Anaheim in Southern California is the location of Disney's first theme park. VidCon, the Internet celebrity conference for the online video industry, is held here every year.Many executives and top influencers from YouTube, TikTok and Instagram will gather here.
At this year's VidCon conference, Instagram held a birthday party and invited many creators to celebrate. They ordered a beautifully crafted chocolate cake with a ribbon to celebrate the first anniversary of the official launch of their social media platform Threads.
This social media product that Zuckerberg used to backstab Musk has been online for a year. Threads was originally a “Twitter killer” created by Meta, which was intended to take advantage of the platform chaos after Musk's acquisition and launch a wave of surprise attacks in the social media field to poach Twitter's advertisers and users.
One year after its launch, how is this “Twitter killer” doing? Has it brought any substantial impact to Twitter, which has been renamed X?
Twitter Killer is growing slowly
Zuckerberg announced on Threads earlier this month that the platform has more than 175 million monthly active users. “What a great year,” Zuckerberg said after announcing the data. He has 4.3 million followers on the platform, and each message has more than 1,000 comments on average.
Zuckerberg, the social networking giant, is not an active social user. In May, he only posted one update on Instagram, and only two in June, which is significantly lower than the update frequency on Instagram. There, each of his updates easily receives more than 10,000 comments, and his number of followers exceeds 14 million.
On the Fourth of July, Zuckerberg posted a video on Instagram of himself wearing a suit, sunglasses, drinking beer, holding an American flag and water skiing. This funny-looking video received over a million likes and nearly 30,000 comments on Instagram. But he didn't post anything on Threads, and he didn't even bother to sync it.
Off topic, Zuckerberg and his family have been living on Kauai Island in Hawaii since the pandemic, where they invested nearly $300 million to buy a corner of the island and built themselves a super luxury house with a bunker. They only return to Silicon Valley when work requires it. He rarely goes to his mansion in San Francisco because there are always protesters outside the door. Although Zuckerberg and his wife donated hundreds of millions of dollars to San Francisco, the left-wing people there do not like them, and the city council even publicly condemned Zuckerberg in 2020.
Unlike Musk, who has several private jets on standby, Zuckerberg does not have his own private jet, and Meta spends more than $2 million a year to rent a plane for him. Zuckerberg is the world's most life-conscious billionaire, and Meta spends $20 million a year on the security of his entire family, which is several times more than other business leaders.
Back to the topic, compared to Musk who spends almost all day and night on Twitter, if even Zuckerberg is not interested in Threads, how much motivation does this “Twitter killer” have to attract users? Although 175 million monthly active users seem to be good data, an increase of 25 million in the past three months, compared to the parent platform Instagram's more than 2.4 billion monthly active users, this is even just a tiny fraction.
Moreover, most of Threads’ users are diverted to the platform through Instagram. After the launch of Threads, Instagram has been pushing users to download and use this new platform. Users do not even need to register. They can log in and import social relationships with one click using their Instagram account. Until now, there are still recommendations for diversion from Theads in Instagram’s information flow.
In May this year, Musk announced that the X platform has more than 600 million monthly active users worldwide, and nearly 300 million daily active users. Since X is already a private company, they do not need to publish operating data on a regular basis. Before Musk's acquisition in 2022, Twitter's official monthly active users were less than 400 million.
However, third-party web analytics company Emarketer predicts thatAt the end of last year, X had only 56 million monthly active users in the US market, while Threads had 29 million, which means that X's user base in the US is less than twice that of Threads.
Maza's ten-year personal grudge
The background of Threads is the intensification of personal grievances between Zuckerberg and Musk. As we all know, Musk is a business leader who speaks without restraint and often mocks super-rich people such as Bezos and Gates. Zuckerberg is the Silicon Valley elite that he despises the most.

No one knows exactly why Musk hates Zuckerberg so much. The two seemed to have no conflict at the beginning. Musk made electric cars and rockets, and Zuckerberg made social networks. The two were even each other's users: Musk was a loyal user of Instagram and often posted his beautiful photos here; Facebook also hired SpaceX to launch its own ground network satellites (this business has been abandoned).
Musk began to publicly mock Zuckerberg because more than a decade ago, Google and Facebook competed to invest in the development of artificial intelligence, and Musk has publicly questioned the safety of this technology, worrying that it may lead to the destruction of mankind. Therefore, he co-founded the non-profit organization OpenAI with many Silicon Valley people, and repeatedly pointed out that Facebook should not blindly pursue profits and develop technology.
Most of the time, Zuckerberg rarely hit back at Musk, unwilling to get involved in a war of words, or perhaps he is not good at arguing with Musk online. Zuckerberg hit back without naming him, saying he didn't understand why there were always irresponsible people exaggerating doomsday theories. Musk, in turn, said disdainfully that Zuckerberg knew too little about artificial intelligence.
After Facebook was caught in a user data leak crisis in 2018, Musk even announced that he and Tesla would abandon the Facebook platform. He stepped on Zuckerberg at the time when he was at his most anxious. In Musk's own words, he just hated Facebook.
Musk's favorite social platform is undoubtedly Twitter, and he is almost a heavy Internet addict. Due to his extreme dissatisfaction with Twitter's management and platform rules, at the end of 2022, he spent almost double the premium and spent $44 billion to acquire the social media giant Twitter, starting his own drastic transformation process and officially becoming Zuckerberg's direct competitor.
However, Musk's reform of Twitter has brought great shock to the platform. In just two months, he reduced Twitter's employees from 7,500 to only 1,800; launched a paid certification blue V service, but it led to the rampant fake accounts; in the name of freedom of speech, he restored tens of thousands of accounts that were banned for controversial speech. And his many controversial remarks and actions have also angered a large number of liberal netizens and mainstream media. Finally, Musk even changed the name of Twitter to X, completely completing his reform.
The direct impact of Musk's Twitter overhaul was that a large number of advertisers stopped placing ads on Twitter, and left-wing users, media people, and intellectuals chose to leave. Although Musk himself lamented last year that Twitter's advertising revenue had lost half, he was so angry that he couldn't control his emotions and even cursed in public, asking advertisers represented by Disney to get out.
Although a large number of celebrities and netizens have flocked to social platforms similar to Twitter, such as Mastodon and Bluesky, these niche platforms are not comparable to Twitter in terms of size and influence, and cannot bring any impact to Twitter's market position. Mastodon has only 2 million monthly active users, which is completely different from Twitter's 350 million monthly active users at the time.
Twitter killers are here
Threads was born in this context. Zuckerberg is very good at attacking and imitating his rivals. Over the past decade, Facebook has repeatedly launched products similar to its rivals, trying to poach users, creators and advertisers. From Snapchat to TikTok to Twitter, all have been attacked by him.
When Twitter was at its most precarious, Zuckerberg launched Threads in July last year, attempting to create a new social media platform. This is a missing piece in the Meta social network matrix: Facebook is a social platform for acquaintances, Instagram is a photo social business, and Threads is a text-based public social media.

Musk, who was attacked, continued to humiliate and mock Zuckerberg on Twitter, while arranging Twitter to sue Instagram for infringing its technology patents by hiring laid-off Twitter employees to develop products. Zuckerberg also activated his Twitter account, which had been abandoned for more than ten years, and only posted a picture of “Spider-Man vs. Spider-Man”, which seemed to be a silent mockery of Musk.
Backed by Instagram's inherent advantages, Threads quickly gained user recognition after its launch. According to data provided by Zuckerberg, within less than a day of its launch, Threads had more than 30 million users, and within five days of its launch, it had more than 100 million users, setting a record for user growth for new social products. Of course, the key reason is that Threads does not need to acquire new users.
More importantly, Threads has directly imported tens of thousands of celebrities on Instagram, including talk show queen Oprah Winfrey, pop queen Taylor Swift and other top celebrities who have settled in this Instagram platform; they also brought their fans from Instagram to Threads.
Twitter, as a public platform, has long been plagued by malicious comments. This is also the main reason why many celebrities left Twitter and focused on Instagram. After Musk took over and significantly relaxed the content control standards, this problem has worsened. Obviously, Zuckerberg wants to poach celebrities and users from Twitter by targeting this pain point.

It seems that Threads has all the innate conditions to challenge Twitter. The rapid growth of Threads after its release has made Twitter feel threatened, and even made Musk lose his temper and curse, using obscene words. This is almost unique among business leaders.
But one year after its launch, Threads does not seem to have brought a significant impact on the X platform. Although the X platform is still full of controversy and its advertising revenue has not returned to the level before Musk acquired it, according to the data released by Musk, the number of active users of X has achieved a more rapid growth and has not been affected by the poaching of Threads.
In contrast, Threads did not continue to grow steadily and strongly after its initial popularity. Even with the continued support of Instagram's traffic diversion, its growth has slowed significantly. Why did Threads lose its subsequent growth momentum and fail to pose a direct challenge to Twitter?
I don't want to touch controversial content anymore
Twitter has been online for 18 years. Over the past decade, despite the continuous turmoil and multiple changes in Twitter's management, stagnant product development, stagnant user growth, and the constant change of social network trends, from Instagram to Snap to TikTok, Twitter's market position has not been substantially challenged and it has always been the most socially influential social platform.

Why has Twitter become the king of social media? This is mainly because of its unique micro-blog product form. Government agencies, news media, and celebrities are all concentrated on the Twitter platform, forming a serious public discussion space and an open online citizen gathering, which has gathered to form social public opinion. This is a feature that Instagram and TikTok, which are more popular and sticky, do not have.
Threads has no ambition or idea in this regard. Both Zuckerberg and Adam Mosseri, head of Instagram, said when talking about the positioning of Threads that Threads does not need to touch on hard news, political content and social topics, and the key attribute they emphasize the most is “friendly community.”
Open discussion and clash of opinions are the characteristics of Twitter, but this is not what Zuckerberg wants. During the past two elections, both the left and right in the United States were very dissatisfied with Facebook's content control policy. The left accused Zuckerberg of allowing controversial political speech and false information, while the right accused him of suppressing conservative speech and favoring the Democratic Party.
It is understandable that Zuckerberg did not want to touch these controversial contents after launching Threads. For a long time, Threads did not have a search box, hot topics and tags. It still does not have a private message function, and it has not even developed a web version, which are all necessary functions for public opinion social platforms. Many users, media people and opinion leaders who were dissatisfied with Twitter came to Threads, but found that it was not suitable for extensive public opinion discussions and clash of opinions. Not long after, they returned to the X platform.
Instagram head Mosley admitted that without these features, it would not be able to satisfy the heaviest users from X, but he emphasized that these are not the key to driving the growth of the platform, and Threads is not just for conversations. The typical discussion scenarios he mentioned are sports, TV, and natural disasters.
It seems that Zuckerberg just wants to create a beautiful community and turn Threads into a text version of Instagram (Threads was originally called Textagram) so that celebrity bloggers and ordinary users can share their lives, entertainment, products and celebrity content in a friendly and peaceful environment, thus winning the favor of advertisers. Advertisers do not want to see their ads appear next to political content.
However, under this product concept, Threads can only take over Instagram's users and traffic, but cannot really take away the discussion traffic and users of hot events from platform X. In addition, the slow growth of users will directly affect the sharing enthusiasm of bloggers and big Vs, while young users are more keen to go to TikTok.
Of course, it is completely understandable that Zuckerberg is increasingly cautious and does not want to be the second Twitter. He has become a thorn in the side of former US President Trump. Just last week, Trump publicly scolded Zuckerberg, accusing them of being enemies of the United States and threatening to make Zuckerberg pay the price after he takes office, or even send him to jail. Current poll data shows that Trump is already ahead of current President Biden.
This year's US election is destined to be more controversial and uncertain than the ones in 2016 and 2020. Compared with Musk's public support for Trump, Zuckerberg just wants to be a little transparent this time, and does not want his social product to be involved in the struggle between the left and right in society again. Threads, which was expected to be a “Twitter killer”, eventually became a “small and beautiful” one with a peaceful life.