If we say that seven or eight years ago, the best-selling books on the Internet were “Addicted” and “Can't Stop”, which exposed how big companies use interactive design to make us addicted to mobile phones.In recent years, the popular trend has evolved into how to prevent minors from becoming addicted to social networks.
The New Yorker's long article “Can We Keep Our Kids Away from Social Networks?” went viral among parents. The famous psychologist Jonathan Haidt's new book “The Anxious Generation” topped the New York Times bestseller list. The subtitle of the book is: Excessive digitalization has led to an epidemic of mental illness among children. “Reshaping Children's Self-Control in the Screen Age” became a bestseller in education.
There are countless articles, books, and podcasts discussing how to keep children away from mobile phones and social networks, but when parents put down their books, they can see their children holding their mobile phones and wandering in the jungle of different social networks such as TikTok, Instagram, X, Snapchat, Twitch, Facebook, etc.
Jonathan Haidt, a psychologist who wrote “The Elephant and the Rider” and “The Righteous Mind”, has published a new book called “The Anxious Generation” | Source: Bookhub
The effect of spreading the word is certainly not as good as compulsory enforcement. Therefore, in the past two years, European and American countries have restricted minors' use of social media in all aspects.
Last month, the European Commission investigated Meta's “addictive” design of social networks. Previously, Instagram's algorithm was criticized for recommending posts containing child-sensitive content. Last year, the Utah state even passed legislation that from 2024, users under the age of 18 must obtain parental consent before they can open or use social media accounts. Similar bills are also being promoted in Connecticut and Ohio.
As we all know, the EU's investigation into Silicon Valley giants can take several years, and legislation is difficult to unify due to different situations in different states and countries. Moreover, not only in Europe and the United States, but also in the world, teenagers are facing psychological problems caused by social network addiction.
Therefore, the US Surgeon General could no longer sit still and was ready to propose a proposal to the US Congress:
Since “Smoking is harmful to your health” can be printed on cigarette boxes, can there also be a warning label on social media?
Is browsing social networks like smoking?
On June 17, Vivek Murthy, a U.S. physician and vice admiral of the Public Health Service and current U.S. Surgeon General, wrote an article in the New York Times calling on Congress to place warning labels on social media platforms.
This is not the first time Murthy has talked about this issue. Last year, he wrote a 23-page report titled “Social Media and Adolescent Mental Health” in a format similar to the “Dietary Guidelines for Residents”. It discussed the physical and mental harm of excessive use of social networks to teenagers from both theoretical and practical aspects, as well as how parents can formulate “house rules” for the use of digital devices.
Current U.S. Medical Director Vivek Murthy | Source: Brooking
However, this kind of message is like the popular articles in recent years, which are persuasive but not executable. As Murthy said at the beginning of the article, “One of the most important lessons I learned in medical school is that in an emergency, don't wait for perfect information. Evaluate the situation, use your best judgment, and act quickly.”
In Murthy's eyes, the mental health crisis of minors has become an urgent problem that needs to be solved. Therefore, he wrote directly to Congress, asking Congress to regulate social media like tobacco and alcohol. The first step is to add a doctor's warning label to social media.
This idea may seem abstract at first glance, but it is not without reason and theoretical support. Murthy's inspiration comes from a product that is also legal and addictive: cigarettes.
Image and text warning labels on American cigarette packages | Image source: FDA
According to the 2020 U.S. Public Health Service Report: Smoking Cessation, since 1965, the U.S. Congress has passed legislation requiring small text health warnings on cigarette packages. Today, many countries require health warning labels that are more than 50% of the cover size on cigarette packages.
Studies have shown that large graphic warnings can convey information more effectively than small text messages, increase people's awareness of the dangers of smoking, stimulate smokers' interest in quitting smoking, and thus reduce the prevalence of smoking.
Vivek Murthy's research team released the 2023 State of the Union Report. Source: The US Surgeon General's Advisory
However, smoking and drinking are behaviors that are medically proven to be harmful to the body. Is social media harmful to this extent?
According to data disclosed by the U.S. Health Resources and Services Agency, in 2019, 13% of adolescents reported a major depressive episode, a 60% increase from 2007. During this period, emergency room visits for children and adolescents also increased sharply due to anxiety, mood disorders and self-harm. According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, for people aged 10 to 24, the suicide rate remained stable from 2000 to 2007, but jumped nearly 60% in 2018. And the mental health of adolescents has been declining year by year since 2012.
The United States is not an isolated case. Scholars have investigated the rise in loneliness among teenagers in 37 countries from 2000 to 2018. The study shows that loneliness is related to the popularity of smartphones and the increase in Internet use. Studies have shown that where the use of smartphones and the Internet is high, teenagers also feel more lonely.
Although it cannot be said that these psychological problems are all caused by social media, these timings coincide with the rise of social media and mobile Internet.
Murthy believes that school buses are very safe, and any food safety issues in schools will attract widespread attention. However, the negative impact of social media on the psychology of teenagers has not been taken seriously. Therefore, he chose to use one of the most powerful tools available to the country's top health officials: asking Congress to add warning labels to social media.
However, social media is not a physical entity like cigarettes and alcohol. It exists in a virtual and dynamic form on different platforms and terminals. If we really want to “label” it, how should we design it?
How to implement social warnings?
Fast Company called together four well-known digital design studios, PXP, BBH, Metalab and Huge, and asked them to design a “universal” warning label for social media. The four studios approached the issue from different angles, and their solutions were also unique.
The four studios can be divided into two factions: simple and crude static reminders and dynamic presentation based on user psychology.
PXP's design is very direct, with a large pop-up warning on the screen. Their idea is very simple. Since the warning labels on cigarette boxes are useful, they should directly transfer the black and white text to social media. Users must face these problems directly. And since accidentally clicking on pop-up ads on social media can jump to the purchase interface, the warning label should also jump to the “help” interface with one click.
Black and white words are indeed very intimidating|Source: PHP
BBH had a similar idea. They took the classic nuclear warning symbol and replaced the nuclear proliferation symbol with a Wi-Fi signal proliferation symbol, with a globe in the middle to show that social media is all over the world and the psychological problems it creates are not limited to any country. Another logo they designed was based on the FBI copyright warning in the DVD.
Two warning pop-ups designed by BBH | Source: BBH
The other two studios are more meticulous. They try to capture the user's psychology when using the product and then prescribe the right medicine.
“We discovered those moments when using social media that would trigger negative emotions in people, and at that moment we reminded users not to take them seriously and get caught up in them.” This is Metalab's idea. They want to present a “tip” before each “key operation” of the user.
For example, before users click on the glamorous web celebrity page, a pop-up message will appear saying, “Please be empathetic. You are seeing other people's highlights, not their daily lives. Don't be too harsh on your own life” or “Everyone has struggles that are not shown online. Please be kind to yourself.” The user must click “Continue” before the content is displayed. Or when the user is typing a comment, a pop-up message will appear saying, “Your words are meaningful. Please be polite.”
Metalab wants to use these reminders that just happen to appear to transform the user's possible “one thought to become a devil” into “one thought to become a Buddha”, and turn hostility into virtue.

Metalab's design | Source: Metalab
Huge Studio grasps the psychology of teenagers. They believe that no teenager wants to be told what to do, and harsh reminders will only make them feel guilty, rebellious and even rebellious.
They chose to use stronger bold fonts with warmer tones, and after teenagers have been swiping their phones for a long time, they swiped to the warning screen smoothly, and the interaction required users to swipe down slowly many times before they could slide away the warning. No preaching, just obstacles and friendly reminders.
Huge's design | Source: Huge
No matter how it is designed, the digital native generation will never put down their mobile phones. Therefore, the primary responsibility for how to design “non-addictive” for them, how to regulate content, and how to control algorithms may need to be borne by Silicon Valley giants themselves, rather than directly pushing it to parents, non-governmental organizations, or even relying on legislation for rough enforcement.
“One of the worst things for parents is knowing that their children are in danger, but being unable to do anything about it. Parents can't buckle up and put on helmets for invisible dangers. They are trying to fight the best product designers and the most resourceful companies in the world alone,” Murthy said. This statement also echoes the words of Tristan Harris, a former Google design ethicist, “The smartest people in the world are gathered in Silicon Valley, trying to keep you staring at the screen.”
The platforms only consider commercial interests and will not take responsibility unless they are constrained. The harmfulness of social media has only spread from Facebook and Twitter to Instagram, which is mainly based on pictures and texts, and then to short video platforms that are more likely to be addictive.
On these platforms, minors may be exposed to online harassment, verbal bullying, or extreme violence and sexual content driven by algorithms. The content does not need to consider who is watching behind the screen, it will only be displayed endlessly in the waterfall. Those glamorous and beautiful places that teenagers cannot reach in the closed campus are processed through filters, subtly changing the dreams of teenagers from scientists to Internet celebrities.
In this light, putting a warning label on social media seems a bit mild.
If we want to fundamentally solve the problem of social media addiction, we still have to give the ball back to big companies.





