Hacker reports that Google will start implementing Manifest V3 this week

Google is continuing with its plan to phase out Chrome extensions that support Manifest V2. As previously planned, the rollout of Manifest V3 will begin in June 2024, which will weaken the capabilities of ad blockers and a number of other solutions.

The transition has begun

Although the transition to Manifest V3 has been delayed several times in the past, this time Google developers reportedthat the decision to begin implementation was made based on community feedback, which was considered satisfactory and allows work to continue without further delay.

Starting today, June 3, 2024, users of Chrome 127 (Beta, Dev, and Canary) with Manifest V2 extensions active will begin to see end of support warnings, and extensions that still rely on Manifest V2 will lose the “Featured” badge. .

The phasing out of V2 extensions will then extend to the stable release of Chrome, and users will be advised of alternatives that support Manifest V3. It is expected that people will be able to temporarily re-enable their Manifest V2 extensions, but this option is expected to be removed soon.

Organizations using the ExtensionManifestV2Availability policy will remain exempt until June 2025, after which they will be given an additional year to migrate to Manifest V3-compliant extensions.

Manifest V3

As a reminder, Manifest V3 is a new version of the extensions framework that Google says is designed to improve the security, privacy, performance, and overall reliability of Chrome extensions. Thus, Manifest V3 should help Google achieve the following goals:

  • limit extensions' access to user network requests;
  • force developers to include all functionality in the extension itself, ending the practice of remote code hosting;
  • transfer modification of network requests from extensions to the browser itself;
  • replace background pages with special workers to improve browser performance.

The main problem with Manifest V3, which the community has been discussing since 2018 (1, 2, 3), is that it creates serious technical problems for extension developers and makes it difficult for ad blockers, antiviruses, parental control solutions and various privacy products to work .

Because of this, the Electronic Frontier Foundation called Manifest V3 is “deceitful and dangerous”, stating that “Mv3 is unlikely to have much impact on (users') protection.” In a later article, EFF representatives noted, that Google's “less resource consumption” argument doesn't hold water either. We came to similar conclusions Mozilla specialists. So, Firefox will support Manifest V3, but it has no plans to disable support for Manifest V2.

It is worth saying that back in 2022, the developers of the AdGuard ad blocker spoke in detail about what the transition to Manifest V3 entails, and what problems they had to face when creating a new version of the blocker. In short: there were not enough limits on filtering rules, the syntax of declarative rules was very limited, users could not view filtering logs, and the innovations caused performance problems.

And recently, the developers of uBlock Origin, considered one of the most popular ad blockers, were forced to create a new project called uBO Lite (uBOL), which is a browser extension that supports Manifest V3. While this extension will likely work for many people, the developers caution that more advanced users may need to configure additional settings or grant additional permissions to specific sites.

One of the main problems is that rule sets will no longer be able to be regularly updated by the extension itself through automatic updates. Instead, updates will only occur when new versions of extensions are released, meaning any update will require a new version to be submitted to the Chrome Store, which could entail a security review of several weeks. As a result, for example, YouTube will be able to instantly change its ad delivery system, but once Manifest V3 becomes mandatory, extension developers will not be able to respond to these changes quickly.

The uBlock developers even prepared a special FAQexplaining the difference between the current extension and the new version of Manifest V3.

Skepticism about Manifest V3 stems largely from questions surrounding “content filtering,” as well as the ad blocker APIs and anti-tracking extensions used by advertising companies including Google.

Google, which receives about 77% of its advertising revenue, has yet to provide any serious explanation for why Manifest V3 limits content filtering, and it's unclear how this fits with its goals of “improving security, privacy, performance and reliability.”

However, Google claims that it listened to developer feedback and made the necessary improvements to Manifest V3. Among them: support for user scripts, offscreen documents and expanding the number of allowed rule sets for declarativeNetRequest.

Also among the key changes implemented recently, the company notes the ability to skip reviews for rule updates and version rollbacks, which should provide developers with greater control over updates.

Google says that as a result of its efforts to accelerate adoption of Manifest V3, more than 85% of actively supported Chrome extensions (including popular ad blockers like AdBlock, Adblock Plus, uBlock Origin and AdGuard) have already migrated to Manifest V3 or released versions that support it. .

For developers whose extensions are still running on Manifest V2, Google “strongly recommends” complete migration in the near future.