The radish runners can't even get the job of driver

Recently, the discussion about Carrot Run has been gaining popularity on major platforms. At the same time, the discussion about Carrot Run has gradually extended to driverless cars and triggered discussions on social topics such as “taxi/online car-hailing drivers being replaced.”

In just a few days, public opinion fermented layer by layer, some exaggerated and even wrong information began to be mixed in, and public sentiment and traffic were greatly incited. Huxiu Auto believes that before hotly discussing technology changing society, people need to have an objective grasp and analysis of the current facts.

Fragmented communication fuels the fire and carrots run away

After sorting out recent hot events, it was found that the hot topics of public opinion mainly focused on topics such as “the number of orders for Luobo Kuaipao exceeds 6 million”, “Wuhan has invested more than 1,000 driverless cars”, “taxis/online ride-hailing cars will be replaced”, and “Luobo Kuaipao collided with pedestrians in Wuhan”.

But the problem is that these events do not occur continuously, but they break out in the public opinion field at the same time, which inevitably leads to some factors of human processing and dissemination.

On July 9, news about “LuoBo KuaiPao's booming orders” began to appear in various media channels. Headlines such as “1,000 driverless cars have been put into use in Wuhan, with a total of 6 million orders received” and “The proportion of driverless orders in Wuhan has reached 45%” appeared in various media.

But in fact, most of these data are historical data, and some of the data have no causal relationship. When they are spread as headlines, they begin to change.

According to Huxiu Auto, there are currently only more than 400 Carrot Run vehicles in Wuhan, and it is planned to increase the number of vehicles to 1,000 by 2024 (but it has not yet been fully deployed).

The data of “6 million orders” comes from Baidu's first quarter financial report of 2024, which points out that as of April 19, 2024, Luobo Kuaipao has provided more than 6 million orders of autonomous driving travel services to the public.But this is the cumulative number of orders for LoBo Express's manned test operation services in 11 cities (starting from November 2021), not just Wuhan.

In addition, “the proportion of fully unmanned driving orders in Wuhan reaches 45%” is not compared with the travel order volume in Wuhan, but the orders for Baidu Luobo Kuaipao's fully unmanned vehicles, which account for 45% of all Luobo Kuaipao's unmanned driving orders.

With all the impressive data, driverless cars do not seem like a far-fetched technological achievement, but rather a popular product that is just around the corner. While all parties are cheering for it, another voice begins to emerge.

Wuhan taxi drivers complain about their jobs being taken away

A document dated June 20 and titled “Cruising taxis are on the brink of death” was uncovered online, sparking panic about “driverless taxis replacing online ride-hailing vehicles.” Other topics that fermented at the same time included “Caribbean taxis colliding with pedestrians” and “Caribbean taxis obstructing traffic.”

When Luobo Kuaipao became related to social issues related to people's livelihood, it once again attracted public attention, triggering even greater attention and heated discussions, and the direction of public opinion gradually extended to the social impact of driverless cars.

Statistics show that the daily peak number of orders for Luobo Kuaipao exceeds 20, which is close to the number of orders for online ride-hailing vehicles/taxis. The number of orders for the latter two is gradually decreasing, and voices are beginning to emerge that “the jobs of taxis and online ride-hailing vehicles are at risk.”

But the question is, Luobu Kuaipao has been providing commercial services in Wuhan for nearly two years. Why has it become a public opinion anchor at this time?

“Recently, college students in Wuhan are on summer vacation, so the number of orders has decreased a lot. In addition, Luobo Kuaipao has offered many preferential measures. Cars operated by Luobo Kuaipao are cheaper than online-hailing cars and taxis, making it even harder to receive orders.” Mr. Liu, a Didi driver in Wuhan, told Huxiu Auto.

The author tried taking a ride on Luobo Kuaipao in Wuhan in May this year. Compared with the prices of online car-hailing services, the fare of Luobo Kuaipao was nearly half the price during the same period and for the same distance.

The above-mentioned person also pointed out that “last year we could handle 25-35 orders a day, but now we can only handle less than 20 orders a day.” He also said that online ride-hailing cars can basically guarantee the number of orders with the support of platform dispatching orders, but taxis mainly rely on offline cruising to receive orders. In recent years, the number of orders has been reduced due to the influence of online ride-hailing cars. In addition, since this year, Luobo Kuaipao has expanded its operating area in Wuhan, making it even harder for taxi drivers to make money.

The reason why the car-hailing app has caused dissatisfaction among drivers is that it has affected traffic. “It drives too slowly, and it will stop when there are pedestrians or electric vehicles next to it, which will cause traffic jams during rush hours in the morning and evening,” said the online car-hailing driver. In his opinion, this is the core reason for the dissatisfaction among drivers.

Due to the incidents such as “LuoBoKuaiPao turned around and stopped in the middle of the road” and “Two LuoBoKuaiPao cars met on a narrow road and could not give way to each other”, LuoBoKuaiPao is known as “Spoon LuoBo” in Wuhan, which means silly radish.

The radish runners can't even get the job of driver
In the video circulating online, two radish cars met on a narrow road and refused to give way to each other

From the car wash to the discussions on industry and social issues it triggered, the long-silent driverless cars have once again become the focus of public opinion. Among them, there are people who cheer for the implementation of new technologies as well as critics and panickers. However, in this wave of public opinion, driverless cars have once again stood at the center of the topic.

A Wuhan resident told the author that there is a stop for Luobo Kuaipao 1.2 kilometers away from his workplace. He and his colleagues have never tried it before, but with the recent news, some people around him are eager to try it.

Carrot runners may be more anxious than drivers

Although driverless taxis have become popular, judging from the current number of driverless taxis providing commercial services, they are still unable to take away the jobs of ride-hailing and taxi drivers.

Wuhan is the region with the largest number of LuoBoKuaiPao investments and the widest operating range. The Wuhan Demonstration Zone has 491 autonomous driving vehicles in regular operation. However, compared with the average daily number of 29,400 online-hailing vehicles in Wuhan (data disclosed by the Wuhan Transportation Bureau in May), the deployment ratio of LuoBoKuaiPao is less than 2%.

According to official data, Luobo Kuaipao has currently opened manned test operation services in 11 cities, and carried out fully unmanned autonomous driving travel service tests in Beijing, Wuhan, Chongqing, Shenzhen and Shanghai.

Another autonomous driving company, Pony.ai, has launched commercial operations in the four first-tier cities of Beijing, Shenzhen, Guangzhou and Shanghai, with a total of nearly 300 autonomous vehicles. Data shows that the total number of traditional taxis and online ride-hailing vehicles in Beijing, Shanghai, Guangzhou and Shenzhen alone can reach about 300,000 units, and the current number of driverless taxis does not even account for 1% of the market share.

What's more, manufacturers including Luobo Kuaipao and Pony.ai can only obtain licenses for test operations in limited areas, and are not officially operating vehicles. In addition, in actual applications, self-driving taxis have fixed stops and only support point-to-point connections, which will have a certain impact on the service experience.

However, even if driverless taxis are not large in size, they can still cause panic in the travel service market, which actually reflects the anxiety of the travel market.

In the first half of this year, many places across the country issued risk warnings for the online car-hailing industry, saying that the capacity of online car-hailing has been saturated, far exceeding actual demand, and publicly reminded people to be cautious in entering the online car-hailing industry. Data from transportation management departments show that the average daily number of orders received by online car-hailing vehicles in many places does not exceed 20 orders, and the average revenue per order is around 20 yuan, with the average daily income per vehicle being only more than 200 yuan.

Against the backdrop of saturated transportation capacity, driverless taxis that came out with subsidies further squeezed the market.Self-driving taxis have not yet reached a point of profitability.

Even though the cost of the sixth-generation Baidu Apollo model has dropped from 500,000 to 200,000, it is still some distance away from achieving true profitability. (Huxiu Auto once made an analysis in the article “Has Baidu settled the Apollo account?”)

Taking the operation of LuoBoKuaiPao in Wuhan as an example, the estimated data shows that the current operating cost of Apollo's fifth-generation driverless taxi in Wuhan is about 471 yuan, including the safety officer fee, charging fee, car washing, operation and maintenance fee, etc. On the revenue side, LuoBoKuaiPao App shows that the subsidy for orders within 5 kilometers in Wuhan Economic Development Zone is about 5 yuan. Calculated based on an average of 20 orders per day, the daily turnover of an unmanned vehicle is only 100 yuan.

It should be pointed out that although it is a driverless car, it is still equipped with a safety officer in the background. Data shows that the ratio of safety officers taking over in Wuhan has increased from 1:4 last year to 1:10 (that is, one safety officer monitors 10 cars).

An autonomous driving industry practitioner once told Huxiu Auto that some regions will have clear takeover requirements. For example, Guangdong requires a safety takeover of 1:3. However, if long-term profitability is to be achieved, it is estimated that the takeover ratio must at least reach 1 to control several dozen.

In addition, Robotaxi that enters the operation stage needs to update high-precision maps on a monthly basis, which also involves huge cost expenditures.

Taking various factors into consideration, the current driverless taxis only operate in limited areas. Compared with the entire travel service market, this scale is not enough to gain dominance in market competition.

There is no doubt that driverless cars are the trend of travel, but there are still many problems to be solved before they can be commercialized on a large scale.

Autonomous driving cannot achieve success overnight

“After discussing Robotaxi with friends in the AI/mobility/L4 industry, my conclusion is that the capabilities, regulations, and commercial closed loop are not there yet. The reason why people say they will break even soon is because they haven't calculated a lot of things.” When the popularity of Robotaxi was high, He Xiaopeng, chairman of Xpeng Motors, came out to express his views.

The radish runners can't even get the job of driver
The picture is taken from He Xiaopeng's Weibo

Basically, the three aspects pointed out by He Xiaopeng are exactly the major factors that hinder driverless taxis.

First, let’s look at the capabilities. Currently, Robotaxi has proven its unmanned driving capabilities, but the intelligent driving route of a single vehicle cannot meet the needs of large-scale city-level autonomous driving. However, to promote the implementation of a larger scale, the construction of “vehicle-road-cloud integration” is needed.

This is a huge project, and the transformation and completion of infrastructure cannot be achieved overnight.

The latest development is that the Ministry of Industry and Information Technology and five other departments have announced a list of pilot cities for the application of “vehicle-road-cloud integration” for intelligent connected vehicles, including 20 cities (consortiums) such as Beijing, Shanghai, and Chongqing, which have entered the planning stage for large-scale implementation.

In addition, the division of responsibilities and powers in the actual application of driverless driving is also a core issue.

Just this month, the “collision accident between Luobo Kuaipao and a pedestrian who ran a red light in Wuhan” once again triggered heated discussions on the definition of rights and responsibilities. Regarding “how to define the responsibility of driverless cars”, the current domestic regulations are mostly based on local regulations, and a complete set of national regulations has not yet been established.

Whether it is the “Regulations on the Management of Intelligent Connected Vehicles in Shenzhen Special Economic Zone” issued by Shenzhen in 2022, or the “Hangzhou Regulations on Promoting the Testing and Application of Intelligent Connected Vehicles” officially implemented in May this year, they are both local regulations.

In addition, Beijing, Wuhan and other places have also begun to issue relevant drafts for comments, aiming to clarify the rights and responsibilities of driverless cars from a legal perspective. For example, the recently released “Beijing Autonomous Driving Vehicle Regulations (Draft for Comments)” points out that if a traffic violation occurs while an autonomous driving car is on the road, the public security traffic management department will handle and identify it in accordance with the current laws and regulations. If there is a driver in the car, the driver will be dealt with in accordance with the law; if there is no driver in the car, the vehicle owner and manager will be dealt with.

Although local regulations are increasing, a simple division of powers and responsibilities is obviously unable to meet the complex real-world traffic scenarios. If driverless cars are to truly move towards larger-scale applications, the issue of responsibility will always be an unavoidable threshold. Of course, this requires more case law accumulation and extensive discussion.

Whether it is the investment in new infrastructure or the liberalization of autonomous driving at the policy level and the regulation at the regulatory level, these are all factors that need to be promoted simultaneously with the evolution of autonomous driving. It is enough to see that the spring of autonomous driving has not really arrived yet.

However, the online popularity caused by Luobo Kuaipao has brought the L4 autonomous driving, which had been dormant, back into the public eye. With high attention from all walks of life, it is worth looking forward to whether the story of autonomous driving will undergo new changes.