A real look at Robotaxi in Beijing, Guangzhou and Shenzhen: It takes only half an hour to take a taxi, and some platforms can “take advantage of it”–Fast Technology–Technology changes the future

A real look at Robotaxi in Beijing, Guangzhou and Shenzhen: It only takes half an hour to take a taxi, and some platforms can “take advantage of it”

There were different opinions on whether Luobo Kuaipao had shaken up the travel service market in Wuhan.At the same time, cities such as Beijing, Guangzhou and Shenzhen, where autonomous driving is progressing rapidly, are calm, which makes people curious. Why is this?

Recently, Cailianshe reporters conducted offline surveys in Beijing, Guangzhou and Shenzhen, trying to find answers through personal experience and conversations with passengers, taxi drivers, Robotaxi practitioners, platform parties and analysts.

I haven’t spent a penny at this stage, can the discount continue?

“Now riding is free.” A vehicle safety officer said when a Cailian reporter was experiencing Pony.ai Robotaxi in Qianhai, Nanshan District, Shenzhen.

(The Pony.ai payment interface shows “Free of Charge”)

At the Tongzhou District Government Station in Beijing, the reporter hailed a white Robotaxi. With the first-order discount and other discounts, the approximately 5-kilometer journey was free of charge.

Around 4 p.m. on the afternoon of July 13, the reporter took the Luobo Kuaipao bus from Exit A of Guangzhou Science City Metro Station to Exit B of Suyuan Metro Station. The 3.1 km journey cost a total of 3.88 yuan after deductions from event discounts.

In Guangzhou's Huangpu District, Mr. Li, a passenger who took the Luobo Kuaipao to the get-off point, told a reporter from Cailianshe that the overall experience of taking a driverless car was similar to that of taking any other car, but the price was cheaper. He only paid about five yuan for a half-hour ride, or about 50 cents per kilometer.

A real look at Robotaxi in Beijing, Guangzhou and Shenzhen: It only takes half an hour to take a taxi, and some platforms can

(Photo taken by Cailianshe reporter of Luobo Kuaipao Vehicle in Huangpu District, Guangzhou)

According to reporters' field visits to Beijing, Guangzhou and Shenzhen, Robotaxi platforms currently have price advantages compared to traditional online car-hailing and taxis. However, it remains to be seen whether the preferential strategies introduced during the market expansion stage can be sustained in the long run.

According to the safety officer of Pony.ai, the early tests have been relatively mature.“It is estimated that the charges will start in one or two months. After the charges are implemented, there will be coupons in the early stage, and the subsequent prices for calling a taxi should be similar to those of a normal taxi.”

In addition to the price, which is of great concern to the market, in terms of operating areas, according to a survey by Cailianshe reporters, seven districts in Beijing, including Beijing Economic and Technological Development Zone, Daxing District, Fangshan District, Haidian District, Shunyi District, Tongzhou District, and Shijingshan District, have carried out road tests on autonomous vehicles, of which 11 roads and 322.46 kilometers in the Economic and Technological Development Zone have carried out vehicle road tests. Shenzhen's autonomous vehicle road test operations are mainly concentrated in Nanshan District, Pingshan District, and Bao'an District; Guangzhou is mainly concentrated in some areas of Huangpu Science City.

A real look at Robotaxi in Beijing, Guangzhou and Shenzhen: It only takes half an hour to take a taxi, and some platforms can

(The blue part is the main operating area of ​​​​LuoBoKuaiPao in Guangzhou)

However, different manufacturers have different advancement speeds, and their operating areas and scopes vary slightly. For example, the reporter checked the Luobo Kuaipao APP and learned that in Guangzhou, it currently only operates in some areas such as the Science City in Huangpu District, while in Beijing it covers Yizhuang, Tongzhou, Shougang and parts of the Software Park. WeRide and Pony.ai mainly operate in Yizhuang in Beijing.

In Shenzhen, “(Pony.ai's Robotaxi service) has been running for two or three years. Initially, it was mainly tested in Qianhai, and later expanded to Houhai. Recently, Xixiang has also been opened. Pony.ai should be the one with the largest number of vehicles (Robotaxi deployed) in Shenzhen.” The aforementioned security officer told the Cailianshe reporter.

The experience of waiting for a bus for half an hour needs to be improved

During the actual experience, the reporter found that Robotaxi is still in the early exploration stage and can only provide point-to-point pick-up and drop-off services. Long waiting times and easy traffic jams are all relatively common problems.

When I took the Carousel in Guangzhou Science City, I could not choose to get on the bus at any location, but had to go to a designated spot nearby. After accepting the order, the page showed that there were 2 people waiting, and it was estimated that a car would respond in 3-8 minutes, but in fact, the timeout was exceeded several times, and the number of people waiting increased to 7. Then the page prompted “few cars nearby”, and it actually took 30 minutes from accepting the order to getting on the bus and sitting down.

During the morning rush hour on the 12th, the reporter tried to call a car in the Qianhai area of ​​Nanshan District, Shenzhen, and found that the Luobo Kuaipao app showed that there were 4 people waiting, but the waiting time was about one hour; the Pony.ai app responded relatively quickly, showing that the car would arrive within 8 minutes, but it still took 22 minutes from receiving the order to actually getting on the car. During the same morning rush hour, the Didi app responded in only 2 minutes, and the overall time (from receiving the order to getting on the car) was about 9 minutes.

A real look at Robotaxi in Beijing, Guangzhou and Shenzhen: It only takes half an hour to take a taxi, and some platforms can

(Estimated response time during peak hours is at least 1 hour)

Is the long waiting time related to the small number of vehicles on the road at this stage?

The customer service staff of Luobo Kuaipao told the reporter of Cailianshe that they currently provide fixed pick-up and drop-off points in the operating area. The vehicles are operated in different time periods and regions. The number of vehicles deployed may be different at different times. The response time for calling vehicles is based on the system dispatch display page. The safety officer of Pony.ai said, “It's mainly because the vehicles are not idle and there are many people calling for them.”

Traffic jams caused by self-driving vehicles are also often the focus of discussion. According to a Shenzhen taxi driver, the self-driving cars currently on the road behave rather “mechanically”. “For example, when turning right at a zebra crossing, they will wait for a long time even if there are no pedestrians. I encountered a traffic jam near Coastal City before because the self-driving car in front of me turned around too slowly.”

According to the market access test results and the policy requirements of the demonstration zone, WeRide, LoBo, and Pony.ai have already launched some fully driverless Robotaxi vehicles in various places, and the rest put into operation all have primary driving safety officers.

A real look at Robotaxi in Beijing, Guangzhou and Shenzhen: It only takes half an hour to take a taxi, and some platforms can

(Currently, Shenzhen's driverless vehicles are still equipped with safety officers. Photo taken by Cailianshe reporter)

It is worth noting that the large-scale operation of fully driverless Robotaxi requires solving the problem of “safety trust” among consumers. Many passengers have reported that they are concerned about the reliability of autonomous driving technology and that they are unable to solve unexpected problems encountered in the car.

A person who used to work as the main driver safety officer and autonomous vehicle dispatcher at Luobo Kuaipao told Cailianshe reporters, “From a technical perspective, the safety of the vehicle itself is very high. What really affects the safety of autonomous driving are those people in each city who do not obey traffic rules.” In addition, there is a cloud cabin safety officer behind the purely unmanned Robotaxi. When the vehicle is abnormal or malfunctions, the system automatically switches to the screen of the abnormal vehicle, and the cloud cabin safety officer quickly intervenes.

He said that if passengers encounter unexpected problems, they can call the customer service number, and the dispatcher will guide the cloud cabin security officer to handle the problem according to the regulations. For example, if a passenger suddenly falls ill and cannot complete the order, the driving route can be changed to the hospital.

“In extremely special circumstances, if the vehicle gets into trouble, we can also quickly resolve it through remote assistance, thus avoiding the possibility of causing traffic jams to a large extent. Pony.ai has also set up detailed safety emergency plans for fully unmanned autonomous driving testing and operations. In response to accidents encountered in current tests (without passengers), we have set up a fully unmanned testing safety management team, which will have specific personnel dedicated to handling them, such as remote safety officers, on-site accident handling specialists, traffic control liaison specialists, etc.” A relevant person in charge of Pony.ai told a Cailianshe reporter.

Low market share, difficult to influence the travel market structure

Luobo Kuaipao has deployed more than 400 driverless cars in Wuhan. Will this affect taxi drivers and have an impact on the travel market?

A Robotaxi practitioner told Cailianshe reporter, “Currently, the market share of Robotaxi is still very low. Even the market share of Turnip Run in Wuhan is only 1%, which is not enough to impact the existing market.”

“Autonomous driving travel services will supplement and promote the operation of the travel and transportation industries for a long time, rather than replace them.” The above-mentioned practitioner told Cailianshe reporter that autonomous driving travel services are still an emerging business model, which will greatly improve the efficiency of travel and transportation, reduce traffic accidents caused by human driver errors, and make up for future labor shortages. Therefore, including autonomous driving companies and travel companies are actively making plans.

Many taxi drivers in Beijing, Guangzhou, Shenzhen and other places also told Cailianshe reporters that Robotaxi has little impact on them. Mr. Sun, who has been in charge of taxi rental for many years, said, “I have been paying close attention to this issue recently, but Beijing only has pilot areas in Yizhuang, Shunyi and other places, so the business is normal and has not been affected.”

A taxi driver who often drives in Huangpu District, Guangzhou, told reporters that he has not felt any pressure in receiving orders recently after the launch of the self-driving car. “Taxi-hailing is a matter of personal preference. Passengers in a hurry will not necessarily choose self-driving cars, because the cars are slow to arrive and they may stop and not move.”

“Except for peak hours, the taxi business is generally average now, mainly because each taxi company and the Didi platform have more cars, and the Didi platform also has a price advantage.” said a Shenzhen taxi driver.

At the entrance of a large residential complex in the Robotaxi test operation area in Nanshan District, Shenzhen, there is a long queue of taxis waiting to pick up passengers. During peak hours, taxis are in short supply, and many residents will book traditional online taxis in advance to save time. At this stage, Robotaxi is only a way of travel for a very small number of people to “try out”.

“It seems that no one around me would rely on Robotaxi for commuting. Even if you can get a car, you will most likely be late if you take a Robotaxi during the morning rush hour on weekdays,” resident Mr. Wang told Cailianshe reporters.

According to the “Intelligent Connected Vehicle Technology Roadmap 2.0”, the market share of highly autonomous intelligent connected vehicles will reach 20% by 2030, and it will take some time for Robotaxi to be implemented on a large scale.

However, there are indeed concerns that the survival space of Robotaxi will be squeezed as the number of them increases in the future. Mr. Sun said, “Some people around me are very nervous. Many drivers are asking whether it will affect their future business, especially when they heard that Daxing Airport will have unmanned driving.”

Large-scale deployment requires clear responsibility for accidents

According to the latest media reports, the debut of Tesla's self-driving taxi Robotaxi, which was originally scheduled for August, may be postponed to October, and Tesla's market value has evaporated by $72 billion. However, even so, the competition for the “number one player” in the self-driving taxi service market will only become more intense. Large-scale investment in the market and seizing market space will also become the key to the next round of competition.

Cailianshe reporter learned from Pony.ai that since December 2018, it has launched the autonomous driving travel service PonyPilot+ in Guangzhou, Beijing, Shanghai, Shenzhen and other cities in China. It is the world's first company to launch autonomous driving travel services in both China and the United States. According to the list of Beijing's autonomous driving vehicle road test qualifications for 2024 announced by the Beijing Intelligent Vehicle Industry Innovation Center, Luobo Yunli has obtained the trial operation test qualification, of which hundreds of vehicles have entered the test phase III. In addition, during WAIC2024, reporters learned from the Luobo Kuaipao booth that it will achieve full coverage of Wuhan this year, and plans to invest 1,000 new-generation mass-produced unmanned vehicles in Wuhan to achieve 7×24 hours of fully unmanned operation.

However, we still need to consider what problems may arise when Robotaxi is put on the market on a large scale.

Yuan Shuai, the founding sponsor of the New Intelligence and New Quality Productivity Living Room, said in an interview with a reporter from Cailianshe that after Robotaxi is mass-produced and commercialized, the problems that may arise include increased traffic congestion, tight parking resources, impact on the traditional travel industry, and network security and privacy protection issues.

Gao Zelong, vice president of the Digital Economy Platform Branch of the China Communications Industry Association, mentioned the considerations of technology maturity and cost. He said that Robotaxi can basically achieve single-vehicle intelligence and autonomous driving in more than 90% of scenarios, but the long-tail scenarios are difficult to improve and polish the algorithm, and it takes a lot of time to accumulate mileage and settle data. At the same time, the cost of Robotaxi's single-vehicle service includes the cost of manufacturing the vehicle, the labor cost of the safety officer, and the marketing cost during the operation process.

Zhi Peiyuan, a master's student enterprise tutor at the School of Management of China University of Mining and Technology (Beijing), believes that there may be problems with traffic safety and accident responsibility. “To ensure the safe operation of Robotaxi, it is necessary to strengthen the vehicle's sensor system and artificial intelligence algorithm, establish a strict safety supervision system, implement regular performance evaluation and maintenance inspections, and ensure that all vehicles meet the highest safety standards; it is necessary to work closely with the legislature to promote the formulation of a legal framework specifically for Robotaxi and clarify the responsibilities of manufacturers, software suppliers and passengers.” He said.

Zhan Junhao, a strategic positioning expert and founder of Fujian Huace Brand Positioning Consulting, also mentioned the importance of the issue of responsibility when he was interviewed by a reporter from Cailianshe. He said that at the policy level, the Robotaxi industry needs to actively cooperate with government departments to promote the improvement of relevant laws and regulations, clarify the responsibility, and provide legal protection for the healthy development of the industry.

Cailianshe reporters noted that Shenzhen, Shanghai, Wuxi, Suzhou, Jiangsu and other places have issued and implemented local regulations on intelligent connected vehicles. On June 30, the Beijing Municipal Bureau of Economics and Information Technology also issued the “Beijing Autonomous Driving Vehicle Regulations (Draft for Comments)” (hereinafter referred to as the “Draft for Comments”), which provides the standards for the division of responsibilities for autonomous driving traffic accidents.

The “Draft for Comments” points out that if a road traffic accident occurs when the vehicle's autonomous driving system function is activated, causing personal injury, death, or property damage, and the responsibility lies with the autonomous driving vehicle, the vehicle owner or manager shall bear the liability for compensation.

The Guangzhou Municipal Transportation Bureau also told Cailianshe reporters earlier that it will strengthen the safety of autonomous driving in a variety of ways. “First, Guangzhou's policy clearly stipulates that intelligent connected vehicles will be tested by level and category. On the premise of ensuring the safety of people's lives and property, the gradually upgraded testing mechanism will support corporate technology research and development and innovation. Second, through a detailed analysis and evaluation mechanism for multiple indicators that affect road driving safety, such as basic indicators of test roads, traffic safety facilities, and classification standards, the traffic safety of open test roads will be maximized. Third, a real-time data upload monitoring mechanism will be established to strengthen compliance monitoring and management of the vehicle testing process. Fourth, an accident reporting mechanism will be implemented to strengthen the supervision of road traffic accidents.”