The recent “oil tanker incident” has been a hot topic and has been a big drama in recent days.
On July 2, after a long investigation, the reporter found that the same tanker truck that had been loaded with coal-to-liquid liquids (CTL) and kerosene continued to transport edible oil without being cleaned. This phenomenon of mixing tanker trucks seems to have become an unspoken rule in the industry.
This report quickly attracted attention from all parties, and a number of official media outlets stepped in to speak out about this chaos.
The self-media quickly followed up and uncovered more information.
For example, blogger @高剑栗 foundA truck mentioned in the news repeatedly transported goods to different edible oil manufacturers and coal-to-oil manufacturers within half a year.
More details were exposed, and the manufacturers who were exposed this time also began to respond:
For example, China National Grain and Oils Reserves Corporation stated that the entire system will carry out in-depth special inspections.
Many listed companies, including Golden Dragon Fish, say that there is no problem with their oil.
The State Council Food Safety Office also set up a joint investigation team the day before yesterday to thoroughly investigate this issue.
As of now, the whole matter has not been completely concluded. Please wait patiently for the subsequent official announcement.
We think there are many things we can talk about here, such as the dangers of mixed loading in oil tankers and why previous tests failed to detect the problem.
First of all, it is certain that the practice of mixing edible oils not only violates morality, but also breaks the legal bottom line. Teacher Luo Xiang even directly described this behavior as “tantamount to poisoning.”
Many people may have only a simple objection to the practice of filling coal-to-oil and then filling it with edible oil: How can the oil for human consumption be mixed with coal-to-oil for industrial use?
But we may not have any idea of how much harm it does.
Let’s put it this way, coal-to-oil is the process of converting coal into industrial oil through a series of reactions such as catalytic hydrogenation of coal. It is also one of the many mineral oils.
Most of these mineral oils, including coal-to-liquid oil, contain harmful substances such as cycloalkanes (MOSH), aromatic hydrocarbons (MOAH), sulfides and heavy metals. Among them, the most worrying are aromatic hydrocarbon compounds.
The structure of aromatic hydrocarbon compounds is quite stable, and the polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) among them are very toxic and are also highly toxic to the human body. They can be called the scavengers of the chemical world.
If you consume food contaminated with mineral oil for a long time, you are likely to experience symptoms such as vomiting, diarrhea, and coma, and your nervous system, respiratory system, etc. will be damaged.
According to the report of Beijing News,If the tank is not cleaned after unloading the coal-to-liquid, there will usually be several kilograms to more than ten kilograms of coal-to-liquid left in the tank.
If we use a 30-ton tanker truck as an example, the concentration of aromatics in the contaminated vegetable oil can reach 16.5 mg/kg, while the EU recommends that the content be controlled within 0.5 mg/kg.
I think you all understand how big the gap is between 16.5 and 0.5.
In addition, this report also mentionedMixed loading of industrial wastewater, plasticizer, waste oil, water reducing agent, etc.There are many more issues that have not been reported. Who knows what other chemical reagents have been installed?
What’s even more frightening is that this is not the first time that similar incidents of mixing tanker trucks have been reported.
As early as 2015, similar situations were reported by reporters from Hunan and Nanning City, but they were not taken seriously by the outside world at the time, so much time has passed and the situation has not improved.
Even Hunan reporters found out thatAfter transporting caustic soda, the tanker truck was simply washed with water and started transporting oil again.
So the question is, is there a problem with storing cooking oil this way? If there is a problem, why has it not been discovered?
We looked up some information and found that there are actually quite a few regulations here.
For example, the issue of transporting edible oil by tank trucks involves multiple laws and regulations from four departments, including development and reform, transportation, public security, and market supervision.
Every law and every regulation requires that the process must be safe and harmless, etc., and the shipping details of edible oil are mainly based on the national standard “Specifications for Bulk Transportation of Edible Vegetable Oil GB/T 30354-2013”.
It does say in there that, for example, containers need to be cleaned regularly, someone should be assigned to be responsible, and then professionals should be asked to check them.
When filling oil, it is necessary to check whether the container meets the standards.
It seems that the regulations are quite detailed, but if you think about it carefully, there are many tricks involved.
First of all, this is a national recommended standard. Although in general,There is a good consensus among Chinese companies that the standards set internally are generally higher than the recommended national standards.
However, its regulatory strength is certainly not as strong as that of mandatory standards, so it is easy for the company to set high standards and it is difficult to truly implement them.
This incident is similar. Several large oil companies have regulations for tank inspections, but they may not be implemented at all.
Now let's talk about cleaning tanker trucks. The national standard states that oil tankers need to be special edible oil tankers, but they are allowed to transport different types of edible oil.
In fact, even if the same type of oil is transported for a long time, the tanker truck needs to clean the tank, and cleaning the tanker truck is much more difficult than everyone imagines.
Because although the tanker looks like a cylinder on the outside, many partitions are set inside the tank to prevent the wave effect.
Moreover, when the tanker truck transports oil for a long time, the “old oil stains” will further increase the difficulty of cleaning. Water is not enough. If chemical reagents are used, how to remove the chemical reagents becomes a problem again.
We also consulted relevant people who sell automatic tanker cleaning equipment in China, and they said that few people in China buy this thing.
If the cleaning is done manually, many accidents have occurred over the years.
Therefore, this kind of troublesome work is naturally not cheap.
According to the original report of Beijing News, it may be several hundred or thousands of yuan. However, after further investigation, some media found that the cleaning cost of the tanker truck may reach 1,500-2,500 yuan, which is higher than the original report.
With the ever-increasing safety regulations in recent years, the transportation costs of tank trucks have continued to rise, and the market for tank truck drivers has become increasingly saturated. As a result, everyone is looking for ways to save money, and in the end the tank washing process, which is both troublesome and not taken seriously, is omitted.

Although according to regulations, large grain and oil companies should require oil tankers to present inspection reports from third-party professional organizations before loading oil, it seems that the enforcement strength may be smaller than expected.
Therefore, in actual operation, oil tankers are prone to mixing problems.
Then you may want to ask, why were oil quality problems not detected in past finished oil inspections?
Some people may think that this is similar to the melamine incident. Who would have thought that mineral oil would be checked in vegetable oil?
But after checking various sources, we found that the story of edible oil and mineral oil has a long history.
For example, as early as in a report in 2000, Xinxiang, Henan Province, had carried out mineral oil testing in edible oil throughout the city, and found quite a few problems.
Not only that, as mentioned earlier, this is not the first time that mixed loading of tank trucks has been reported by the media.
Why, this report was discovered by the media instead of being detected?
This may be related to the current national standards for edible oil products.
Because currently, our mandatory national standards do not require the testing of mineral oil components.
Moreover, we clearly have relevant inspection methods. For example, in the two documents “GB/T 37514-2019” and the grain industry standard “Determination of Saturated Hydrocarbons and Aromatic Hydrocarbons in Animal and Plant Fats and Oils for Grain and Oil Inspection”, the saponification method, alumina thin film chromatography and liquid chromatography-gas chromatography are mentioned respectively to determine the mineral oil components in animal and plant fats and oils.
Oh, by the way, one of the standard setters is China National Grain and Oils Reserves Corporation.
But similar to the previous transportation standard, this is still a recommended standard. As for how many grain and oil companies and food processing plants will conduct testing for this recommended standard, it is unknown.
We also consulted relevant people, and recommended several testing methods in national standards and industry standards, but they were not quite satisfactory.
For example, the most widely used saponification method and fluorescence method have a minimum detection limit of 0.3-0.5%. That is to say, concentrations below this cannot be detected. So is it healthy for the human body if the concentration is below this? We can only say that we don't know.

After this incident, many people may think that if domestic oil monitoring is not perfect enough, then I will just drink imported oil.
But I'm not saying it's my fault, maybe the ones made abroad aren't that good either.
To put it bluntly, the uses of mineral oil are too wide. It is an indispensable raw material in many oil processing and product packaging, so it can easily migrate into food.
Processing of potato chips, packaging of chocolate and milk powder may contain mineral oil migration.
As early as 2019, the European non-governmental organization Foodwatch detected MOAH in infant formula, which attracted widespread attention.
In 2021, Foodwatch collected 152 products across Europe and found that one in eight products tested contained large amounts of mineral oil.
Therefore, the European Commission was prompted to introduce restrictions on mineral oil aromatic hydrocarbons in food in 2022.
But similar to our recommended national standards, the EU also issues recommendations for non-mandatory standards, and specific details will depend on the actions of each member state.
The problem of mixed loading of tank trucks also exists overseas. Similarly, they do not have official detailed regulations, but rely on a “non-profit” organization such as EFTCO, the European Federation of Tank Cleaning Organizations, to set up standards and liaise with cleaning plants.

For this reason, they will issue a certificate of conformity every time they complete cleaning. Without this certificate, most oil refineries will not fill oil.
But at the same time, they cannot guarantee that the clothes are washed completely clean, and cases of forged certificates of conformity occur from time to time.

In the United States, although the regulations are very detailed, oil refineries and drivers must ensure that oil tanks are clean and hygienic.
But in fact, the tanker drivers on their side said that it could not be cleaned at all.
After some research, I was puzzled. Has it turned out that people all over the world have been drinking mineral oil for decades?
Moreover, journalists really got a lot of credit this time, as the issues they have been reporting on for more than a decade have never been perfectly resolved.
But then again, in my opinion, this incident does not present a problem to us, but a phenomenon.
If we only talk about the problem of mixed loading in tank trucks, we can improve the national standard, make it mandatory, allocate some funds, and develop new technology to wash the tanks, and probably solve the problem well.
But if this loophole disappears, then another “bad oil” will appear. Do we have to debug it again?
So behind the problem, what deserves more attention is that maintaining food safety cannot be achieved solely by laws or national standards.
To put it bluntly, no matter how good a chef is, he cannot use a pot that has been filled with arsenic to cook for customers. This is not something the law can regulate at all.
Safety on the dining table is an area that always needs to be improved. Regulations are lagging, and patching will always be a step behind.
Ultimately, it is the responsibility of every food factory to strictly control every link in food manufacturing and pursue better food safety standards. National standards should be the bottom line, not the upper limit of food manufacturing.


















