For a couple days ago, Apple introduced its first smart home hub in the form of Home view. The device has a format that is unusual for smart home hubs and is almost reminiscent of an enlarged Apple Watch. Google’s Nest Hub series, Amazon’s Echo Show and most other hubs have oblong screens in landscape format.
Appla offers two variants of Homeview, one that stands on the table and one that can be hung on the wall and that lacks the speaker stand that the table model has. Both cost $299 in the US, but the wall model also requires a wall mount, which is sold separately from $60. The screen is the same between the models: 7 inches with 1088 × 1088 pixelsi.e. completely square.
The odd format means that a lot of material gets black sad edges if it is not enlarged and thus cropped. Most videos on YouTube have an aspect ratio of 16:9, while, for example, Hollywood films streamed on Netflix often have a format that is closer to 21:9. Smartphones usually use the 4:3 format for still images and system cameras often 3:2, so even slideshows show sad edges or need to be enlarged and cropped to fill the screen.
A YouTube video in 16:9 is slightly larger on an iPhone 18 Pro Max than on Homeview.
On an iPhone 18 Pro Max held horizontally, a 16:9 video fills about 82 percent of the screen’s surface, while the same video fills 56 percent on Apple’s Homeview. The surface used for playback is 89 cm² on the Homeview and 94 cm² on the iPhone 18 Pro Max.
The same video fills 96 percent of the screen on Nest Hub, but only 56 percent on Homeview.
Probably the most popular smart home hub on the market is Google’s Nest Hub, which has an aspect ratio close to 16:9. On the Nest Hub, a Youtube video fills 96 percent of the screen area and on the Pixel Tablet, which has the 16:10 format, 90 percent, compared to 56 percent on Homeview. The area of the video will be 132 cm² on Google’s hub, while Homeview can only display 89 cm².
A movie in 21:9 fills less than half the screen on Homeview.
The worst is with feature films in the 21:9 format. On Homeview, such a film becomes a strip that is just over 5 cm high and fills 43 percent of the screen. Those who want to have a series or film running while the dishes are being removed will therefore get a smaller picture than on many mobile phones.
A 4:3 landscape photo fills about three-quarters of the screen on both Homeview and Nest Hub.
Even for still images, the Nest Hub makes better use of the screen area. A photo in 4:3 fills 78 percent of the screen on Nest Hub compared to 75 percent on Homeview. The image is indeed larger on Homeview, 119 cm² versus 108 cm², but this is due to the screen being around 15 percent larger and not to the format. With portrait photos, however, the situation is reversed: they still fill 75 percent of Homeview’s screen, but only 44 percent of Nest Hub’s.
At the same time, there are situations where it the square format fits better. Vertical clips from Tiktok, Instagram and Youtube Shorts do indeed fill the same 56 percent of the surface as a standard 16:9 video, but on a Nest Hub they only occupy a third of the screen area. Web pages typically scale to width and scroll vertically, so they should work fine, and for recipe pages, Apple has built a simplified view into Safari.
Has Apple then chosen a crazy format? For a hub that will mostly display pictures, the calendar and smart home gadgets, the square screen will probably work well. But in the kitchen, for example, where a smart home hub can just as easily show a YouTube video, a series or a match while the food is being prepared, outweigh the disadvantages all the more.
What do you think about the format of Apple’s Homeview? Can you imagine using a smart home hub with a square screen, or do you prefer the format that, for example, the Google Nest Hub uses? The word is free.