The aftermath of the “world's largest IT accident” has not yet subsided: Does the “culprit” of 8.5 million computer blue screens not need to pay compensation?

Last Friday, Eastern Time, the world experienced the “largest IT failure in history”:Due to serious errors in the software update of US information security giant CrowdStrike, a large number of Windows computers around the world using the software have collectively fallen into a “sea of ​​blue screens”.

As of Sunday Eastern Time, Microsoft reported that a total of 8.5 million devices were affected worldwide. Although CrowdStrike has fixed the relevant configuration errors and Microsoft has released recovery tools to help IT administrators repair Windows hosts, it will still take several days to fully resolve the problem.

In addition, the series of damages caused by this IT disaster cannot be ignored, and the relevant legal responsibilities and compensation issues are still to be discussed. However, according to the terms of CrowdStrike's agreement, the company may not need to pay compensation for this global accident.

8.5 million computers worldwide go on strike

Last Friday, Eastern Time, due to an unexpected incompatibility between a software update pushed by cybersecurity giant CrowdStrike and the Windows system,Airlines, media, banks and retail companies around the world that use Microsoft Windows systems have been catastrophically affected, with many airports, shopping malls, hotels, offices, factories and stock exchanges paralyzed.

On Sunday, Eastern Time, CrowdStrike said that 8.5 million Windows system devices were affected and down due to defects related to software update content, most of which have been restored to online operation.

They stressed that the outage only affected Windows hosts, and Mac and Linux hosts were not affected. They said that the software update error has been identified and isolated, and the company has deployed a fix.

Microsoft also said in a blog post: “We currently estimate that the CrowdStrike update affects 8.5 million Windows devices, less than 1% of all Windows devices… Although the percentage is small, the broad economic and social impact reflects that enterprises operating many critical services use CrowdStrike.”

Microsoft has released a recovery tool to try to help IT administrators repair Windows hosts affected by the CrowdStrike bug update. The tool creates a bootable USB drive that IT administrators can use to help quickly recover affected machines.

It will still take several days to resolve the issue

Although CrowdStrike claims that the relevant configuration errors have been fixed and Microsoft has released a repair tool, it will still take several days to fully resolve the series of problems caused by this error. Especially for organizations and enterprises with complex systems, this global chain of damage is not easy to reverse.

“We think it will take three to five days to resolve the problem,” said Eric O'Neill, a U.S. cybersecurity expert. “That's a long downtime for the agency.”

Vasileios Karagiannopoulos, a cybersecurity researcher at the University of Portsmouth, said the problems “may take days or even weeks to resolve.” He added that the issues are “so pervasive and widespread in the system that technical support may become scarce due to lack of demand.”

Kevin Beaumont, a cybersecurity researcher, said CrowdStrike customers are facing an “extremely painful” process to resolve the issue, “with the only option being to recover manually,” he said.“You have to go into the server or PC, boot it up in safe mode in the console, log in as an administrator, and then basically hack the system to get it back online.”

CrowdStrike doesn’t need to lose money?

After such a major global cybersecurity incident, related legal and compensation issues have also become a focus of attention.

The first thing to pay attention to is whether CrowdStrike needs to compensate the affected companies. The answer to this question is probably “No”.

Despite the global industry losses,But under the terms of the cybersecurity company’s agreement, CrowdStrike does not have to pay any compensation beyond a simple refund.

The terms of the agreement for CrowdStrike's Falcon security software already limit liability to “fees paid.”

“This means that if a company were to claim compensation from CrowdStrike for lost business or revenue, the most it could recover would be the amount it paid to CrowdStrike,” said Elizabeth Burgin Waller, chair of Woods Rogers' cybersecurity and data privacy practice.

However, some cybersecurity experts have analyzed that affected companies could consider suing CrowdStrike for compensation for losses caused by business interruption. However, considering that software companies usually bear almost no responsibility for major interruptions and cybersecurity incidents, the compensation that such lawsuits can win may be negligible.

despite this,Analysts still expect CrowdStrike itself to take a big hit, especially as the company will likely have to spend a lot of money to rebuild its reputation after this issue is resolved.

“We think there will be financial consequences to this issue,” said Keith Bachman, senior research analyst at BMO Capital Markets. “For example, we think customers will seek damages and compensation, which we think will likely include discounts on new and renewal contracts. So we think there will likely be an impact on growth rates and cash for the business.”

CITIC Securities Research Report pointed out that the configuration update error of CrowdStrike may cause the company to face certain economic losses and more serious reputational losses. This accident may cause CrowdStrike's existing and potential customers to reconsider their partnership, and CrowdStrike's main competitors may benefit from it.

Are airlines required to provide compensation?

In addition, in this accident, do the airlines that were most affected need to refund or compensate consumers for flight cancellations? The answer is “not necessarily”.

The aftermath of the

Global flight cancellations surged from last Friday to Sunday

Under EU law, airlines must offer passengers an alternative flight or give them a full refund or compensation if a flight is delayed for more than three hours or canceled altogether. However, there are exceptions to this rule, such as weather conditions and safety risks, because these are beyond the control of the airlines. Therefore, EU airlines are likely to consider the suspension as “exceptional circumstances” beyond their control.

The situation in the UK is similar. Last Friday, the UK Civil Aviation Authority (CAA) sent a letter to industry executives,The airline said the outage could be considered an “extraordinary circumstance”, meaning it had no obligation to compensate affected passengers.The letter allegedly read in part: “It is unlikely that passengers will be entitled to a fixed sum of compensation.”

Under U.S. law, there is no industry-wide standard for compensation for stranded passengers, and most airlines set their own compensation policies. However, the U.S. Department of Transportation has confirmed that they believe the flight disruptions related to the IT problem are a “controllable risk” and is pressuring airlines to help cover the costs of the incident.

“We've reminded airlines that if they experience significant delays, they have a responsibility to take care of their customers,” said U.S. Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg.