I advise you not to play.
These are the top 10 most popular games on the gaming platform Steam, including many old faces, such as Dota2 released in 2016, PlayerUnknown's Battlegrounds (PUBG) released in 2018, and GTA 5 with global sales of over 200 million copies.
But now, there is a weird thing in the list – Banana.
This mini-game, which was launched in April this year, has attracted a large number of players since its launch.Since mid-June, the number of players has exploded, with the highest number of online players exceeding 890,000 so far..
Banana historical player online statistics | Image source: Steam
Absurdly, Banana is a game where you can do nothing but click – click on the bananas, and the numbers on the screen will increase, and that's all there is to it.
Banana game interface|Image source: Steam
This alone is of course not enough to attract nearly a million players, but if the developer tells:Do you have the chance to get virtual items for free that can be sold for thousands of dollars?”
The developer has introduced an economic system for Banana, which allows players to randomly obtain bananas with different skins as their online time increases. These bananas can be sold on the Steam platform to earn real money for players.
To put it simply, this is an NFT-like game in the form of a banana peel.
Banananomics
The real gameplay of Banana is this: every 3 minutes a player is online, he or she has the chance to get a Banana. When the time accumulates to 3 hours, the player will get at least one Banana; after 18 hours, a rare Banana can be obtained. According to YouTuber Jauwn, he has already obtained 3 Bananas in just 10 minutes online.
After obtaining these bananas, players can list them for sale on the Steam market. The rarer the banana, the higher the price. For example, there are only 25 Crypticnana, which was sold for $378.92 on May 31st; as the number of gamers increased, the price of Crypticnana also rose to $514 on June 11th. Currently, there are 5 Crypticnana for sale on the Steam market, and the lowest price is as high as $942.71.
The Special Golden Banana is currently the most expensive Banana sold, selling for $1,345.01 on June 11.
There are currently more than 100 types of Banana in the Banana game. Most of them are priced below $1, such as Moonnana, which is the most common, at only $0.03.
At present, Banana has formed a simple economic system on its own. Developers produce Banana, and players obtain Banana through “labor”. Players can earn money by selling Banana. The rarer the Banana, the more people will chase it, and the higher the price.
But in the final analysis, these Bananas are just digital images. Developers can create these images at no cost, set the probability of dropping, and artificially create scarcity. Someone can buy a Banana for $1,000, but it doesn't mean that they can sell it for the same price. Over time, once the popularity of Bananas has passed, these Bananas that were purchased at a huge cost are likely to be worthless.
Hery, a member of the development team, also mentioned in an interview with Polygon: “I believe the reason why it (Banana) is popular is because it is a legitimate 'infinite money glitch'.”
This is somewhat similar to NFT. The difference is that Banana does not use any blockchain technology. In other words, the story of “uniqueness” told by NFT does not exist on Banana.
Only fools will be fooled?
It is obvious at first glance that this is a game of passing the parcel. The developer will naturally get the most profit, and the platform Steam will also get a 5% commission on each transaction.
Who will take over at the high price? It is the retail investors who bought Banana at the high price.
In this case, why does Banana attract so many players?
In psychology, there is a Dunning-Kruger effect. It describes a cognitive bias.Refers to the situation where people with limited abilities have a false sense of superiority and mistakenly believe they are better than they really are..
In the case of Banana, people tend to overestimate themselves and think that they will not be the unlucky one who takes over at a high price.
The theory of behavioral economics can also explain the psychology of players. In 1713, Swiss mathematician Nicolas Bernoulli proposed the “St. Peter's Paradox”.
Suppose there is a coin game where every time a coin is flipped, the prize money is doubled as long as it lands on heads, but the player must end the game as soon as tails lands once.
Therefore, if the initial bet is 2 yuan, there is a 1/2 probability that the player can win 2 yuan (throwing a head once), a 1/4 probability of winning 4 yuan (throwing two heads in a row), and a 1/8 probability of winning 8 yuan (throwing three heads in a row).
If we only consider the expected value, the amount of money can grow infinitely, and theoretically many people should want to participate in the game. But Bernoulli found that few people were willing to do so. In his own words, “Although standard calculations show that the expected value (of players) is infinite, … it must be admitted that any normal person would be very happy to sell his entry for twenty gold coins.”
The St. Petersburg paradox reveals that naive decisions made based solely on expected value may not be adopted by anyone in real life.
Banana actually promises an “infinitely growing amount of money”, but unlike the St. Petersburg Paradox, it does not require an “entry ticket” (bet). Instead, any Steam player can get the opportunity to “win unlimited money” without any threshold.
This is a huge psychological incentive, because since there is “nothing to lose” anyway, more people will try their luck with a try-it-out mentality. Even if they don't make money, in most cases they won't lose anything.
But when the bubble bursts, someone will always pay for it.




