Chinese car companies that have entered the BBA base camp: Somewhat uncomfortable with the local climate

Europe, as the birthplace of automobiles and the birthplace of countless luxury brands, has always represented the top stage of the automobile market. It is like NBA to basketball and F1 to racing. Any automobile brand that can compete with traditional giants such as Mercedes-Benz, BMW and Porsche in their birthplaces represents that a car company has truly entered a mature stage and has a certain strength foundation.

Chinese automakers have sensed opportunities in Europe.Last year, a total of 12.84 million new cars were sold in the European market, including 2.01 million pure electric models, with pure electric sales increasing by 28% year-on-year.All these have emboldened Chinese automakers to announce their plans to enter the European market in recent years.

However, when it comes to the stage of business implementation, various automobile brands can be said to be mixed.

The good news is that European users generally give Chinese electric vehicles a good evaluation. In a very short period of time, we have greatly narrowed or even eliminated the gap in product strength with European car companies.

The worrying part is that unlike Latin America, Southeast Asia, the Middle East, and Central Asia, which are the overseas markets that Chinese automakers often go to, the European market is much more complicated than other regional markets in terms of entry barriers, landing difficulties, fierce competition, and user maturity. Coupled with Europe's strict laws and regulations and the recent EU additional tariff incident, Chinese automakers are facing many difficulties in their overseas expansion into Europe.

Huxiu Auto visited several countries in Europe in June and also visited the stores of Chinese auto brands in Europe. Against the backdrop of cultural differences between the East and the West, what difficulties did Chinese automakers encounter and what did they gain on their way to Europe? What inspiration can all this bring to us? The author will share his experience of visiting Europe in several parts.

The product strength is strong, but Chinese car companies lack patience

Located within a 2km radius of Marienplatz in Munich, Germany, there are three Geely-owned stores: Lotus, Lynk & Co, and Polestar. Lotus occupies the best location, right next to the Mercedes-Benz image store, and naturally attracts many potential customers from the Mercedes-Benz brand.

The author chatted with the Lotus store manager (hereinafter referred to as Maria) for more than 40 minutes. Before joining Lotus, she worked for Mercedes-Benz and BMW for a total of 10 years.

Because of these two career experiences, she has a deep understanding of the German market, especially the luxury brand user group. After joining Lotus for a period of time, she also learned how Chinese car companies commercialize this British sports car brand.


Image source: Photo taken by the author at the Lotus store in Munich, Germany

In Maria's opinion, taking the Lotus pure electric models in their store as an example, the high-end electric cars made by Chinese companies have excellent performance and good design, and their product strength can definitely compete with BBA. However, if you want to gain a firm foothold in the European market, what is more important than product strength is: building trust. She believes that Chinese companies still lack a little patience in building long-term trust with European users.

Maria told me that the replacement cycle of European users is much longer than that of the Chinese market. It is normal to buy a new car after driving an old car for about 8 years. So some users may have already started to look at cars in dealerships when they have used the car for 6-7 years, and finally placed an order for the car one year later.

This means that European users have an extremely long car-buying decision cycle and may come to the store several times a year. From the entrance greeting to the product introduction, every user experience may affect the transaction.

In Maria's view, Mercedes-Benz and BMW are not selling cars, but are trying to build connections and trust with all potential users. Once the brand and the user trust each other, user loyalty will be there.She has seen too many real examples of three generations of a family choosing Mercedes-Benz.

Chinese car companies that have entered the BBA base camp: Somewhat uncomfortable with the local climate
Image source: Photo taken by the author at the European Cup billboard at Munich subway station in Germany

The European market likes cultural accumulation and they don’t believe that a good product/service can be achieved quickly.

Kimi, the head of a European advertising company who has served many Chinese car companies in their overseas expansion, told the author: Among the 17 sponsors of this European Cup, four are Chinese brands, namelyBYD, Hisense, Alipay, VivoThe momentum is indeed very strong, but he hopes that all Chinese brands can understand one thing: although the European Cup has attracted a lot of attention, it is not live streaming after all. It is a long and complicated process from improving brand influence to increasing sales.

The fast-paced, fast-iteration approach that the Chinese market is accustomed to does not work in the European cultural context. If management does not adjust strategies or expectations in a timely manner, the final outcome is likely to be a defeat.

“It has damaged the collective image of Chinese brands”

“Great Wall's closure of its Munich office and stores has hurt the collective image of Chinese auto brands,” said Müller, a project director of a German luxury brand. He is a German, but has worked in China for six years and has a deep understanding of the Central European market and culture.

Müller told the author from a German perspective: In fact, many German users cannot tell how different the backgrounds of brands such as Great Wall Motors, BYD, and NIO are. In the eyes of most Europeans, these are all Chinese brands.

The chain reaction brought about by Great Wall's decision to close its German office and stores some time ago is:German users may wonder, will other Chinese car brands also withdraw from the German market one day?

Müller believes that Great Wall's series of decisions actually hurt the first batch of German car owners who trusted it. How will after-sales, repairs and maintenance be solved in the future? Will OTA software updates keep up with the pace? The market liquidity of used cars will inevitably deteriorate, and the value retention rate will also drop sharply.The first batch of German car owners who chose it are likely to never choose Chinese cars againChoosing a German independent brand will at least ensure that there are stable dealer outlets responsible for subsequent maintenance, and the liquidity and value retention rate in the second-hand market will also be guaranteed.

The author learned from foreign media such as electrive and Automative News Euro:Great Wall Motors sold more than 6,300 new cars in the European market in 2023Since the opening of the Munich office in Germany in 2021, three years have passed, and the sales data has not met expectations, so Great Wall decided to officially close the Munich office in Germany in August this year, and at the same time dismissed the management team with business director Steffen Cost as the core and more than 100 employees. Before joining Great Wall Motors Germany, Steffen Cost was responsible for the European market operations at Kia Motors.

Closing the Munich office does not mean that Great Wall will immediately withdraw from the European market, but the blow and long-term impact on European business will be far-reaching.

Chinese car companies that have entered the BBA base camp: Somewhat uncomfortable with the local climate
Image source: Great Wall Motors official website, signing ceremony between Great Wall and dealer group Emil Frey

Here is a brief review of Great Wall Motors' business progress in Europe.

In early 2020, Great Wall Motors executives began contact and long-term negotiations with Emil Frey, a century-old European dealer group. In September 2021, Great Wall's Wei brand Mocha PHEV (Coffee 01) and Ora Good Cat were unveiled at the Munich Motor Show in Germany, officially announcing their entry into the European market. In November 2021, Great Wall opened a German subsidiary in Munich and established its European headquarters.

In August 2022, Great Wall Motors signed a formal contract with dealer group Emil Frey. The two parties reached a strategic cooperation on the import and distribution of Weipai and Ora in the European market, and jointly marketed the Weipai Mocha PHEV and Ora Good Cat, which were the first to enter the German market, and started delivery in the fourth quarter of that year.

But after that, the cooperation between the two companies was not smooth. According to the German magazine “Manager”: At the beginning of the cooperation, the two models still maintained the original marketing plan and were named WEY Coffee 01 and Ora Funky Cat.

But soon, Great Wall changed their brand strategy, changing the two models to GWM (Great Wall Motor) Wey 05 and GWM Ora 03, and the Great Wall brand became the main body. This move made the dealer group Emil Frey quite dissatisfied.

After the news of closing its Munich headquarters was exposed, Great Wall said that its European business would continue, but would be directly managed and supervised by its Chinese headquarters.Dealer group Emil Frey will have to do business directly with the Baoding headquarters instead of working with the Great Wall European team in Munich, Germany as in the past.

Foreign media electrive also mentioned one point: According to the original plan, Great Wall was also preparing to expand its business to Switzerland, Austria and other countries, and had already hired local market general managers and formed a team. But the closure of the Munich office in Germany means that all this will no longer be possible.

Chinese car companies that have entered the BBA base camp: Somewhat uncomfortable with the local climate
Image source: Photo taken by the author on the streets of Berlin, Germany, of a store that Great Wall had evacuated

When I visited the German market this time, I found that Great Wall's store in Berlin was closed and all the display cars in the store had been moved out. Next to Great Wall's Berlin store is Nio House Berlin and Huawei's store. As Müller said, Great Wall's store closures and withdrawals are indeed damaging the overall image of Chinese brands. The stores of the three Chinese brands are less than 20 meters away from each other.

When I walked in the core area of ​​Munich, I saw an ORA Funky Cat, but in the small pure electric vehicle segment, I saw more of the Elf 1 produced by the joint venture between Geely and smart.

A German smart car owner shared with the author: Although the Elf 1 is a little more expensive than the Funky Cat of ORA, it is backed by the Mercedes-Benz smart brand, and has better interior and exterior design and battery life. He thinks it is worth the money.He believes that Mercedes-Benz will not withdraw from the German market in any case, and the after-sales warranty and the value retention rate of used cars are more guaranteed.

Müller finally told me: There are indeed opportunities in the European market, but if you are not fully prepared to make a long-term investment, it is better not to enter. Once you are determined to enter the European market, you should maintain strategic focus and stick to it.

High-end is not the only solution, starting from the mid-range is not a bad thing

About 20 meters away from the closed Great Wall store is Nio House in Berlin. Compared with Huawei and Great Wall, Nio's store has a better area and location. It is precisely because of this that many young people in Berlin like to go to the second floor of Nio House to work.

The reason is that there is cheap coffee at 3-4 euros per cup, there is power supply to charge the computer, and the environment is also very good. Even if you are not a NIO owner, you can go upstairs and use a workstation for free.

Chinese car companies that have entered the BBA base camp: Somewhat uncomfortable with the local climate
Image source: Photographed by the author at Nio House in Berlin, Germany

The first floor of the store displays three models: EL8 (China's ES8), ET7, and ET5t, as well as an EP9 sports car. The salesman Wagner speaks fluent English and German and communicated with the author for more than half an hour.

In his opinion, NIO's positioning is definitely higher than Tesla, that is, it is benchmarked against German BBA. Whether in terms of driving performance or design, NIO is definitely not inferior to German luxury brands.

But the difficulty he encountered in the sales process was that many of the advantages of NIO cars require users to test drive them in person to fully experience them. However, because they are unfamiliar with this new car-making force from the ancient oriental country, many citizens of Berlin, Germany, do not have much desire to test drive them in person, especially after seeing that the price in the store was not low, they left on their own.

Wagner gave a real example: after entering Nio House, many German people thought that NIO was a high-end brand launched by Japanese and Korean car companies such as Kia, Hyundai, Toyota, and Honda.Only after the salesperson gave a full explanation did they know that this car company was from China.

Weilai's pricing strategy is not very competitive in the German market. The entry-level version of the BMW 3 Series in the German market is priced at 36,500 euros, and the starting price of the Audi A4 is only 31,000 euros. The price of the Weilai ET5t without a 75-degree battery is 52,000 euros. Buying out the battery requires an additional 12,000 euros, or Baas service, 169 euros/month battery rental fee. This means:For the price of one NIO ET5t, you can buy two Audi A4s.

This pricing strategy does put some pressure on sales staff like Wagner. Given that German users generally have a high degree of loyalty to BBA, it is certainly not easy for NIO to achieve a sales explosion in the German market with its extremely high prices.

In Wagner's opinion, NIO has little chance of winning in the German market by competing head-on with BBA. If it is willing to introduce some lower-priced product series in the future and enter the market with a mid-range rather than a high-end positioning, its chances of winning will be much greater, and it can at least snatch a lot of market share from Japanese and Korean brands.

He believes that NIO's greatest strengths are actually its service and battery protection. Kia was able to gain a foothold in the European market by offering longer warranties than European car brands. Labor costs in Europe are high, and sincere service and battery protection policies can actually save car owners a lot of money.

Chinese car companies that have entered the BBA base camp: Somewhat uncomfortable with the local climate

Image source: Photo taken by the author on the streets of Oslo, Norway: NIO EL7 (ES7) taxi

Unlike the slightly difficult landing in the German market, NIO's performance in Northern Europe, especially the Norwegian market, has been much easier. Norway is also NIO's first stop in entering the European market in 2021.

The author then went to Nio's Nio House direct stores in Oslo, Norway and Gothenburg, Sweden. On the streets of Oslo, Nio's visibility is much higher than last year, but mainly taxis. On one street, you can even see two EL7 (ES7), one ET5t, and three Nio taxis at the same time.

Of course, in addition to NIO, you can also see BYD Tang EV, Hongqi E-HS9, SAIC MG EHS, and Xiaopeng P7 taxis on the streets of Oslo. Even SAIC Maxus EUNIQ 6, which is rarely seen on domestic roads, can be seen in Oslo.

A Norwegian customer at the Nio House store in Oslo told me that he thought NIO's aesthetics and design surpassed other Chinese brands (excluding European-dominated models such as Polestar and Lotus), which gave him a new understanding of Chinese electric vehicles. As for whether taxis would damage NIO's brand image, the Oslo local thought it would not, because taxis in Norway are too expensive and are considered high-end consumption.

Chinese car companies are gradually abandoning direct sales in Europe

Just talking about visibility, during the few days I visited stores in Europe, the three most common Chinese cars were Lynk & Co 01, BYD Atto 3 (Yuan Plus), and SAIC MG4.

Lynk & Co is probably one of the earliest Chinese automakers to enter the European market. In 2016, the brand was launched in Berlin, Germany. In October 2020, the first experience store in Europe opened in Amsterdam, the Netherlands.

The author also visited Lynk & Co stores in Munich, Germany and Stockholm, Sweden, and found that they only had one model, the 01, on display, which was mainly used on a subscription basis. However, the author learned that:Because the timing and conditions are ripe, Lynk & Co will immediately start to implement the dealer general agent model.

Chinese car companies that have entered the BBA base camp: Somewhat uncomfortable with the local climate
Image source: Lynk & Co Z10 debuts in Gothenburg, Sweden

On June 12, they also held the debut of their first pure electric model Z10 in Gothenburg, Sweden. The European sales channels are being rolled out, and the pure electric models are being launched simultaneously. These two things combined really show that they have the intention to make efforts in the European market.

Geely Auto Group CEO Jian Jiayue shared this set of data:Lynk & Co has exported more than 70,000 vehicles, mainly to the European market. They have built 12 experience stores in 7 European countries, and their future development will still focus on Europe.

In addition to the new car's debut in Europe, what is more meaningful is that Lynk & Co also took everyone in Sweden to review Geely's layout and growth history in Europe:

From the acquisition of Volvo in 2010, to the establishment of Geely Europe Research and Development Center (CEVT) in 2013, to the acquisition of 9.69% of Daimler's shares in 2018, and the establishment of a smart joint venture with Mercedes-Benz in 2020. It can be said that before the products went overseas, Chinese automakers had already begun to lay out business operations such as capital going overseas and technology exchanges. Looking back, this cycle has now spanned more than a decade.

In an outdoor parking lot in Gothenburg, the author chatted with a local user of Lynk & Co 01. After driving it for two and a half years, he believed that Lynk & Co could replace Toyota RAV4 and meet his needs at a relatively reasonable price.

When learning that Lynk & Co was about to launch a pure electric sedan, this old Swedish user said that he could definitely exchange it for one, because his small yard could be used to install a home charging station, and the Z10 looked much cooler than the Lynk & Co 01.

Chinese car companies that have entered the BBA base camp: Somewhat uncomfortable with the local climate
Image source: Photo taken by the author at the Lynk & Co Z10 launch event in Gothenburg, Sweden. From left to right are Lin Jie, Jian Jiayue, and Chen Xiaofei

Chen Xiaofei, deputy general manager of Lynk & Co. Sales Company, once put forward such a view: when talking about parameters and configurations of many models, they ignore the emotional value.And original design happens to be the place where emotional value is best reflected.

During my visits to several European cities, I also found that whether it is German, Swedish or Norwegian users, their car design and aesthetic literacy are very high, which is a test for the original design level of Chinese car brands.

Unlike Lynk & Co's gradual pace of development, Geely's other brand, Zeekr, has repeatedly suffered setbacks on its road to expansion into Europe.

According to what I learned from Zeekr's European sales company, Zeekr's European sales strategy has abandoned the previous direct sales model and switched to the general agent model. Spiros Fotinos, CEO of Zeekr's European sales company, is rumored to have resigned. Some members of Zeekr's European team told me that he has been away from his business for a while. As for the specific developments, I asked the Zeekr public relations team, but I have not received an accurate reply as of press time.

Currently, Zeekr's European team is responsible for sales in the Netherlands and Sweden, and the monthly sales of the 001 and X models are only more than 100 units. The Israeli market is managed by Zeekr's overseas EM division, which has nothing to do with the European sales company.

A member who has participated in Zeekr's European business told me that except for the poor software ecosystem, the rest of the Zeekr European version is actually not bad, especially the 001 has been proven in the domestic market. However, there are three main reasons for the poor sales in Europe:

1. The sales channel expansion is too slow. Currently there are only two stores in Amsterdam, the Netherlands and Stockholm, Sweden.

2. The pricing is too high. When planning the product, it has to be benchmarked against Tesla Model Y, but the Model Y starts at 40,000 euros, while the Zeekr 001 starts at 60,000 euros, which is 1.5 times that of Tesla.

3. There is no marketing activity and not many European users know who Zeekr is.

Chinese car companies that have entered the BBA base camp: Somewhat uncomfortable with the local climate
Image source: Photo taken by the author at the Zeekr store in Amsterdam, the Netherlands

I have visited Zeekr's direct-operated store in Amsterdam, the Netherlands. The location is excellent, close to a commercial street with huge traffic. However, the traffic in the store is pitifully small, and the originally large store area seems even more empty.

Mike, an account manager of a European dealer, told me that Tesla chose direct sales to a large extent because the high prices of Model S and X, which started at 80,000 euros, led to no dealers willing to take the high risk, so Tesla passively chose the direct sales model. Chinese car companies only saw the explosive sales of Tesla, and chose direct sales like a copycat, which was actually a strategic mistake.

Without the support of local European dealers, the sales channels will explode too slowly, and after-sales and warehousing and logistics outlets will also consume considerable financial and human resources of the OEMs, as well as the most precious time cost.

Mike believes that there is no problem for Zeekr to switch to the general agent model now, but they have missed the one and a half year window and have dragged on to the node for additional tariffs. At this moment, if the car company goes to negotiate with the European dealer group, it will definitely have fewer chips in hand, which is not conducive to fighting for better terms and freedom for itself.

As a Chinese automaker, Mike appreciates BYD's European strategy:We took almost no detours and started working with dealer groups right from the start, and had already decided to build a factory in Hungary before the tariffs were implemented.

At present, BYD has opened 260 stores in Europe, and the huge number of terminal channels helps BYD to quickly distribute its products. As for brand communication, Mike said succinctly: sponsoring the European Cup is definitely more effective than opening direct stores. A good marketing strategy must be to not spend the budget that should not be spent, and not to feel sorry for the budget that should be spent.

In China, the direct sales model is easy for car companies to manage and the pricing system is relatively stable, which has helped Zeekr achieve a sales breakthrough. However, in Europe, due to different cultural backgrounds and laws and regulations, the high-cost direct sales model has become a burden.

In Mike's opinion,Under the direct sales model, car companies have to hold a large amount of assets (including inventory), and their balance sheets will expand. Zeekr's slow pace of opening stores and dismal sales fully demonstrate that they do not have the ability to assume all retail functions in the European market at this stage.

Choosing to cooperate with a dealer group means that the headquarters no longer needs a large organization to be responsible for pre-sales and sales matters. This may also be the main reason why Spiros Fotinos, CEO of Zeekr's European sales company, is suspected to have resigned.

Build factories in Europe and promote cultural exports

After visiting the entire European market, I talked to more than a dozen friends working in the European automotive industry. Among them, there are Chinese working on the front line of overseas expansion, as well as many Europeans who are interested in China's electric vehicle industry.

Several European friends generally believe that: No one dislikes low-priced Chinese electric cars. Due to the world economic situation, the wages of many Europeans have not increased for many years, and have even declined; it is definitely attractive to spend less money and buy better products.

But they also expressed their fear of price wars, because behind this are many practitioners and suppliers sacrificing their interests.If the price war hits the European market, I might have to cut my salary, and I might not buy the car even if it is cheaper, because after all, people buy cars with their salary.

Among them, Louis, a European friend who works on the overseas expansion of Chinese electric vehicles, hopes that Chinese cars can truly gain a foothold in the European market and move from exporting products to exporting culture, so that Europeans can see that Chinese companies can not only manufacture good products, but also export remarkable values.

Finally he believed:Chinese car companies will come to Europe to build factories. It will be interesting to compete with European car companies on the same starting line in the future.