A controversial digital communications surveillance law that undermines end-to-end encryption is up for vote again in the EU Parliament. Despite opposition to the original “chat control” bill, the law is now being reintroduced as “client-side scanning” (CSS).
EU Home Affairs Committee votes against random surveillance
In November 2023, the EU Committee on Civil Liberties rejected the proposal to monitor communications for suspicious content such as depictions of abuse (CSAM). This led to considerable protest from data protection organizations and the public. The new approach, called “client-side scanning,” now tries to defuse the criticism by claiming that encryption is not directly circumvented. The CSS involves scanning content on users’ devices before it is sent encrypted.
Encryption remains controversial
Supporters of the new law emphasize that the protection of encryption is maintained through the mechanisms of the CSS, but users must consent to scanning in order to continue sending images and videos. Critics argue that this practice effectively forces consent to surveillance and thus undermines encryption.
Signal announces possible withdrawal from the EU
In response to the upcoming vote, Signal President Meredith Whitaker has confirmed that the messaging app Signal will cease its service in the EU if the law is passed. “The order for mass surveillance of private communications fundamentally undermines encryption,” said Whitacker. The vote on the law at the European Union level will then take place on June 19.