What are the three major problems that the third largest CPU architecture, RISC-V, has to solve? –Fast technology–Technology changes the future

It is most appropriate to use “changing with each passing day” to describe the development of RISC-V in China in the past year.

RISC-V start-ups have emerged one after another, gradually maturing from hardware to software, and applications are no longer limited to microcontrollers. Brave players have begun to test the water in PCs, cars and servers, and have achieved tangible results.

At the same time, the international voice of China’s RISC-V industry has also become stronger.

According to the latest data from the RISC-V International Foundation, as of July 2023, the number of member units has exceeded 3,820, covering more than 70 countries. Among the foundation’s 22 senior member units, 12 are from China.

China’s RISC-V industry has flourished, but new developments have created new problems.

At the third Dishui Lake China RISC-V Industry Forum held on Monday, important contributors to the RISC-V industry discussed the three key issues in the development of China’s RISC-V industry – software ecology, patent protection, and talent training “Start discussions to clarify the future development trend for China’s RISC-V industry.

RISC-V is developing upwards, and servers and cars are “two blossoms”

A year ago, the discussion on the implementation of RISC-V applications was more focused on microcontrollers, but now the application of RISC-V has undergone earth-shaking changes: the industry is no longer conservatively sticking to the IoT field, from cars to servers. Pioneering behaviors that took the first step in the field of performance appeared one after another.

In the automotive field, Corelaid’s NA900 CPU IP successfully passed the ISO26262 highest automotive functional safety level ASIL D certification in July this year, becoming the first RISC-V IP core certified by Corelaid for automotive standards; in the server field, computing Neng Technology launched the first RISC-V server processor – 64-bit multi-core processing SG2042, which won the support of developers and provided developers with better compilation tool support.

The choice to expand to the automotive and server fields based on RISC-V is not groundless, and RISC-V supporters have given strong reasons for their support.

Peng Jianying, CEO of Xinlai Zhirong Semiconductor, said at the Dishui Lake Forum that Xinlai chose to focus on the automotive field for three main reasons:

First, the development of mobile phones as the first generation of smart terminals has hit a bottleneck;

Second, the emergence of new energy vehicles has brought new changes to the new electrification architecture, which means that new markets and new technical requirements have emerged. In the automotive field, ARM is not absolutely leading, and the software ecology is semi-closed. At the same time, automotive chip design companies are more willing to actively embrace the open RISC-V;

Third, Xinlai’s team has years of accumulation in the CPU IP field and is capable of landing in the high-threshold automotive field.

Lian Weihan, chief CPU architect of Tenstorrent Inc., is also positive about RISC-V entering the automotive field.

“In-vehicle systems are the core of competition for smart cars. In order to achieve differentiation in the future, automotive companies must adopt customized instruction sets for electronic systems. RISC-V is the only instruction set that can be customized. Autonomous driving and RISC-V The combination of V is something that will definitely happen,” Lian Weihan explained.Tenstorrent itself is also laying out vehicle-related RISC-V chips.

In August of this year, five chip giants, NXP, Infineon, Qualcomm, Bosch, and Nordic, jointly established a RISC-V company for the automotive field. RISC-V’s entry into the car has become unstoppable.

In the field of servers, Lian Weihan once participated in the architecture design of Tenstorrent RISC-V server processors. He said that the reason why he is optimistic about the development of RISC-V in the server field is that after some market research, RISC-V focuses on The server market is large enough and can bring more economic benefits than AMD and Intel, and the software ecosystem does not need to make much change, so the server field is a good application scenario for RISC-V .

Compared with Tenstorrent, Suanneng Technology’s decision-making is even bolder, “We chose something that no one made, because we think we can use our own technology to make RISC-V server processors”, the product director of Suanneng Technology Lu Jinian said.

At the same time, he said that at the moment when the demand for computing power is overwhelming, he has not seen expensive GPUs become faster, and the new wave of AI is an opportunity for RISC-V.

Three key issues in the development of China’s RISC-V industry

New developments create new problems. With the rapid development of RISC-V, how to solve the three key problems of software ecology, patent protection and talent training?

Join the RISE organization or establish a local software ecological project

“The open hardware platform of RISC-V is to create an open source software ecosystem for RISC-V. The problem is that with the RISC-V development board, although it is easy to open source, it is easy to duplicate investment when writing separate software,” said China RISC- Dr. Dai Weimin, chairman of V Industry Alliance, founder, chairman and president of VeriSilicon, said at this forum.

More than ten years ago, Arm and other Arm SoC companies jointly established Linaro, a non-profit open source organization, to regularly discuss what projects need to be established, what functions to implement, and then assigned to each project for execution. The projects are developed by Linaro developers and member companies According to the requirements of the project, the corresponding development is completed, and then uploaded to the branch maintained by Linaro or the open source branch.

Linaro’s development results are basically open source, and finally successfully contributed to Arm’s open source ecosystem.

Following the example of Linaro, 13 companies recently launched the RISE (RISC-V Software Ecosystem) project to promote the development of the RISC-V software ecosystem.

For Chinese RISC-V companies, is it necessary to join RISE to improve the software ecosystem?

After an intense round table discussion, the guests participating in the round table came to a relatively consistent conclusion:

RISE led by international giants can indeed lead the software ecology, but the organizers have their own core circle. If any Chinese company joins as a single member, it is difficult to take its suggestions seriously. Chinese RISC-V companies should first jointly establish It is more conducive to the development of China’s RISC-V industry and more efficient for its own regional organization to discuss in a small area first, and then send influential members to join RISE as representatives.

Protect patents like Linux

RISC-V is gaining momentum. When x86 and Arm feel threatened, patent issues will become a problem that RISC-V companies have to face. If other CPU IP companies initiate patent lawsuits on CPU micro-architecture, the health of the RISC-V industry ecology Development will be hindered.

In 2004, Microsoft regarded the open source operating system Linux as a serious competitive threat, and implemented a patent policy, using the 4500 patent to suppress Linux.

In 2005, IBM, Red Hat, NEC, SUSE, PHILIPS, and SONY jointly established the Open Invention Network (OIN) as a shared defensive patent pool to protect Linux and related open source projects.

Until 2018, Microsoft finally ended its competition with Linux, joined OIN to embrace open source, and licensed its entire patent portfolio to OIN members for free, including 60,000 patents.

Today, RISC-V needs to learn from the experience of Linux and establish its own patent alliance.

At the Dishui Lake Forum, VeriSilicon Microelectronics, Xinlai Zhirong Semiconductor, Pingtouge, Shiqing Intelligent, Shanghai Sierxin, Juquan Optoelectronics, Xinsiyuan and Shanghai Hengrui Intellectual Property Service Co., Ltd. jointly launched the establishment of RISC -V Patent Alliance, which was initiated by the RISC-V Industry Alliance (CRVIC) and is calling for more RISC-V companies to join.

What are the three major problems that the third largest CPU architecture, RISC-V, has to solve?

Popularizing RISC-V in College Competitions

Arm is able to take root in the Chinese market, and its close cooperation with universities has played an important role. Does training RISC-V talents also need to use development boards for teaching like Arm?

Dr. Chen Hongming, director of the Zhejiang Ocean University Laboratory, said that simply developing RISC-V development courses is not easy to arouse students’ interest. To cultivate RISC-V talents, students need to participate in the competition, so that students are willing to spend time on research and truly achieve production. Learning linkage.

He Hu, an associate professor and doctoral supervisor at the School of Integrated Circuits of Tsinghua University, said that when cultivating RISC-V talents, he did not pay special attention to a certain product or system, but took the open source characteristics of RISC-V as a good target for researching computer architecture.

“In recent years, we have invested a lot of energy in the design of RISC-V GPGPU, fully realizing a GP-GPU instruction-level architecture based on the RISC-V instruction set. At present, we are promoting the establishment of an open source community, Then it can attract a large number of users to participate.” He Hu said

Under the joint construction of industry, academia and research institutes, RISC-V is more and more capable of competing with Arm and x86. Will we be greeted with a new architecture era?

What are the three major problems that the third largest CPU architecture, RISC-V, has to solve?