What is “Alipay tap”? Does it require NFC? Finally figured it out

Hey guys, payment methods have reached the next level?

The thing is, these days, when I was browsing various social apps, I was flooded with the new “Touch on Alipay” feature. (hereinafter referred to as “Touch on Alipay”)

Different from the familiar QR code payment, after unlocking the phone, you can complete the payment by “touching” the back of the phone on the new device in just one step.

Some friends in Shanghai or Hangzhou may have already experienced it.

“It's too fast to rush to pay the bill.”

“People just opened their phone and you’ve already paid.”

What is “Alipay tap”? Does it require NFC? Finally figured it out

Amid the heated discussions among netizens and the media, I also discovered that since the introduction of QR code payment more than ten years ago and face recognition payment five or six years ago, the payment method seems to have not been so lively for a long time.

What is “Alipay tap”? Does it require NFC? Finally figured it out

At the same time, the Internet is also like a reincarnation, just like some netizens questioned the QR code payment. During this period, I also saw many netizens questioning Alipay's “touch and go”, including but not limited to:

“Isn't it just NFC? Isn't this just a leftover from transportation cards and access control?”

“If you lose your phone, won’t it be swiped by anyone?

“After that, will QR code payment still be usable?"

To be honest, I think that when faced with new things, everyone will have some doubts and concerns, which is actually quite reasonable.

So we followed the questions of netizens and carefully studied “Touch”, but found that this thing is actually not that simple, and everyone has some misunderstandings about it.

What is “Alipay tap”? Does it require NFC? Finally figured it out

First of all, I want to tell you a little-known fact that most of my friends don’t know:

“Touch” is actually the same as the familiar “scan”, both of which are a type of barcode payment.

I know this may seem hard to understand at first glance, after all, these two things don’t seem to have anything in common. . .

But after listening to the popular science of the bad reviewer, I can guarantee that next time you use “touch” to pay for your buddies at the midnight barbecue stall, you can have something to talk about and fill your cups.

What is “Alipay tap”? Does it require NFC? Finally figured it out

From my experience, “Scan” requires entering the Alipay App and opening the payment code, which takes 3 steps.

The “tap and go” feature allows you to pay by simply tapping your phone to the payment. This is quite different. (PS: Android phones only require one step, while Apple phones require you to click “open” to complete the payment after tapping.)

But from the perspective of information transmission, they are actually close friends. Because whether it is “scanning” or “touching”, it only serves the purpose of verification and does not transmit key payment information.

Because the actual payment occurs on the network side, it is a type of online payment, and in the financial industry standards, this is the same type, that is, barcode payment.

The essential difference between the two is that “Scan QR Code” uses the display and camera on the mobile phone, while “Touch” uses the NFC hardware on the mobile phone.

What is “Alipay tap”? Does it require NFC? Finally figured it out

But let's be honest, the “tap and pay” experience is indeed a bit too similar to NFC payment.

In fact, although they both share the same experience, they have different paths in terms of principles, inheritance and evolution. . .

The most essential difference between them is:“Tap and Go” does not store and transmit payment information through the phone's NFC.

Let's put it this way, in the mobile phone NFC payment mode, the bank card information is encrypted and stored locally on the mobile phone, and the payment information is transmitted to the POS machine via NFC when payment is made. The POS machine then sends a request to the bank to complete the payment, and the mobile phone does not need to be connected to the Internet.

Alipay's “touch and go” is different. The mobile phone does not store bank card information, nor does it transmit payment information via NFC. It just uses NFC to complete the “handshake” between the two devices, and the subsequent process is all done online.

Therefore, tap and hold payment and NFC payment follow different standards and belong to different categories.

What is “Alipay tap”? Does it require NFC? Finally figured it out

In addition, from the perspective of inheritance and evolution, “mobile phone NFC payment” originated from “bank card payment”. After upgrading from magnetic stripe bank cards to IC chip cards, payment can be made through card induction. The card information is stored in the mobile phone NFC card, which becomes mobile phone NFC payment.

“Touch and Pay” originated from barcode payment, which can be traced back to Internet payment. When the mobile network era came, it evolved into mobile payment, and user payment is equivalent to completing an online transfer.

What is “Alipay tap”? Does it require NFC? Finally figured it out

Having said that, I believe that smart friends also have a question in their minds.

That is, since the “tap and go” payment experience is exactly the same as NFC payment, isn’t Alipay reinventing the wheel by doing this?

If you have this free time, it would be much more meaningful to go to the Ant Forest and steal some energy.

In fact, Alipay is not just looking for trouble.

“Tap and Go” actually achieves many things that traditional NFC payments cannot do, and it is also the most suitable for our national conditions.

Remember what the bad reviewer mentioned earlier, that with “tap to pay”, Android only requires a tap, but does Apple require an extra step?

What is “Alipay tap”? Does it require NFC? Finally figured it out

This is actually Alipay’s fancy operation, which allows the “touch and go” function to support both Android and Apple phones.

Because traditional NFC payment is a “card simulation mode”, the bank card information is encrypted and stored in the mobile phone, the mobile phone simulates the card, and the POS machine reads the mobile phone.

However, the “card simulation mode” of Apple mobile phones is not open to the public. In China, the “card simulation mode” is dedicated to Apple Pay.

What is “Alipay tap”? Does it require NFC? Finally figured it out

Therefore, the Alipay “touch” performed a reverse operation and selected the “card reader mode”. The mobile phone simulated as a card reader, read the merchant's device information, and completed the “handshake”.

However, due to the limitations of the mobile phone system, it is still necessary to jump through Apple's system level, which is the “opening” step.

The Android system is open and has no system restrictions, so the experience is extremely fast.

In short, the number of active devices in China is about 20:80 for Android and iOS, with 950 million and 260 million users respectively. As a cross-platform third-party payment, Alipay must find a solution that can be used on both iOS and Android.

I have to say that the idea of ​​”tap and pay” is quite clever. And this is the only payment method on the market that uses a card reader.

What is “Alipay tap”? Does it require NFC? Finally figured it out

In addition, in the battle of mobile payments in China, barcode payment is more suitable for the Chinese market and ultimately won.

In fact, when mobile payment was first introduced, NFC technology was the hottest technology and the industry had high expectations for it.

However, mobile phones at that time did not have NFC components. So around 2010, China Telecom launched SIMpass, China Unicom and China Mobile launched RF-SIM cards, and so on.

Through the SIM card + NFC antenna module, mobile phones that do not originally have NFC chips can also be used for mobile payments.

At the same time, China's local third-party mobile payment is also exploring SMS payment, sound wave payment, and barcode payment.

In 2013, QR code payment began to be promoted in China. However, the debate on “choosing NFC or QR code payment” continued until 2016.

What is “Alipay tap”? Does it require NFC? Finally figured it out

Eventually, QR code scanning was used in every street corner across the country, bringing China's mobile payment coverage rate to 86%.

The reason is very simple. Although NFC has many advantages, it is still too high-brow for the market.

First, ten years ago, only a few flagship phones had NFC functionality. What many people don’t know is that it wasn’t until 2014 that Apple launched the first iPhone 6 with an NFC chip.

Secondly, compared with a QR code, NFC payment POS machines are too expensive and owners of street shops and roadside stalls cannot afford them.

What is “Alipay tap”? Does it require NFC? Finally figured it out

In addition to these, deeper reasons include payment rates and the financial system behind them.

China's mobile payment rates are now quite low. Thanks to the efforts of banks, payment companies, card organizations, clearing agencies and other parties, China's mobile payment rates are usually between 0.3% and 0.6%.

For small and micro businesses that just post a payment code to do business, the fee can be as low as zero.

Low payment rates have activated the vitality of the entire market. With the super popular QR code payment and ultra-low rates, China's mobile payment coverage has reached 86%.

What is “Alipay tap”? Does it require NFC? Finally figured it out

However, Apple Pay, which is popular abroad, is essentially still running on the existing POS card swiping system, and the comprehensive fee rate may be as high as 2%-3%. That is to say, when consumers pay $100, the merchant only gets $97-98.

The fee of $3 to $4 must be shared by the bank card organization, the issuing bank, the mobile NFC payment manufacturer, etc.

However, such rates are difficult for small domestic businesses to afford.

It seems that consumers do not have to pay for this money, but the wool comes from the sheep, and the final cost is still borne by the consumers.

What is “Alipay tap”? Does it require NFC? Finally figured it out

So this seemingly strange operation of Alipay solved all the pain points of NFC at once, which has to be said to be quite clever.

On the basis of the already wide coverage of QR code payment, the addition of NFC makes the experience even better. For example, the elderly do not need to spend five or six steps to find the payment code, they can just touch it and everything else remains unchanged.

As for security, payment is different from bus and subway. Whether it is barcode payment or NFC payment, verification and unlocking is an essential step.

“Tap and Pay” has the same security standards as QR code payment, and because the devices are very close to each other and payment information is not transmitted between devices, it cannot be seen by a third party like a QR code.

What is “Alipay tap”? Does it require NFC? Finally figured it out

Every payment requires an Internet connection to obtain a security token from the cloud, so both the user and the merchant need to be connected to the Internet, and there is also a risk control system to ensure security.

Alipay itself also has a promise to compensate in full for theft. Whether it is a merchant or a consumer, if there is financial loss, they can get compensation.

But do you think that tapping will replace QR codes? I don’t think so. Just posting a payment code to do business is still the most convenient option for many small shops.

But for places like supermarkets and chain stores, “touch and pay” quickly is indeed a better way.

In any case, it is definitely a good thing to let those companies do some complicated things and leave the simple things to users.