feel tense about everything other than coffee making.

Behind the collapse of baristas is the lack of solutions in chain stores

It is often the trivial matters that pull a barista out of the flow state of making coffee.

First, there are customer complaints. In his exchanges with several chain brand baristas, Zhiwei noticed that chain coffee brands care about customer complaints much more than we thought.

“Generally, whenever there is a complaint, we will call the customer immediately. If it is our fault, we will ask the customer to make a note and send him a cup next time, or ask someone to deliver it to him now.” Junjun said that there will definitely be times when the store is negligent and makes mistakes, but there are also many unreasonable customers. “The barista must solve the problem, but in fact, the store manager can still see the complaints in the background.”

She said,We often have to beg customers to withdraw their complaints because the company really cares about this.

The work group also often receives pressure from above. For example, it is required that the rating of Meituan Takeout be restored from 4.7 to 4.8 within a week. During this period, there should be no more negative reviews, and the number of positive reviews should be appropriately increased. Follow-up visits should be made every day, and the follow-up forms should also be sent to the group.

Junjun told Zhiwei,There was even a store manager who directly contacted the friends of the customers who wrote the bad reviews through various means. He went through a lot of trouble and spent a lot of time and effort just to delete a bad review.

In the entire catering industry, it is normal to pay attention to customer complaints. However, in the coffee industry, due to the special nature of store baristas who have multiple duties, handling such customer complaints is often the responsibility of baristas themselves.

In stark contrast to feedback from the outside world, what baristas fear most is brand collaborations. The more excited consumers and brands are, the more afraid baristas become. This represents the oversaturation of today's work and an unpredictable error rate.

When we encounter the situation where we want to give away co-branded gifts with an order, not only do we get a lot of orders coming in, but sometimes they get placed in the wrong place, or they are missed, or the co-branded information is inaccurate, and customers come to ask why there are no gifts.

In some brands where after-sales service is not very mature, baristas must take on the responsibility of customer service. Their hands are constantly busy preparing cups of coffee, and their brains are also working quickly to explain joint activities. At this time, handling customer complaints and making coffee are both muscle memory.

Li Hang told us that this was nothing, even in such extreme circumstances, “One time my backend app crashed.” Although he knew that the orders had been cancelled, looking at the blank mobile page, Li Hang suddenly got lost in this small store.

Then there are some basic needs. It is said online that when a barista at Manner is on duty alone, he has to put up a sign stating the reason and phone number when going to the toilet, and even put a countdown stopwatch. In fact, this is true. Li Hang (pseudonym), a former employee of Manner, told Zhiwei that it should be handled this way, but when they have to be on duty alone, “I don't go to the toilet if I can avoid it.”

Most of the time when Junjun worked at Tim's, there were at least two people on duty at the same time. But she told Zhiwei, “I rarely drink water when I'm at work, but I drink a lot after work.”

Trying to reduce the number of times you go to the bathroom will not necessarily help you make more cups of coffee, but what you actually save is some unnecessary communication costs and trouble. You may go to the bathroom quickly and come back quickly, but if you ask your colleagues in advance to take your shift, etc., this will also cause trouble to others.

“The meal time is about 30-40 minutes, and generally no one stays overtime because no one wants to cause trouble for others.” Junjun added that he would plan the time to go to the toilet according to the store's turnover, and if necessary, try to avoid the morning rush hour and afternoon tea.

She also encountered “Murphy's Law”. When she was in a hurry to go to the toilet, her hands were full of orders. If you don't experience it, you will never know that mental and physical pressure can give a person a feeling at the same time.

Li Hang, who often works alone, simply eats after get off work. “Sometimes when I'm not feeling well or in a hurry, I'll ask my colleagues on the next shift to arrive a little earlier.”

As for how many cups of coffee they produce every day, none of them can give an answer. “Quite a lot.” “No one has the time to count.” “Data is the company's business.”

The beautiful data is given to investors by the brand. Although baristas have to go through all the big and small matters in the store, they rarely have a sense of the data. In their opinion, the most meaningful data is:

Go to get off work and leave work on time, and no working hours are deducted.

Behind the collapse of baristas is the lack of solutions in chain stores

Compared with other tea brands, the number of baristas in the same time period of the chain coffee shop is relatively small. According to sources close to Manner, Manner has improved the “one-person store” situation by increasing part-time jobs and optimizing shift scheduling, and the company will continue to improve the scheduling mechanism in the future.

Li Hang also said that the shift system at a store in Shanghai where he previously worked was that two people took turns working in two shifts, one from 8 a.m. to 2 p.m. and the other from 1 p.m. to 6 p.m.

Another Lawazza coffee employee told Zhiwei that the company had arranged for him to be on duty alone, but he refused.

He explained that this situation does exist, but it may be rare. After all, for brands that use semi-automatic coffee machines, the threshold for becoming a barista is relatively high, and it is common to have a shortage of staff. In addition, the business of the stores he encountered with only one person on duty was average, so the company made such arrangements.

According to several baristas, it is normal to be busy when running a shop and doing business, but the levels of scheduling, handling of sudden orders, and manpower dispatch vary among brands, which is why when arrangements are not made properly, the front-line baristas will be under pressure.

During the time Li Hang worked in Shanghai, he encountered numerous cases of oversupply. The company actually had a staff transfer system, “but the company couldn't transfer staff because other stores were also too busy and the total number of staff was insufficient.”

Li Hang added that he used to work for another coffee chain brand. “They have a system in the background, like a map, which can show the number of orders for each store. If they see that a store has more orders than people, they will flexibly transfer people there. The commuting expenses are directly reported to the regional manager and reimbursed normally.”

It takes Li Hang about 1-2 minutes to make a cup of coffee on Manner. Generally speaking, the estimated order time shown in the Manner mini program is also 2 minutes.

Li Hang said that when there is only one person on duty, these 2 minutes are enough, but the premise is that the number of orders is moderate.“Because one person has to greet guests, wipe the cups when they bring their own, and meet a few customers who place orders on the spot, and a few takeaway orders, it is easy to exceed the time limit.”

To put it bluntly, the fundamental reason is that there are not enough people. A barista working at Luckin Coffee said that the actual time it takes to issue an order is usually shorter than the estimated time, because the fully automatic coffee machines produce coffee quickly, and there are many people with clear division of labor.

On the one hand, companies want baristas to play multiple roles, requiring efficiency and good reviews. On the other hand, consumers are mostly people who have immediate functional needs for coffee, which is why more and more chain coffee brands are opening in office buildings and business districts.

When customers come to ask about their overdue orders, it is difficult for the barista to explain that the overtime is caused by insufficient staff, the system is not smart enough, or because they just washed a cup and wasted time.

In addition to the double-sided pressure, the promotion space for baristas in chain coffee brands is also extremely limited.

Junjun has worked in many coffee shops, and there are many baristas around her who have been working there longer. The fate that no one can escape is that they can only get promoted by changing jobs. “For example, if you work at Tim's for several years and you can't be promoted to store manager, you can become a store manager by changing jobs to Starbucks.” She said that many brands are like this, “one job for one person.” If they don't open a new store or the store manager of this store doesn't leave, the people below them won't be promoted.

In general, comparing coffee shops and tea shops, baristas seem to have higher skills requirements, and tea making seems to be more mechanical and assembly line-like. However, in the actual experience of baristas, the so-called skills are more like smokescreens, because the ceiling of chain coffee shops is too low. No matter how good they are at making latte art or how precise they are in controlling details such as the amount of water and temperature of beans, they cannot break through the menu set by the company and exercise any subjective initiative.

Skills will not expand in practice and become a killer weapon for the next job search, because the next time you apply for a job, you still have to memorize new formulas.

Wen Qi (pseudonym), a coffee industry practitioner, told Zhiwei that the general career path for a barista is apprentice, barista, store manager, regional manager, and general regional manager.

That is to say,For baristas who enter the industry based on their skills, their ultimate career destination is actually management.

Wenqi also said that the upward space for baristas is difficult to define, but generally not high. Even if you participate in competitions, it won’t help much, maybe the salary will be a little higher. The salary level of general baristas is relatively poor. “In Beijing, Shanghai and Guangzhou, a monthly income of more than 10,000 is already a medium to high level. The salary of a barista generally does not exceed 30% of the revenue.”

Manner, where Li Hang works, is already a company with good salary levels in the same industry, but he also said that he encountered a situation where there was no commission, only a basic salary, so he often doubted why he should continue to work in this industry.

Behind the collapse of baristas is the lack of solutions in chain stores

Almost every barista has encountered endless orders, difficult to erase customer complaints, or even face-to-face conflicts. Some baristas told us that they usually just pretend they can't hear them because they have too many orders and don't have time to argue.

In response to the top-down pressure from the company, baristas sometimes come up with their own “countermeasures”.

Junjun said that in order to ensure the efficiency of serving food, they often cancel orders in advance. “At that time, Tim's required that the serving time for an order should not exceed 5 minutes. If it was about to exceed the time limit, a red signal on the machine would start to remind you. This is a unified standard, no matter how much food the customer ordered.”

She explained that normally when the food is served, the waiter will scan the machine in the store to notify the customer, but when faced with a situation like this where the time limit is strict, they will scan in advance before the food is served.

“No matter how you explain to the customer that you scanned the code in advance, they only want the data.”

Before Li Hang resigned, he received several tickets that clearly stated “employee violation of discipline”. One of the reasons was “no cup message when serving” and the other was “no reminder of guests’ points”.

Moreover, among the three categories of general violation, relatively serious violation and severe violation, he was convicted of “severe violation” both times. According to him, he was not clear about the standards for general, relatively serious and severe violations.

Inevitably, a paradox arises in the coffee industry.

On one hand, coffee brands are pursuing the number of stores, brand scale, and product standardization, which is the pursuit of efficiency and return on investment. On the other hand, more and more brands want to be unique, using semi-automatic coffee machines, providing hand-brew, latte art, bring your own cup and other services, which is the pursuit of reputation and quality.

But the reality is that it seems difficult to have both without increasing manpower.

To resolve this contradiction, perhaps we cannot rely on the numbness of the store clerks, but need more efforts from the companies. Since we are pursuing efficiency and standardization, the improvement of the backend system, such as formulating a more efficient shift system and a more benign after-sales service channel, are all indispensable parts of the process of achieving standardization.

Manner, which is at the center of the storm, also opened up recruitment for “part-time baristas” this year. Sources close to Manner revealed to Zhiwei that part-time workers are mainly responsible for store takeout packaging, sanitation and cleaning, and customer reception. They do not participate in coffee making, and the proportion of part-time workers is very low.

Behind the collapse of baristas is the lack of solutions in chain stores
Manner Part-time Barista Recruitment Page

This is a solution, but its actual effect remains to be tested. In Li Hang's opinion, Manner's part-time hourly wage is high, with the highest hourly wage in Beijing, Shanghai and Shenzhen reaching 28 yuan, and in other cities such as Changsha and Nanchang, the hourly wage can reach around 20 yuan.

But he personally thinks that “it's not very meaningful” because in actual work, the main variable that causes orders to explode and timeouts is still the coffee making itself. It's just that handling other chores has prolonged the production time. It's not that saving this time can make more cups of coffee. “There is no good training for this part-time job, and I don't know how to do anything anyway.”

As for how to solve the problem, Li Hang said frankly: hire more full-time baristas.

In fact, it is difficult for chain coffee brands to raise labor costs. A coffee practitioner Xiang Zhiwei said that the technical barriers in the coffee industry do not lie in labor, not to mention that for chain brands that pursue economies of scale, the more stores they open, the more they need to control labor, because if there are thousands of stores across the country, and each store has too high technical requirements for people, it will be difficult to control.

In other words, chain coffee brands often set minimum standards when hiring baristas, and as long as they know the basic operating procedures, they can start working on the job.

Junjun also found that many brands are gradually relaxing their control over barista skills. “When I joined, I had a one-month training period, which was led by senior employees. After a month, there was an assessment, such as making 8 cups within 10 minutes. At that time, it was also required that the order of placing ingredients must not be wrong. Now many stores have begun to directly bring new employees to work, and they can learn on the job, without such assessments.”

Human resources are not that important in the coffee industry, but they bear the greatest pressure. Although they seem to be the most core job, they are actually just memorizing recipes and cannot participate in R&D work, and there is no clear promotion path.

One barista told us that he plans to try a few more chain brands, “and then start his own business, or take a class.”