In 2023, GAC Group (SH: 601238) had a revenue of 128.76 billion yuan, a year-on-year increase of 17.5%; annual sales were 2.5 million units, a year-on-year increase of 2.9% (ranking fifth among national auto companies); but non-net profit was 3.57 billion yuan, a year-on-year decrease of 52.3%.
The three major indicators of revenue, sales volume and non-GAAP net profit showed two increases and one decrease.
In the first quarter of 2024, GAC Group's revenue fell by 19.1% year-on-year, quarterly sales fell by 29.1% year-on-year, and non-net profit fell by 52.1% year-on-year. All three indicators fell sharply.
In May 2024, GAC Group's monthly sales fell by 25.3% year-on-year. Among them, GAC Honda and GAC Toyota's sales fell by 41.3% and 17% respectively; Aion, which was highly expected, saw its monthly sales fall by 32.2% (the cumulative sales in the first five months fell by 38.7%), and its IPO prospects are not optimistic.
In recent years, new energy vehicles have been advancing rapidly and have quickly occupied the traditional fuel vehicle market. However, GAC's Japanese fuel vehicles have outstanding energy-saving advantages, and their sales have grown against the trend, with market performance far exceeding that of German and American joint venture brands.
Aion started early and got off to a fast start. In 2023, its sales volume reached 480,000 units, ranking third in the national new energy vehicle sales list, only behind BYD and Tesla.
With energy-saving fuel vehicles as its basic base, GAC Group has built the fast-growing Aion into its “second growth curve”. A year ago, in the eyes of many investors, GAC Group had a bright future.
Man proposes, God disposes. Entering 2024, new energy vehicles, with performance (range, fuel economy) and price as the banner, have entered the hinterland of traditional fuel vehicles – Japanese fuel-efficient vehicles, and GAC Group is the first to bear the brunt. Originally, the daily life was colorful, but now there is an urge to “turn the table”.
Independent and beautiful, joint venture to make money to support the family
Independent brands and joint venture brands are the two main pillars of GAC Group. Almost all of the listed company's vehicle sales revenue comes from independent brands, while profits come from joint venture brands (investment income from associated/joint ventures).
1) Domestic brands’ revenue increased but profits did not
Since 2017, GAC's own brand revenue has maintained “double-digit growth” and will almost “double” by 2023, but the gross profit is quite meager:
In 2017, GAC's vehicle manufacturing business revenue was 50.2 billion, gross profit was 11.2 billion, and gross profit margin was as high as 22.2%;
In 2018, GAC's gross profit from vehicle manufacturing business revenue dropped to 8.2 billion, with a gross profit margin of 16.3%;
In 2019, the situation took a sharp turn for the worse, with revenue from vehicle business reaching 36 billion yuan, a year-on-year decrease of 28.5%; gross profit was only 1.1 billion yuan, with a gross profit margin of 3%.
Since then, the gross profit margin of GAC's vehicle manufacturing business has been hovering at a low level.
In 2023, the vehicle manufacturing business will have revenue of 94 billion yuan, gross profit of 3.7 billion yuan, and gross profit margin of 3.9%.
Domestic brands have not yet really started to make money, but the price war has already spread like wildfire.
The CEO of GAC said in a recent speech: Expanding the auto industry is not a solution, the goal of a business is to make a profit… What is heartbreaking is that the gross profit margin of the “king of expansion” is as high as 23%.
2) Investment income has lasted for three years
GAC Group's net profit comes from investment income from associated/joint ventures. In the past ten years (2014-2023), investment income exceeded the net profit of the fiscal year in seven years.
In recent years, the sales and profits of joint venture brands under other automobile groups have dropped sharply:
For example, Changan Automobile's investment income peaked from 2014 to 2017. In 2016, Changan Ford alone contributed 9 billion yuan in investment income, exceeding its non-GAAP net profit. Since 2018, investment income has fallen sharply, seriously dragging down the group's performance.
SAIC Motor's investment income from its joint ventures has remained stable at more than 25 billion for many years. In 2019, it slightly dropped to 23 billion; in 2020, it plummeted to 14.3 billion; in 2022 and 2023, it will be 10.8 billion and 10.7 billion respectively.
The joint venture brands of automobile groups such as Changan and SAIC have declined around 2019, but Guangben and Guangfeng have grown against the trend:
In 2021, the investment income contributed by GAC Group's joint ventures exceeded 10 billion for the first time; in 2022, it reached 13.4 billion.
In 2023, the situation suddenly changed, and the investment income contributed by joint ventures dropped sharply to 7.9 billion. However, the ratio of investment income to net profit increased to 179%, indicating that the performance of independent brands was even worse.
Fuel efficiency is the most prominent advantage of Japanese cars, making them the “last bastion” of fuel vehicles. Compared with SAIC and Changan, GAC has been able to make huge profits from joint ventures for three more years.
Energy-saving vehicles and new energy vehicles
Japanese automakers, represented by Toyota, are committed to hydrogen energy technology and believe that pure electric vehicles are a transition and not the best solution.
Traditional fuel vehicle companies all have similar views, but when choosing other transition plans, Japanese companies focus on HEV (hybrid electric vehicle), German companies mostly focus on MHEV (mild hybrid), and Chinese car companies such as BYD focus on PHEV (plug-in hybrid).
Since the HEVs of Guangben and Guangfeng do not have a pure electric driving mode, they cannot be listed as new energy vehicles. Guangzhou has come up with a “local policy” – the “Energy-Saving Vehicle Catalog”. Although the models in the catalog cannot get green license plates like new energy vehicles, the chance of winning the lottery is greatly increased. It is difficult for ordinary fuel vehicles to get a license plate, but the chance of winning the lottery for energy-saving vehicles can be as high as 100%.
Unsurprisingly, the protagonist of Guangzhou's Energy-Saving Car Catalog is GAC, including hybrid or “dual-engine” models of Accord, Camry, Levin, Wildlander, Haoying, Odyssey, etc. Since they are not plug-in hybrids, the relevant models can only be named “energy-saving cars” and enjoy the “host” treatment in Guangzhou.
Compared with the radical new energy route (such as BYD stopping production of fuel vehicles), GAC’s advantageous strategy is to “gradually improve” fuel vehicles into energy-saving vehicles.
In the first half of 2021, GAC's sales of new energy vehicles and energy-saving vehicles were 52,000 and 123,000 units respectively, with new energy vehicles accounting for only 5% of total sales;
In the second half of 2022, GAC's new energy vehicle sales were close to 200,000 units, accounting for 15% of total sales, but still 37,000 units less than energy-saving vehicle sales;
In each quarter of 2023, GAC's new energy vehicle sales surpassed energy-saving vehicles in all aspects, mainly due to the rise of Aion – in Q2, Q3, and Q4, Aion's quarterly sales were all above 100,000 units. Among them, Q3 sales reached 142,000 units, accounting for 90% of GAC's new energy vehicle sales and 22.5% of GAC's total sales. This quarter, GAC's new energy vehicles accounted for 25% for the first time.
According to original forecasts, by 2035, traditional fuel vehicles will still account for as much as 50% of China's new car sales.
This is a market with annual sales of more than 10 million units, and we should not give up. From the perspective of energy conservation and emission reduction, efforts to reduce the fuel consumption of hundreds of millions of fuel vehicles will benefit the country, the people, and the environment (assuming that by 2035, annual sales of traditional fuel vehicles will exceed 10 million units).
Plans cannot keep up with changes. In December 2023, Miao Wei predicted that the goal of “new energy vehicle penetration exceeding 50%” could be achieved ten years ahead of schedule, that is, in 2025. In fact, in May 2024, the domestic new energy vehicle penetration rate was close to 50%.
Some organizations even boldly predict that the penetration rate of new energy vehicles in China will reach 90% by 2035!
The era of fuel vehicles ended ten years ahead of schedule, which was beyond the expectations of Toyota and Honda, and also disrupted GAC's overall planning.
No wonder I'm in a bad mood
GAC Group has many subsidiaries, which can be summarized into two pillars: one is the joint venture brand, including GAC Honda, GAC Toyota, GAC Mitsubishi, etc.; the other is the independent brand, including GAC Passenger Cars, GAC Aion, etc.
In 2017, GAC's total sales increased by 21.3% year-on-year, exceeding 2 million units for the first time. GAC Honda and GAC Toyota sold 705,000 and 422,000 units respectively. The sales of GAC's own brand passenger cars exceeded GAC Toyota, reaching 509,000 units, accounting for 25.4% of the group's total sales.
In 2018, GAC's total sales reached a record high of 2.148 million units, a year-on-year increase of 7.3%; the sales of Toyota and Honda were 741,000 and 580,000 respectively. The sales of GAC's own brand passenger cars were 535,000, accounting for 24.9%.
GAC's sales stagnated in 2019 and 2020. In 2021, it regained its upward momentum, with annual sales of 2.14 million units, including 780,000 Honda and 828,000 Toyota; and 444,000 self-owned brands (including 120,000 new energy brand Aion).
In 2022, GAC's sales increased by 13.5% year-on-year, reaching a record 2.434 million units. Guangfeng's sales exceeded 1 million, a year-on-year increase of 20%; the sales of its own brands reached 634,000 units (including 270,000 Aion units), accounting for 26%.
In 2023, GAC's sales volume will further increase to 2.5 million units. The sales volume of GAC Honda and GAC Toyota declined, while the sales volume of its own brands increased by nearly 40%, accounting for more than 35%.
Until 2023, GAC Group's sales have maintained an upward momentum for two reasons:
First, joint venture brands will remain strong until 2022. Despite the decline of GAC Mitsubishi, GAC Fiat Chrysler, GAC Hino and other brands, GAC Honda's sales remain strong, and GAC Toyota even achieved growth against the trend. In 2017, GAC Toyota's sales were 442,000 units, and in 2022 it exceeded 1 million units, with an average annual compound growth rate of 17.7%.
In contrast, SAIC Volkswagen's sales volume reached 2.1 million units in 2018, but less than 1.22 million units in 2023; SAIC GM's sales volume reached 1.96 million units in 2018, but fell to 1 million units in 2023. In just five years, the sales volume of the two joint venture brands fell by a total of 1.84 million units!
Secondly, when the sales of Japanese joint venture brands declined, domestic brands grew strongly. In 2023, the “two Toyotas” finally couldn't hold on, with Guangben's sales falling by 13.7% and Toyota's falling by 5.5%, a total of 156,000 units less than in 2022, while domestic brands sold 251,000 more units, allowing GAC Group's sales to continue to grow.
“Joint venture brands are tenacious and independent brands are striving for success.” With these two major pillars, GAC Group is having a much better time than SAIC, Dongfeng and Changan.
From January to May 2024, the situation took a sharp turn for the worse:
GAC Group's total sales volume was 700,000 units, down 24.5% year-on-year;
Guangben’s sales volume was 174,000 units, down 24.3% year-on-year;
Guangfeng's sales volume was 266,000 units, down 27.3% year-on-year;
The sales volume of self-owned brands was 257,000 units, down 17.5% year-on-year. Among them, the sales volume of GAC Passenger Cars was 156,000 units, up 6.2% year-on-year; the sales volume of Aion, which was highly anticipated, was slightly higher than 100,000 units, down 38.7% year-on-year.
From January to May 2024, BYD's cumulative sales reached 1.27 million units, a year-on-year increase of 26.8%; Geely Holding (HK: 00175) was even more powerful, with cumulative sales of nearly 790,000 units in 5 months, a year-on-year increase of 45%. Among them, Zeekr's sales volume was 68,000 units, an increase of 112% from January to May 2023.
One of the reasons for today's passive situation is the relatively insufficient investment in research and development: from 2014 to 2023, GAC Group has invested 44 billion in research and development, of which 36.2 billion was capitalized (capitalization rate of 82.3%), equivalent to 53.4% of the total net profit in 10 years.
Between 2014 and 2023, GAC Group has accumulated investment income of 83.2 billion yuan from its associated/joint ventures, equivalent to 123% of the total net profit for the 10 years.
Let the two Toyotas prosper for another ten years, and Aion or other independent brands will have the strength to “roll”. #Long-termism#




