After more than 50 years, the United States “returned to the moon.”
At 6:24 pm Eastern Time, the “Odysseus” landed autonomously on the lunar surface and subsequently established radio communication with the mission control center for 13 minutes. This landing was the first lunar lander mission launched by the United States since Apollo 17 in 1972, but more importantly, it was also the first time a private company successfully sent a lander to the moon intact. It can be said to be a day recorded in history. , opened a new chapter in private commercial aerospace.
More than 50 years ago, in the tense atmosphere of the Cold War, the United States promoted the exploration of the moon on an almost nationwide basis. Today, this historic feat is accomplished by private forces. Behind the success of this mission are SpaceX's Falcon 9 rocket and Intuitive Machines' Odysseus lander. The cooperation between these two companies demonstrates the strength of private aerospace.
The landing is part of NASA's Commercial Lunar Payload Services (CLPS) program, designed to support the agency's Artemis program – returning astronauts to the moon and even establishing a mission there A permanent base. The successful landing of “Odysseus” is an important step towards this goal.
Landing on the moon has never been a simple matter. Globally, apart from the United States, only the government space programs of the Soviet Union, China, India and Japan have successfully conducted a “soft landing” on the lunar surface. Until now, landing on the moon still has a high failure rate.
Other recent attempts, such as Pittsburgh's Astrobotic Technology, Japan's ispace's Hakuto-R mission, Israel's Beresheet lander and Russia's Luna 25, have all failed.
Although this “Odysseus” mission is not as grand as the original Apollo mission, NASA hopes to usher in a more revolutionary era: introducing private commercial aerospace forces to participate together, and ultimately achieving cost-effective transportation in the solar system. This vision heralds that future space exploration will be more frequent and less expensive, opening up new possibilities for human activities in space.
The “Odysseus” lander will land in the Malapert A crater near the moon's south pole | Image source: NASA
The first commercial company to successfully land on the moon
On February 15, the hexagonal cylindrical Nova-C lander named Odysseus was launched by a SpaceX Falcon 9 rocket and successfully entered the lunar orbit on February 21. On February 22, at approximately 18:23 pm Eastern Time, Odysseus soft-landed in a crater called Malapert A in the south pole region of the moon.
The landing site is a flat area near the Malapert A crater, located near the moon's south pole. This area has been detected as having frozen water hidden in the shadows of craters, and is one of the reasons why the moon's polar regions have attracted exploration in recent years.
Although Odysseus successfully landed, there were some hiccups along the way. In a briefing the day after the landing, Intuitive Machines executives said Odysseus tipped over on its side during landing but was “still alive.” Analysis by its pilots showed that as the lander approached its final descent, one of its six legs got stuck, causing it to roll over and end up leaning against a rock.
However, with the successful landing, Intuitive Machines, headquartered in Houston, Texas, has become the first commercial company to successfully land near the moon's south pole. Intuitive Machines is a diversified space company focused on space exploration, providing products and services through four distinct business segments: Lunar Access Services, Orbital Services, Lunar Data Services, and Space Products and Infrastructure to support robotic and human missions Continuing exploration of the Moon, Mars and beyond.
Intuitive Machines was founded in 2013. Among the three founders, Stephen Altemus, Kam Ghaffarian, and Tim Crain, two are from NASA: among them, Stephen Altemus, who serves as the company’s co-founder, president and CEO, worked at NASA Johnson Space Center Served as deputy director and worked at NASA's Kennedy Space Center and the Space Shuttle Program. His experience at NASA spans space shuttle operations, launch and landing activities, and his role as director of reconstruction of Columbia following the Space Shuttle Columbia disaster.
Another co-founder, Timothy P. Crain, served as chief engineer at NASA Johnson Space Center and participated in the navigation design of the Mars science lander. While at NASA, he also served as Orbital Guidance, Navigation, and Control (GNC) Systems Manager for the Orion spacecraft, and as Flight Dynamics Lead for Project Morpheus.
Intuitive Machines is one of several companies hired by NASA to transport instruments that will conduct reconnaissance missions before NASA astronauts return to the lunar surface, scheduled to return to the moon within the next decade.
For this mission, NASA paid Intuitive Machines $118 million under the Commercial Lunar Payload Services (CLPS) program to deliver six instruments to the moon, including a stereo camera, and a radio receiver for Surveying the effects of charged particles on radio signals.
NASA plans at least eight other CLPS missions through 2026, including two more from Intuitive Machines and another from Astrobotic. Intuitive Machines has been contracted for two more CLPS missions; Pittsburgh-based Astrobotic Technology is working on a second mission, this time to send a rover to shadowed areas on the moon that may harbor ice.
After that, as long as the Artemis program has astronauts operating on the moon, this program will continue to provide necessary supplies to the lunar base.
How NASA launched “commercial spaceflight”
In the past, NASA built its own spacecraft. Before Neil Armstrong became the first astronaut to land on the moon, NASA launched a series of robotic spacecraft from Surveyor 1 to Surveyor 7 to demonstrate landing techniques and study the properties of lunar soil.
But when NASA designs and operates its own spacecraft, it typically seeks to maximize its chances of success, and its designs tend to be costly.
The Apollo lunar landing program from 1969 to 1972 is a classic example of a program that, with an almost unlimited budget, solved the nearly impossible problem of achieving the feat of landing humans on the moon, also known as the “moon landing” plan”.
However, although the six Apollo lunar landing missions were epoch-making events, the astronauts spent relatively short time on the lunar surface during these missions.
The longest stay was by Apollo 17 astronaut Eugene Cernan and his lunar module pilot Harrison Schmidt, who stayed for three days. By comparison, Neil Armstrong and Buzz Aldrin spent less than 21 hours on the Apollo 11 mission in 1969, the first lunar landing.
At this stage, the United States' lunar exploration was mainly about basic exploration, which was vividly summarized as “planting the flag and leaving footprints.”
But lunar exploration programs are different in the 21st century. When NASA launched the Artemis program in 2017, it made it clear that the new era of exploration would be even more ambitious.
NASA's goal is not just to repeat its past footsteps, but to establish at least a semi-permanent base on the moon and build a mini space station called Gateway in lunar orbit to serve as a “springboard” for astronauts to and from the lunar surface. In addition, NASA also plans to establish a habitat on the lunar south pole to provide astronauts with a “lunar home.”
However funding is an issue. In the glory days of the Apollo program, NASA's budget accounted for 4% of the total U.S. federal budget, but today this proportion has dropped to 0.4%.
In response to this funding constraint, NASA has had to shift its operating model and outsource the design and construction of spacecraft to private companies. This approach is similar to how SpaceX provides NASA with services to transport astronauts to the International Space Station. SpaceX will charge NASA based on the service, just like it does for other satellite manufacturers and private customers.
Before 2011, the United States relied on the space shuttle for space missions, but abandoned its use due to poor safety and high costs. Since then, NASA has relied on Russia's Soyuz spacecraft to transport astronauts, paying approximately $4 billion to Russia over nine years.
To end this dependence and reduce costs, NASA began working with private industry and launched the Commercial Crew Program to develop new crewed spacecraft in partnership with SpaceX and Boeing. SpaceX's Dragon spacecraft and Boeing's CST-100 Starliner spacecraft received funding from NASA respectively. In the end, SpaceX successfully became the first private company in history to send humans into space at the end of May 2020.
This NASA-initiated shift not only improves safety and cost-effectiveness, but also promotes private sector participation in space exploration. SpaceX's success, especially its first commercial manned space mission in 2020, also marks the beginning of private companies' important role in space exploration.
In 2018, NASA went a step further and launched the Commercial Lunar Payload Services (CLPS) program, which further outsources the task of providing astronauts with the equipment they need to private industry.
Thomas Zurbuchen, the former senior NASA science officer who launched the CLPS program, estimates that a robotic lunar lander designed, built and operated in NASA's traditional way would cost $500 million to $1 billion, which is almost five times what NASA paid Intuitive Machines. times.
In the past, space exploration was mainly led by government agencies, but now private companies have become an important force in promoting space exploration with their flexibility and innovation capabilities. Through the operation of the business model, the cost of space exploration has been reduced, further promoting the breadth and depth of exploration. This is the goal behind NASA's “deliberate efforts” to incubate private commercial aerospace companies for more than 20 years and support the development of commercial aerospace with orders.
NASA looks to private companies to come up with innovative ways to achieve the goals of space exploration at a lower cost. The operation of this business model can not only reduce the cost of space exploration, but also stimulate innovation by introducing market competition, which is expected to promote the breadth and depth of exploration activities.
Today, U.S. commercial aerospace leads the world, and behind this is the development of a series of innovative technologies, strong support from government policies, active participation of private enterprises, and the public’s continued enthusiasm for space exploration.
Zhai Guanglong, the founder of Songguo Travel, who has long been concerned about the commercial aerospace field, once carefully analyzed the factors that enabled the development of U.S. commercial aerospace:
NASA’s policy guidance and institutional innovation
Broad social interest in aerospace and intergenerational inheritance
Support from civil society organizations and businesses
Accumulation of commercial aerospace enterprises and professional talents
Science and engineering graduates from the world's top universities provide a steady stream of fresh blood to the aerospace industry
Mature industrial supporting system and deep participation and long-term commitment of financially free entrepreneurs.
Among them, he believes that NASA's policy guidance and institutional innovation provide a solid foundation for the development of commercial aerospace. NASA's open space resource policy, public-private partnership model, and emphasis on deep space exploration not only provide commercial enterprises with a clear direction for development, but also lower their barriers to market entry through practical support in funding and orders.
The ecosystem built by NASA, including mature rocket companies and spare parts suppliers, as well as its inclusive strategy, promotes diverse competition and common progress within the industry.
The mature industrial supporting system provides necessary technical and material support for aerospace enterprises. The United States' industrial base in aerospace-related materials, processes, integrated circuits, and computing simulation software provides solid backing for the development of aerospace enterprises.
Zhai Guanglong believes that another factor worthy of attention is the in-depth participation of financially free entrepreneurs, such as Amazon founder and CEO Jeff Bezos and Elon Musk. and long-term commitment, injecting core impetus into the development of commercial aerospace.
Jeff Bezos once publicly stated that he sells US$1 billion in Amazon stock every year to invest in his aerospace exploration company “Blue Origin”; the original goal of SpaceX, founded by Musk, was to The cost of space launches has been reduced to one-tenth of the operating expenses of the U.S. government, and the risks of transporting materials and personnel into space have also been reduced to one-tenth of the previous level. These entrepreneurs not only provided capital, but also brought continued enthusiasm for the aerospace industry and management experience, driving the prosperity of the entire industry.
Policy support provides opportunities for entrepreneurs, and their participation promotes the development of the industry. The industrial supporting system provides the necessary infrastructure for the entire industry. These three factors are interrelated and work together to form the key cornerstone of the success of U.S. commercial aerospace.
From this perspective, China's commercial aerospace is not only a “commercial track” that has gradually prospered in the past 10 years, but also an important driving force for China's aerospace and even human exploration of the universe, and should win more attention and support. .