When Apple chipmaker TSMC received federal subsidies to build its first U.S. plant, creating jobs for American workers was one of the key arguments. But even as hiring continues in full swing, a new report finds that nearly half of the employees at TSMC’s Arizona plant are from Taiwan.
In addition, it is now said that plans for a six-phase expansion program designed to allow the Arizona plant to compete with the output of plants in Taiwan are unlikely to go ahead…
TSMC plant in Arizona: theory and practice
TSMC’s announcement to build a chip plant in Arizona was hailed as a major success for the US Chip Act, designed to free the US from dependence on China for the supply of advanced chips and create jobs for American workers. Apple proudly announced that it will be sourcing American-made chips for some of its devices.
However, the shine soon began to wear off. The plant would only be able to produce larger chips suitable only for older Apple devices, and TSMC soon demanded more subsidies and fewer regulations.
The project is behind schedule and over budget, and production has already been pushed back to 2025 rather than 2024. There is talk that American-made chips will cost more than chips made in Taiwan, which could mean Apple will buy them for less than originally expected.
Nearly half of TSMC’s Arizona plant employees work in Taiwan
US job creation was first called into question when TSMC decided to bring in about 500 Taiwanese workers to speed up construction work. The battle quickly turned ugly because of this.
But while it was described as a short-term measure used only during the construction phase, a new report today paints a different picture. The Financial Times reports that with almost half of the production staff already hired, about 50% of them are actually from Taiwan.
TSMC has already hired more than 2,200 of the 4,500 employees it plans to hire there once both factories are in production. However, nearly half of the employees hired so far are from Taiwan, according to two people familiar with the situation.
One reason for this is said to be that the company hires engineering graduates as technicians because it expects them to be able to use their own initiative to adjust parameters to maximize profitability. But engineering graduates in the US tend to be attracted to more interesting opportunities elsewhere.
“You can empower amazing workers if they’re so highly skilled, but that’s not going to happen in the US,” says Dylan Patel, chief analyst at US consultancy SemiAnalysis. He adds that technicians in Taiwan typically complete four years of engineering school. But for engineering graduates in the US, “there are job opportunities that pay better and are more stimulating, like designing new lenses for Apple or working at Meta than in a factory.”
Expansion plans in doubt
When the project was first announced, the plan was to start with one plant and quickly add a second. This is exactly what happens.
The US government asked the company to add four more plants, for a total of six. This would allow Arizona to compete in output with so-called megafactories in Taiwan and create thousands of additional jobs.
TSMC agreed in principle and acquired the land needed for additional plants, but today’s report suggests that is unlikely to happen.
The two factories the company has announced so far will bring its monthly capacity to 60,000 wafers on which circuits are printed and microchips are cut. That would make the Arizona plant mid-sized, but much smaller than the 100,000-plus-wafer-per-month “gigafactories” the company operates in Taiwan.
TSMC has acquired enough land for four more phases of expansion that could take Arizona to that scale, but has not said so publicly. Some TSMC supplier executives now say they don’t believe the company can achieve all six steps.
Photo: Dan Christian Paduretz/Unsplash