Carbon dioxide can also be used as a battery! The cost is lower than lithium, but the life is much longer–Fast Technology–Technology changes the future

Carbon dioxide is usually emitted as a by-product of power generation, and power generation is sometimes measured in terms of how much carbon dioxide is emitted.

Taking the United States as an example, in 2022, each kilowatt-hour of electricity generated in the country will emit about 0.86 pounds (1 pound is approximately equal to 453.6 grams) of carbon dioxide.[1].


Image source: Reference 1 (AI translation)

Coal-fired power produces the second-highest amount of carbon dioxide emissions of all forms of power generation, at 2.3 pounds per kilowatt-hour, second only to oil at 2.38 pounds per kilowatt-hour. However, oil is rarely used directly for power generation, while coal is basically used for power generation. Every country's power grid has a high proportion of coal-fired power installed capacity.

Currently, China's coal-fired power installed capacity accounts for less than 40% of the total capacity (the actual power generation ratio is higher than this). This proportion has dropped a lot in recent years, but it is still high compared to the United States.

So, in fact, our country's average carbon dioxide emissions per kilowatt-hour of electricity generated are higher than those of the United States (because of the high proportion of coal-fired power).

However, many people may not know that carbon dioxide can also be captured and used to generate electricity. It is an excellent material for rechargeable batteries that can store electrical energy and release it when needed.

Carbon dioxide can also be used as a battery! The cost is lower than lithium, but the life is much longer
Figure: Mobile phone lithium battery

How do CO2 batteries work?

When it comes to rechargeable batteries, many people will think of chemical batteries such as lithium batteries and nano batteries. Few people will think of carbon dioxide, but scientists have indeed found a way and it has been applied.

Lithium batteries or nanobatteries store and release electrical energy through the redox reaction of materials, but carbon dioxide batteries have a completely different way of storing and releasing electrical energy – they utilize the unique physical properties of carbon dioxide supercritical fluid.

When CO2 exceeds a certain temperature and pressure – namely 31.1°C and 7.39 MPa – it becomes supercritical, a state in which it can expand like a gas but still has the density of a liquid.

In fact, in this state it can dissolve some substances like other liquids. The caffeine in coffee is often dissolved through supercritical carbon dioxide.

Carbon dioxide can also be used as a battery! The cost is lower than lithium, but the life is much longer
Figure: The working principle of a carbon dioxide battery. The right side is carbon dioxide, and the three tubes on the left are for storing carbon dioxide liquid.

Of course, to use it to generate electricity or release electrical energy, it is used to maintain a high density when it expands, so that it can be pumped through a turbine and drive the turbine to rotate, thereby generating electricity.[2].

If the discharge process is solved, then how to charge it?

This is also very simple. Just let it reach supercritical temperature and pressure. This temperature is almost room temperature, so when charging, you basically just need to convert electrical energy into pressure.

Carbon dioxide can also be used as a battery! The cost is lower than lithium, but the life is much longer

Advantages and disadvantages of carbon dioxide batteries

In fact, using supercritical carbon dioxide to generate electricity is nothing new. It has always been proposed and developed as a reliable alternative to steam in various power generation methods – mainly including nuclear power and concentrated solar power.

However, as we can see, many people are not familiar with it, and this is because it does have some shortcomings and cannot be widely used.

First of all, from the principle of carbon dioxide power generation, we can know that this type of battery cannot be modular like lithium batteries and nano batteries, which can be made into various shapes and sizes.

Since it turns into carbon dioxide gas after expansion, it requires a fairly large space to store the carbon dioxide, so it cannot be widely used by ordinary people like lithium batteries and nano batteries.

On the other hand, its round-trip efficiency is actually not very high, around 75%. That is, for every 1 kWh of electricity used to charge a phone, it can only release 0.75 kWh of electricity.

In comparison, the round-trip efficiency of lithium batteries can reach 85% (chemical batteries are currently the most efficient energy storage method)[3].

However, carbon dioxide batteries also have their own advantages.

Carbon dioxide can also be used as a battery! The cost is lower than lithium, but the life is much longer
Comparison between carbon dioxide batteries and lithium batteries, source: Reference 3

first,It uses environmentally friendly and inexhaustible industrial waste——Carbon dioxide is much better than lithium batteries. Lithium resources are not abundant, but sodium is relatively better.

Secondly,CO2 battery's round-trip efficiency does not decrease over timeit can still maintain an efficiency of about 75% for more than 30 years, but chemical batteries like lithium batteries will significantly reduce their efficiency over time, and may be much worse than before in two or three years.

in addition,The depth of discharge of CO2 batteries is almost 100% under all conditionsThis is not the case with chemical batteries. The chemical reaction is affected by various factors, and the depth of discharge will change significantly.

the most important is,The cost of carbon dioxide batteries is slightly lower than that of chemical batteries. If compared based on the storage of the same amount of electricity, the cost per kilowatt-hour of lithium batteries is about 1.7 times that of carbon dioxide batteries.

In fact, judging from the advantages and disadvantages of carbon dioxide batteries, it is not suitable as an ordinary household battery, but it is very suitable as an energy storage power station in the power grid.

Carbon dioxide can also be used as a battery! The cost is lower than lithium, but the life is much longer
Figure: Fengning Pumped Storage Power Station

How important is storing electricity?

On Fengning Mountain in Chengde City, Hebei Province, there is a special hydropower station. It is built on the top of the mountain. Normally, electricity is used to pump water up to fill the reservoir, and then the water is released to the next reservoir to generate electricity.

This hydropower station is the Fengning Pumped Storage Power Station, which is the largest pumped storage power station built by humans in this century. The total investment has reached 19.237 billion yuan, and the total storage capacity of the upper reservoir has reached 45.04 million cubic meters.

Since electricity is used to pump water and then release it to generate electricity, this process involves energy loss, so many people don't understand why they would do this kind of loss-making business.

In fact, the reason is very simple.The national power grid must use as much electricity as it generates, otherwise the power station will overheat or even burn out.

Therefore, this kind of energy storage power station is needed. When the power generation is too much to be used up, the electricity will be conducted to the energy storage power station for storage. When the power generation is insufficient, the electricity from the energy storage power station will be released. Fengning Pumped Storage Power Station is of this type. Its essence is also a “rechargeable battery”. Charging is equivalent to converting electrical energy into gravitational potential energy.

With the relevant regulations on carbon neutrality, the installed capacity of clean energy in various countries, such as wind power stations and solar energy, has become more and more. However, these power stations rely on the weather and cannot be artificially controlled to generate electricity at all times.

Carbon dioxide can also be used as a battery! The cost is lower than lithium, but the life is much longer
Simulation diagram of carbon dioxide energy storage power station, source: reference 3

so,As the use of these unstable clean energy sources increases, the demand for energy storage power stations will become greater and greater. Carbon dioxide batteries can also be charged like pumped-storage power stations when power generation is high, and release electricity when power generation is insufficient.

However, the round-trip efficiency of carbon dioxide batteries is slightly lower than that of pumped-storage power stations. Fortunately, it uses carbon dioxide, which is a reasonable use of carbon emissions.

Finally, it’s worth mentioning that while CO2 is very stable, non-toxic and harmless, a CO2 battery energy storage plant that’s coming online in Italy this year might need to store 1,000 tonnes of CO2 – a huge dome structure for storage, which would be a pretty dangerous facility.

If this carbon dioxide accidentally leaks, it may cause the collective death of organisms in a fairly wide range around it.

refer to:

[1].https://www.eia.gov/tools/faqs/faq.php?id=74&t=11

[2].https://spectrum.ieee.org/this-power-plant-runs-on-co2

[3].https://energydome.com/co2-battery/