He got hit by a blow before he even achieved anything.
BMW's all-electric MINI has encountered difficult obstacles before it was officially put into mass production and sales in China.
According to Reuters, BMW's all-electric MINI produced in China may face the highest electric vehicle tariff of 38.1%, “which may deal a fatal blow to the sales prospects of this mid-range car.”
Moreover, if the pure electric MINIs produced in China in the future face maximum tariffs, MINI's global new energy vehicle strategy will also be disrupted.
The pure electric MINI is a key step in BMW's pure electric strategy. Its role is like that of Smart in the Mercedes-Benz system. However, seeing that Smart is making rapid progress in the field of electrification, MINI must speed up its pace.
Now that the product has not yet officially entered the market, it has encountered this kind of “force majeure”, which is somewhat pessimistic.
Disaster to “family members”
The reason why the highest level of tariffs was imposed was because it did not cooperate with the EU investigation.
People familiar with the matter revealed that because the all-electric MINI model is still in the early stages of development, Beam Automotive seems unable to complete the European Commission's investigation and has therefore been classified as a company “unable to cooperate with the investigation.”
BMW has not responded so far.
However, some media also revealed that the BMW Group is holding urgent consultations within the group on how to deal with this matter after promoting phased tariffs to prevent MINI from becoming the European automaker that suffers the most in this anti-subsidy investigation.
This is interesting. When the EU implements a policy of temporary tariffs, the people who suffer the most are actually its own people.
Of course, strictly speaking, the pure electric version of MINI is already half “Chinese”. In July 2018, Great Wall and BMW signed an agreement to establish a joint venture company, Beam Automotive, with each party holding 50% of the shares, with a total investment of 5.1 billion yuan, and the address was set in Zhangjiagang.
At that time, Beam Automotive's mission was to jointly develop a new generation of pure electric vehicle platforms. In addition to producing BMW MINI electric vehicles, it would also produce Great Wall's own brand electric vehicles.
According to the plan, Beam Automotive's products will enter the respective sales and service networks of BMW Group and Great Wall Motors according to their brands.
At the beginning of the cooperation between BMW and Great Wall, BMW said: “China has become the world's largest electric vehicle market. The localization of MINI pure electric models has become a key factor in the sustainable development of MINI.”
Last September, the BMW Group announced that the next generation of MINI pure electric models will be put into production in China, with Beam Automotive, a joint venture between the BMW Group and Great Wall Motors, as the world's first production location and main export base for the new car.
Behind this announcement is the BMW Group's intention to stop producing MINI electric models at its Oxford plant in the UK and transfer the production line to China.
At the time, Stefanie Wurst, head of the BMW MINI brand, said the Oxford plant was “not ready for electric vehicles” because it had to produce both electric and gasoline vehicles on the same production line, making its operation inefficient.
Therefore, the responsibility now falls on the head of Spotlight Automotive. According to the plan, the next generation of pure electric MINI models will have two models, a new three-door MINI Cooper and a new MINI compact crossover (MINI Aceman). Both models are planned to be put into production successively at the Spotlight Automotive factory and supplied to the international and domestic markets in 2024.
One month later, the domestically produced new three-door pure electric MINI Cooper officially rolled off the production line at the Zhangjiagang plant of Spotlight Automotive, and the first batch of SOP models were only for export.
However, it should be noted that according to the original plan, the first mass-produced new car of Beam Auto should be off the assembly line around 2022. However, due to various problems, such as production qualifications, it has not been launched on the market.
However, the pure electric vehicle market is changing rapidly at the moment, and the pure electric MINI does not seem to have seized the initiative in terms of price or the timing of its launch into the market.
In December 2019, Geely Group and Mercedes-Benz jointly invested in the establishment of Smart Automobile (i.e. Smart), with each party holding 50% of the shares. Mercedes-Benz will design the car, Geely will be responsible for R&D and production, and it will be built on Geely's SEA vast platform.
In June 2023, its first model, Smart Elf #1, was officially launched. Currently, Smart has two models on sale: Smart Elf #1 and Smart Elf #3. Data shows that the cumulative sales of the Smart brand in the first quarter of this year have reached nearly 5,000 units.
The MINI Aceman, which is about to be mass-produced, has a similar positioning to the Smart Elf #1, both of which are small pure electric SUVs. When it is really launched, MINI Aceman will not only face the threat from the Smart Elf, but also face the high tariffs brought by sales.
According to the current price of the first car produced by MINI and Great Wall and unveiled in Europe, 35,000 euros is slightly higher than the selling price of Chinese cars such as BYD Dolphin or MG 4 in Europe.
Based on MINI's brand positioning and market audience, if calculated based on a comprehensive tariff of 48.1% (10% + 38.1%), will MINI still have an advantage in Europe?
Are European car companies the most affected?
Of course, the root of all this lies in the EU’s “tariff stick”.
On June 12, the European Commission decided to impose additional tariffs ranging from 17.4% to 38.1% on electric vehicles imported from China starting next month, on top of the current 10% tariff.

This means that when combined with the existing 10% import tax, Chinese automakers will face tariffs of 27.4%-48.1%.
The reason for this decision was that the Chinese government was believed to have provided unreasonable subsidies to its electric vehicle industry, harming the interests of European manufacturers.
As for the additional tariffs, they are euphemistically called temporary countervailing duties.
Among the three Chinese automakers participating in the sampling, BYD is expected to be subject to a 17.4% temporary tariff, Geely is expected to be subject to a 20% temporary tariff, and SAIC is expected to be subject to a 38.1% temporary tariff. Chinese electric vehicle manufacturers that participated in the survey but have not yet been sampled will be subject to a weighted average tariff of 21%; other Chinese electric vehicle manufacturers that did not cooperate with the survey will be subject to a remaining tariff of 38.1%.
Teslas produced in China will be subject to a separate tax rate, which is not yet known.
The European Commission said that if no solution can be reached with China, the additional tariffs will be implemented around July 4.
Before the resolution is finally implemented, the EU and its member states will make a final vote. If the number of votes against is greater than the number of votes in favor, the resolution can be cancelled. However, it is certain that if the resolution is implemented, the cost of buying cars for European consumers will increase significantly, which is definitely “harming others and not benefiting oneself”.
Many Wall Street analysts have also warned that the European Commission's decision to impose tariffs on Chinese imported electric vehicles may have limited impact on Chinese auto companies, but will instead have a significant impact on European automakers.
Kevin Lau, an analyst at Japan's Daiwa Securities, said that in the first four months of this year, the European market's contribution to the total sales of BYD, Geely and SAIC was only between 1% and 3%, which shows that the EU market has a very limited impact on the overall sales of Chinese automakers.
On the other hand, EU tariffs are unlikely to prevent Chinese automakers from continuing to enter the European market, as they have sufficient cost advantages to absorb the additional tariff costs while still remaining profitable.
At the same time, many Chinese car companies have also been rapidly expanding into the European market and achieving localization in recent years.
But when it comes to European car companies, the situation is not quite right.
China is the most important single market for many European car companies. It is not so much that China has seized the European market, but rather that China has provided these foreign companies with the “soil” for their thriving growth.
In the first quarter of this year, the Chinese market accounted for nearly 32% of BMW's sales and about 30% of Volkswagen and Mercedes-Benz's sales. Therefore, these automakers are generally worried that tariffs on China may lead to countermeasures for German automakers such as BMW, Porsche, Volkswagen, and Mercedes-Benz.
It is not difficult to understand why the people most pessimistic about the news of imposing temporary tariffs are precisely the EU’s own people.
BMW Group Chairman Zipse has stated that the EU's imposition of tariffs on Chinese electric vehicles is a wrong decision. Imposing tariffs will not only hinder the development of European car companies, but will also harm Europe's own interests. This policy “will only shoot itself in the foot.”
Volkswagen CEO Stephen Schwarz even warned, “Just wait for China's countermeasures.”
Nowadays, BMW's pure electric MINI has become the first innocent “victim” to be caught in the crossfire. BMW's iX3 is in a similar situation to the pure electric MINI. Since 2021, BMW Brilliance has been producing the electric BMW iX3 for export from China to Europe.
As more and more of “our own people” are affected, the next to be anxious will be the EU itself.







