First an egg, then a palm tree – something is wrong with these Pokémon evolutions

(Image source: Hachette/GIGA)

It’s nothing new that Pokémon doesn’t always stick to reality. And yet some Pokémon developments still seem to irritate us a little to this day.

Since the first generation of games, you’ve probably asked yourself the question in one development or another: “How on earth can THIS evolve into THIS?” This is often because the Pokémon completely change their appearance after their transformation or have a completely different type than the one they had before. In the worst cases, the Pokémon are no longer recognizable after their evolution.

We have summarized some of these illogical developments for you on the following pages. There are probably some Pokémon among them that have made you suspicious.

Illogical Pokémon Evolutions: Magikarp – Gyarados

(Image source: Hachette)

Let’s first come to one of the most popular examples of illogical developments: the transformation of Magikarp into Gyarados. A seemingly useless, splashing fish is supposed to transform into one of the strongest water monsters in the Pokémon world? It sounds illogical – and it is, but we’ve gotten used to it over time. And somehow the parable of Magikarp and Gyarados seems to have taught us something wise: hard training pays off at some point.

Illogical Pokémon Evolutions: Barschwa – Milotic

(Image source: Hachette)

We can also draw a similar lesson from the development of Barschwa into Milotic, although here we could rather speak of a “transformation from an ugly duckling to a beautiful swan”. You may not believe it, but this ugly fish eventually transforms into one of the most beautiful Pokémon ever. But only under the following, almost ironic conditions: either if it reaches a high beauty value and levels up, or if it has beautiful scales and is traded.

Illogical Pokémon Evolutions: Goldini – Golking

(Image source: Hachette)

Goldini’s physical appearance suggests that it is a female Pokémon, so as a child I assumed that its development would also have feminine traits (although technically the gender split is 50/50 – but I didn’t know that at the time). So you can imagine that I was pretty disappointed when my feminine Goldini became a masculine Golking. But with Pokémon anything is possible, right? It’s just stupid if you’ve already given Goldini a female nickname and later have to live with it as Golking.

Illogical Pokémon Evolutions: Remoraid – Octillery

(Image source: Hachette)

The development from Remoraid to Octillery is at least as disappointing but far more illogical. Because let’s be honest: How the heck is it possible for a fish to suddenly turn into an octopus? Apart from having the same type, the Pokémon have absolutely nothing in common. If the Pokémon were at least similar in color, I might be able to turn a blind eye, but I can’t understand the logic behind this transformation at all.

Illogical Pokémon evolutions: Perlu – Eelabyss or Saganabyss

(Image source: Hachette)

The transformation of Perlu into Aalaybyss or Saganabyss is equally inexplicable. I didn’t know that pearls grow into eels if they carry around a strange stone or tooth long enough. Even the evolution from Aalabyss to Saganabyss (or vice versa) seems far more logical.

Illogical Pokémon evolutions: Schneppke – Firnontor or Frosdedje

(Image source: Hachette)

Something seems to have gone wrong in the development of Schneppke into Firnontor or Frosdedje. Not only do the Pokémon differ fundamentally in their shape, color and appearance, Frosdedje also receives the Ghost type after evolving with the Sparkling Stone. Why is that?

Illogical Pokémon evolutions: Nebulak – Alpollo – Gengar

(Image source: Hachette)

And speaking of ghosts: the development from Nebulak to Alpollo to Gengar is anything but comprehensible. At the beginning the Pokémon is just a round ball surrounded by a purple cloud of mist, later it suddenly grows arms and then ultimately mutates into a pumped-up troll on two legs. And on the outside it bears little resemblance to a ghost.

Illogical Pokémon evolutions: Kleinstein – Georok – Geowaz

(Image source: Hachette)

Additional limbs are apparently not uncommon in Pokémon evolutions. The development from Kleinstein to Georok to Geowaz is similarly bizarre. After his development, Georok not only receives two additional arms, but also a pair of legs. If we ignore this fact, parallels can still be seen between Kleinstein and Georok. At Geowaz at the latest the shock comes: A stone turtle?! It couldn’t be more pointless if you consider that in the course of evolution the Pokémon apparently lost its two additional arms and grew a head and neck instead.

Illogical Pokémon evolutions: Caterpillar – Safcon – Smettbo

(Image source: Hachette)

Let’s now move on to a development that is structured a little more logically and is similar to the development of a butterfly. What initially begins as an inconspicuous caterpillar develops into a cocoon-like Safcon and finally reveals its true beauty as a Smettbo. It’s actually completely logical, isn’t it? If only there wasn’t that one catch…

Illogical Pokémon Evolutions: Bluzuk – Omot

(Image source: Hachette)

… because when you see Bluzuk, you’ll realize that everything didn’t go according to plan. The eyes, the color, the antennae – as similar as Bluzuk and Smettbo are, you would immediately think that the two Pokémon actually belong to the same evolution. And Omot and Safcon could also fit together quite well, at least in terms of their form. And yet it is exactly the other way around. A rumor states that when the Pokédex numbers were assigned, the numbers for Smettbo and Omot were accidentally swapped, which is why the misleading development came about. That would make perfect sense.

Illogical Pokémon Evolutions: Owei – Kokowei

(Image source: Hachette)

The development from Owei to Kokowei makes less sense. The question you are probably asking yourself here is: “How is it possible for a pile of eggs to grow into a huge coconut tree?” Unfortunately, we can’t give you a logical answer. Sometimes we just have to accept things in Pokémon as they are.

Illogical Pokémon evolutions

(Image source: Hachette)

Which of the developments listed here excited you the most?

You can probably think of other illogical Pokémon evolutions that belong on this list.

8 absurd moments in which Ash is a real muscle man

If you can’t get enough of pointless moments in Pokémon, it’s worth taking a look at the absurd situations in which Ash lifts even the heaviest Pokémon with ease.