Tencent is ready to turn the table: “breaking up” with Android channels

Tencent has taken a crucial step in “breaking” with the Android channel.

On June 19, the official announcement of “Dungeon & Fighter: Origins” stated that starting from June 20, the DNF mobile game will no longer be available on the app stores of some Android platforms.

“The DNF mobile game operation team stated that the game will be withdrawn from the app stores of mobile phone manufacturers such as Huawei, OPPO, and vivo, and the mobile game package will be stopped; especially for the vivo app store, the download channel of DNF has been closed.”


Announcement screenshot

To be honest, Tencent rarely appears in the public eye as a “dragon slayer”. This time, it stood on the developer's side and confronted the “Hardcore Alliance” (a “mobile Internet value-added service organization” composed of eight domestic Android mobile phone manufacturers including Huawei, Lenovo, OPPO, vivo, Coolpad, Gionee, Meizu, and Nubia), which really won goodwill.

The reason why Tencent “turned the table” this time is:

For a long time, the “Hardcore Alliance” has traditionally taken a 50% commission from game developers, and Tencent's “new ace” DNF mobile game has shown a money-making ability far beyond expectations. Sensor Tower data shows that in the 11 days since its launch on May 21, DNF mobile game's revenue in the domestic iOS market has exceeded the sum of “Honor of Kings” and “Peace Elite” revenue, and monthly turnover may reach 5 billion, making Tencent Games' mobile revenue in May achieve a 12% increase, and it has been at the top of the domestic iPhone best-selling list for 30 consecutive days.

Tencent is naturally reluctant to think that half of the profits of the new “cash cow” will be taken away by the “Hardcore Alliance” in the future game cycle – as X.D. CEO Huang Yimeng commented:

Tencent is ready to turn the table:
Screenshot of X.D. Inc. CEO Huang Yimeng's social media account

“The domestic Android channels are really disgusting. Not only will half of the revenue be taken away from them, but their official website packages will also be replaced with channel packages that need to be shared during installation. It is better to just remove them from the shelves and only use the official website.”

“Our company's Let's Go Muffin can be ranked fourth in sales even without going through the channels. DNF, which is firmly ranked first in sales, will not be under any pressure. There is no need for Honor of Kings and Game for Peace to go through the channels either, and there is no reason to give channels a share of the profits.”

There aren't many businesses that make money by doing nothing.

In fact, before Tencent openly turned against the “Hardcore Alliance” this time, the issue of “channel sharing” was brought up for discussion in the gaming circle every now and then – because this matter was indeed too outrageous.

The outside world has always criticized the game industry for being a highly profitable industry, but as a creative industry, there is a serious survivor bias. The success of a game requires the right time, place, people, and some accidental factors. There are far more failed products and teams that leave in disgrace than successful ones. The channels will take 50% of all games, and after deducting the payment channel fees, the actual revenue received by the game manufacturers is less than 50%.

Tencent is ready to turn the table:

That is to say,Game manufacturers bear huge costs and risks, and finally come up with a game, but half of the profit is first sucked away by the channels without any guarantee. It is hard for anyone to accept this.

In view of this, there are often news reports about game manufacturers and distribution channels falling out in the gaming industry. Although the complaints of small and medium-sized manufacturers and independent game developers against distribution channels often fail to stir up topics, several well-known game manufacturers have also made quite a stir in the past two years:

In February 2021, NetEase CEO Ding Lei publicly blasted the “Android tax” as high as 50%, which is 20% more expensive than Apple, the most expensive in the world, and is very detrimental to the industry ecosystem;

In January 2021, Tencent and Huawei openly fell out over the issue of channel sharing;

In August 2020, Apple was sued by the developer Epic Games for removing “Fortnite” from its App Store.

Tencent is ready to turn the table:

So, how did the channel practice of taking high commissions from customers and ensuring a stable income come about?

If we trace back, the first generation of game consoles, XBOX, PSN, and Nintendo, were indeed free, but the three major manufacturers soon surrendered their weapons and joined the ranks of charging without hesitation after competing with their competitors under the banner of free. One very important reason is thatGame servers and platform maintenance are extremely expensive, and only by taking commissions can the business model be closed. Only by surviving can we talk about ecological construction.

Of course, the commission ratio that channels take from game manufacturers is also a science: if they charge too much, the manufacturers can't bear it; if they charge too little, the proliferation of junk games will backfire on the platform – in the end, after years of bargaining between game manufacturers and channels, the 30% threshold has gradually become the critical point for the symbiosis and prosperity of both parties.

In this regard, Zhihu author @Mendel further added:

“After Sony dominated the gaming industry, gaming platforms generally took 30% of the royalties + production and wholesale, 30% of the retailer's profit, 30% of the publisher's profit, and the remaining 10% fluctuated according to various factors. Developers split the revenue with publishers from this 30%. Sony and Microsoft also follow this model for digital version revenue sharing, which is equivalent to helping manufacturers save the retailers' share.”

Since then, in addition to AppStore and Google Play abroad, which share a 30% profit margin, Valve's Steam, Poland's CD Projekt Red's GOG, Microsoft's WIN10 Store, Ubisoft's uPlay, EA's Origin, and Blizzard's Battle.net all abide by the 30% profit margin standard – this has gradually evolved into an industry practice.

However, this model completely changed when it was introduced to China – domestic channels increased the commission rate and reduced platform responsibility.

In the era when “channels are king” (Apple has the final say on IOS, so let's not talk about that for now), there were many players sharing the Android market share, from 360, 91 Mobile Assistant, App Store to Huawei, Xiaomi, and OV, which came later, all of them made a lot of money without doing anything – in order to compete for limited channel resources, mobile game manufacturers even took the initiative to reduce the revenue share from 37% to 55% or 82%, making the Chinese game industry a buyer's market for channel dealers, and the channel's voice has been repeatedly raised.

finally,The mainstream revenue sharing ratio of the Android channel is maintained at 50% each for manufacturers and channels; but in reality, the final revenue received by domestic game manufacturers is less than 50%.

The reasons are: first, the major app stores have to deduct channel fees before taking their 50% commission; second, domestic game manufacturers have to deal with SDKs (software development kits) from various channels and frequently changing interface protocols – if they are stubborn and don't go through the channels, their games will be cracked until they are drained of the last drop of blood by pirated copies.

The key issue is thatDomestic Android channels have only learned the high commission rates from foreign countries, but have failed to see that Apple and Google’s commission rules have, in a certain sense, acted as environmental purifiers, blocking a large number of junk games from small companies from entering the ecosystem, thus ensuring the quality of applications and the stability of the ecosystem.

As a result, during the period of 2014-2018 when the mobile game industry was booming, thousands of mobile games of varying quality emerged on the market every year.

In other words, under the hegemony of channel commissions, games have become nothing more than a tool for “traffic monetization” – the channel's review and management of listed games and services are non-existent. Games with questionable quality and lack of distribution capabilities such as “one hit for 999 yuan” and “come and kill me if you're a brother” often promote and divert traffic at no cost. After players enter the pit, they will only guide them to recharge to become stronger. The customer service is non-existent. If there is a real problem, the game will be taken off the shelves and then put on a new vest to continue online.

The result of this vicious cycle is that small domestic game companies are struggling to survive, and even if they have a hit product, they are still working for the channels.

Channel discourse power is being reconstructed

Today, game manufacturers dare to frequently challenge channel dealers, largely due to the huge changes in the industry landscape.

At the macro level, since the full implementation of the game license policy in 2019, the number of games that have passed the review has dropped sharply. Under the background of total quantity regulation, the entire game industry has entered a stock competition for high-quality products after nearly eight years (2012-2020) of extensive development.

Then, reducing channel share naturally becomes a breakthrough for game manufacturers to save money, and it is even an important operational decision that must be considered.

Tencent is ready to turn the table:

In this regard, a game publisher analyzed to Huxiu:

“In the past, traffic efficiency magnified the channel advantages of mobile phone manufacturers, and the revenue brought by the channel overshadowed the traffic investment; now, the quota of game licenses and the trend of high-quality products will further weaken the voice of channels.”

Huxiu has communicated with several game practitioners and found that many people believe that it is time to change the channel's passive income model. At least they should sit down and renegotiate the profit sharing ratio and further clarify the responsibilities and obligations of the channel.

The ideal situation is that, as the two sides bargain and negotiate, the channel can make concessions on tiered revenue sharing based on the turnover and user base of specific products – that is, when a certain level is reached, the revenue will be shared according to a new ratio, so that the revenue sharing between game manufacturers and channels is in a dynamic bargaining process.

In this regard, Guosen Securities Research Report pointed out:

“As the mobile Internet enters a new stage of development, user behavior has changed from 'search' to 'recommendation'. Traditional app stores are squeezed by both users and high-quality developers. The demonstration effect of top games may drive more content providers to 'resist', and the bargaining power of high-quality content will continue to increase.”

At the micro level, the gaming industry is moving from “channel is king” to “content is king”, and good products are gradually weakening the dominance of traditional channels. In particular, in the past two years, there have been many products that refused to use Android channels and achieved impressive market results.

Tencent is ready to turn the table:
Battle screen of the game “Mingchao”

To take recent examples, Kuro Technology's “Mingchao”, miHoYo's “Honkai Impact 3rd”, and NetEase's “All-Star Streetball Party” all refused to be released on the Android channel, but their speed in rushing to the top of the market and the level of discussion on social platforms were undoubtedly at their peak.

Going back further, “Genshin Impact”, “Arknights”, “Pascal's Wager”, “A Hundred Scenes of Jiangnan”, and “Rise of Kingdoms” have all successively abandoned Android channels and turned to TapTap, Bilibili, Douyin, etc. These products not only have an upward data curve, but also have become benchmark cases in the subdivided categories.

Tencent is ready to turn the table:
Battle scene of the game “Arknights”

The deeper reason is thatNew game manufacturers represented by MiHoYo are unwilling to use Android channels. In addition to saving 50% of the commission, it can also prevent the channel from diverting product users.

“In early 2021, there was a saying that 'the whole country in the gaming industry should learn from Shanghai'. At that time, game manufacturers were actively imitating the product management model of emerging game manufacturers such as Lilith and Paper Games, that is, how to bypass channels and settle core users under product IP.” A practitioner told Huxiu.