China's auto industry ranks first in the world: Should we support or oppose it?

The industry's attitude towards internal circulation has completely gone to two extremes.

The forum, which was filled with gunpowder, laid the problems faced by car companies on the table without reservation.

On the one hand, some people believe that Chinese cars will become better and better and stronger as they become more popular.

The other side believes that involution is synonymous with unhealthy competition. The words are so harsh that they even believe that as long as the word “involution” is not eliminated, Chinese cars will never truly go global.

Indeed, if there is a keyword running through the entire industry in the past year, it is internal competition, competition in prices, competition in sales, competition in market share, and even competition in bosses. After the price war started, the situations faced by companies were also different.

Some can still bear it, but some are powerless and can only lie flat and let others do whatever they want. In the long run, this problem obviously cannot be ignored, and its outcome is related to the direction of the automotive industry.

01. Anti-roll vs. support roll

Regarding the term “involution”, Yang Xueliang, senior vice president of Geely Holding Group, first traced the origin of the term.

China's auto industry ranks first in the world: Is it good or bad?

The word “involution” was first used in the English version of Dr. Huang Zongzhi's book “Peasant Economy and Social Change in North China” published by Stanford University Press in 1985. The following year, Zhonghua Book Company translated the book into Chinese and translated “involution” into “involution”.

Originally, involution was a neutral term, but in Yang Xueliang's view, today's involution has become a derogatory term, a synonym for a bad phenomenon and unhealthy competition.

What kind of involution does Yang Xueliang oppose? He gave four points of his personal experience at the 2024 China Automotive Forum:

In a free market, competition is carried out through price cuts;

Under relatively stable market demand, they do not follow rules, ethics, quality and safety, and disrupt the competitive order;

Low-level competition, no quality growth, and no development with lasting momentum;

Only caring about the present and ignoring the long-term, constantly repeating simple reproduction, only seeking quantitative increases but not qualitative breakthroughs, there is no progress.

Its attitude is quite clear. Long-term boundless internal circulation and price wars will result in cutting corners, non-compliant and disorderly competition.

“As a member of the Chinese auto industry, we must protect the orderly competition and sustainable development of the industry. Opposing lawbreakers and criminals is to combat internal circulation and contribute to breaking out of the internal circulation vicious circle. “I believe that Chinese law will definitely support good money driving out bad money, not the other way around. If the current phenomenon continues for a long time, the tragedy of bad money driving out good money will occur.”

China's auto industry ranks first in the world: Is it good or bad?

Zeng Qinghong, chairman of GAC Group, has also publicly criticized “involution”, saying that this is not a solution. He stressed that the automotive industry should have a big picture and a pattern, focusing on long-term strategies, rather than going against the involution.

In contrast, BYD has a different view on involution. Li Yunfei, general manager of BYD's brand and public relations department, holds high the banner of “involution”.It means that Chinese cars are becoming stronger and better.

First of all, on the technical level, Li Yunfei believes that China's automobile technology has achieved a qualitative leap in the continuous “involution”.

He revealed that over the past four years, R&D investment by China's mainstream auto brands has surged to 2.5 times that of four years ago. Everyone attaches great importance to technological research and development, and these are real investments.

He also compared Chinese auto products in recent years with those three to five years ago or even earlier, as well as similar products from foreign and joint venture brands. He believed that Chinese auto products have not only achieved a leap in quantity, but also achieved a transformation in quality from “the more you roll, the better”.

China's auto industry ranks first in the world: Is it good or bad?

Moreover, this transformation is not only reflected in the design and performance of the products, but also goes deeper into multiple dimensions such as service, quality, market share and export volume. In 2019, the market share of Chinese brands was only about 30%, but now it has reached nearly 60%.

“So I think this is the meaning of volume. Our technology will become stronger, our products will become better, our services will become better, our quality will become stronger, our exports will increase, and our market share will increase.”

It is not difficult to see that BYD’s views are exactly the opposite of Geely’s, and it is worth mentioning that BYD supports the “volume” from top to bottom.

Wang Chuanfu also expressed support for “involution” at a recent Chongqing Auto Forum:“Entrepreneurs should embrace and participate in this kind of 'volume' and competition, go global amid the competition, support Chinese brands for the country, and build the world's top brands.”

02. Is it good or bad to engage in internal competition?

To answer this question, let us first look at the overall situation of the domestic automobile industry.

According to the China Passenger Car Association, in the first half of this year, the cumulative wholesale sales of narrow-sense passenger cars in China reached 11.751 million units, a year-on-year increase of 6.1%. New energy vehicles increased even faster, with wholesale sales of new energy passenger cars reaching 4.62 million units in the same period, a year-on-year increase of 30.3%.

The above figures illustrate two key issues. First, the automobile market trend this year is better than last year. Second, new energy vehicles are obviously stronger, and their market share has encroached on the fuel vehicle market.

China's auto industry ranks first in the world: Is it good or bad?

Therefore, in this battle for market share, some players will inevitably retreat and compromise.

The cruelty of this competition can be seen from the performance of each car company. In the first half of this year, many domestic brands and new force brands have achieved varying degrees of growth. In comparison, the joint venture players have not had such an easy time.

For example, retail sales of SAIC Volkswagen, GAC Toyota, FAW Toyota and Dongfeng Nissan have all declined, with GAC Toyota's decline reaching 15.7% in the first half of the year. Most new energy players are growing, with only a few experiencing sales declines, such as GAC Aion's decline of 22.9% in the first half of the year, and Tesla China's decline of 5.4%.

In this battle for market share in new energy vehicles, the player that benefits the most is BYD, which supports internal competition.

China's auto industry ranks first in the world: Is it good or bad?

According to data from the China Passenger Car Association, BYD's retail sales in the first six months increased by 20.3% year-on-year to 1,154,573 vehicles, and its market share reached an astonishing 33.8%, which is a huge advantage over the second-ranked Geely Auto, whose share is only 7.5%.

We can see an obvious trend, that is, the new energy vehicle industry presents a clear “one super and many strong” situation. Facing these competitors, BYD has an overwhelming scale advantage.

The current competitive situation is the product of internal circulation.

Without involution, the development of the domestic automobile industry would be uneven, and many companies would produce shoddy products. For ordinary consumers, without price wars, the prices of joint venture brands would remain high, and the luxury barriers of BBA would be difficult to break.

China's auto industry ranks first in the world: Is it good or bad?

Therefore, a certain degree of internal circulation is obviously beneficial to the development of the industry, and a synonym for “volume” can also be competition. Healthy competition can always stimulate the potential of enterprises.

The “involution” that the above-mentioned companies are resisting should be excessive involution. This kind of “involution” without long-termism will inevitably result in casualties once the war breaks out.

This kind of “volume” affects the company's revenue and brand confidence. Some companies will also experience problems such as increased revenue but not increased profits, and declining profit margins per bicycle. In extreme cases, it may even affect the quality of delivered products.

at the same time,There will also be other competition, such as attacks from water armies, threats from black public relations, etc. Such “volume” will undoubtedly erode brand trust.

In fact, simply comparing competition and business wars between enterprises to involution is a bit of a conceptual substitution. After all, if we look at this issue dialectically, the pros and cons are very obvious.

There has always been competition in the industry, and there is benign competition and malignant competition, and the two types of competition have completely different results.

So, before choosing to support or oppose, isn’t it more important to define involution?

China's auto industry ranks first in the world: Is it good or bad?