15 games fight for the throne of the 90s – but the same game has been at the top for over 25 years

(Image source: KONAMI / Nintendo / Editing GIGA)

On Metacritic, all reviews and ratings for video games are bundled and added together to create an overall score. The result: a list of the best that reflects the collective judgment of the international trade press – from retro classics to modern blockbusters. (Source: Metacritic)

We’ve already looked at the top 15 best-rated games of all time – now we’re zooming in on a single decade. The 90s. An era in which games came onto the market without day-one patches and still made history.

15th place: Wipeout XL

Futuristic hovercraft racing, a soundtrack featuring The Chemical Brothers and The Prodigy, and speeds that would make your eyes water – Wipeout XL was one of the coolest racing games to hit shelves in 1996. Back then, Sony specifically used the series to position the PlayStation as a console for adults – and it worked. Anyone who fired up a PlayStation at a shared apartment party in the 90s would sooner or later end up with Wipeout. However, very few of you would have expected that the title made it into the top 15 of the entire decade.

  • Release: September 30, 1996
  • Platform: PlayStation
  • Genre: Racing game
  • Metascore: 93

14th place: Homeworld

In 1999, Relic Entertainment created the first real-time strategy game that took place entirely in three-dimensional space. No flat map, no up and down – your fleets moved freely through the depths of space. The game also told an amazingly emotional story about a people who, after thousands of years in exile, are finally looking for their home planet. Anyone who liked strategy games back then and had a halfway decent PC couldn’t ignore Homeworld.

  • Release: August 31, 1999
  • Platform: PC
  • Genre: Real-time strategy
  • Metascore: 93

13th place: Gran Turismo 2

(Image source: Sony Interactive Entertainment Europe / Polyphony Digital Inc.)

Over 500 cars. Dozens of routes. A system that felt like a real driving test – only without the annoyed driving instructor in the passenger seat. Gran Turismo 2 was the pinnacle of what the PlayStation could achieve in the racing game sector in 1999. Polyphony Digital packed so much content onto the disc that the game had to be shipped on two CDs: one for arcade mode, one for simulation. Anyone who already loved the predecessor simply got more of everything here – and in a quality that shouldn’t have been possible on the hardware.

  • Release: December 23, 1999
  • Platform: PlayStation
  • Genre: Racing game, simulation
  • Metascore: 93

12th place: Super Mario 64

(Image source: Nintendo)

There is a before and an after. And in between is Super Mario 64. When Nintendo sent its plumber into the third dimension in 1996, it changed not just the Mario series, but the entire idea of ​​what 3D games should feel like. The camera was revolutionary, the controls with the N64 controller’s new analog stick were a revelation, and Peach’s Castle became the epitome of a hub level where a secret lurked behind every wall. Anyone who dragged Mario’s face in all directions on the start screen for the first time knows exactly what we’re talking about.

  • Release: September 26, 1996
  • Platform: Nintendo 64
  • Genre: 3D platformer
  • Metascore: 94

11th place: Diablo

One click. Another click. Another one. And suddenly it’s four in the morning, your warrior is wearing golden armor and you have absolutely no idea where the last six hours have gone. In 1996, Diablo was proof that simple gameplay could be more addictive than any complex RPG. Blizzard sent you into the catacombs beneath Tristram and let you climb level by level – always on the hunt for the next better sword, the next rare drop. The fact that the dungeon was randomly generated with each run ensured that no two runs were the same.

  • Release: December 31, 1996
  • Platform: PC
  • Genre: Action RPG
  • Metascore: 94

10th place: Grim Fandango

» Watch video: Grim Fandango – Remastered: Launch Trailer

Manny Calavera is a travel agent. His office is in the afterlife. His customers are dead. Welcome to one of the most creative settings ever imagined by a game developer. In 1998, Tim Schafer and LucasArts mixed film noir, Mexican death cult mythology and dry humor into an adventure that had never existed before – and, to be honest, not since then. Some of the puzzles were hair-raisingly difficult, but the dialogue was so well written that you just wanted to listen to Manny talk. A game that was ahead of its time in every way.

  • Release: October 14, 1998
  • Platform: PC
  • Genre: Adventure
  • Metascore: 94

9th place: Metal Gear Solid

(Image source: KONAMI)

Hideo Kojima didn’t want to make a shooter. He wanted to make a film that you could also happen to be in. The result was Metal Gear Solid – a stealth game that, in 1998, blurred the boundaries between cinema and video games more consistently than any title before it. Solid Snake sneaked through Shadow Moses, breaking the fourth wall and forcing you to switch controller ports to defeat Psycho Mantis. Anyone who experiences this moment for the first time will never forget it. Metal Gear Solid proved that video games can tell stories that stay with you – even if you don’t always understand them right away.

  • Release: October 21, 1998
  • Platform: PlayStation
  • Genre: Stealth action
  • Metascore: 94

8th place: Quake

Doom was the Big Bang. Quake was the shockwave afterward. id Software delivered the first true 3D first-person shooter in 1996 – no more tricks, no 2.5D sprites, but completely three-dimensional levels and enemies. But what really made Quake immortal was the multiplayer. Deathmatch over the Internet, clans, custom maps, mods – the entire competitive shooter scene as we know it today has its origins here. And yes, the soundtrack by Trent Reznor (Nine Inch Nails) definitely made every walk through the dark corridors feel like someone was breathing down your neck.

  • Release: June 22, 1996
  • Platform: PC
  • Genre: First person shooter
  • Metascore: 94

7th place: Sid Meier’s Civilization II

(Image source: MicroProse)

“Just one more round.” No sentence in the history of video games has cost more sleep than this one. In 1996, Civilization II perfected the formula that Sid Meier had established with the first part – and thus became the epitome of the “I’m about to stop” game, in which you only stop when the birds are chirping outside. From Stone Age villages to space missions, from democracy to dictatorship, from peace to nuclear war – everything was in your hands. And that’s exactly what made it so impossible to turn off the computer.

  • Release: February 29, 1996
  • Platform: PC
  • Genre: Turn based strategy
  • Metascore: 94

6th place: Gran Turismo

Before Gran Turismo came out, racing games on consoles were primarily one thing: arcade. Drift, boost, crash, have fun. Polyphony Digital had a different idea in 1998: a racing game that felt like real driving. Each of the over 140 vehicles behaved differently, each corner required braking points, each tuning part noticeably changed the driving behavior. There was also the legendary license mode, which let you prove that you could even drive before letting you onto the track. For an entire generation, Gran Turismo was the reason to buy a PlayStation.

  • Release: May 12, 1998
  • Platform: PlayStation
  • Genre: Racing game, simulation
  • Metascore: 96

5th place: Half Life

(Image source: Valve Corporation)

Gordon Freeman doesn’t speak. He doesn’t get any cutscenes. He doesn’t even look particularly heroic. And yet Half-Life fundamentally changed the first-person shooter genre in 1998. Valve completely dispensed with classic cutscenes and told the entire story from Gordon’s perspective – without ever taking control away from you. The Black Mesa experiment, the alien invasion, the escape through the facility – it all happened while you were in the middle of it all. There was also an AI that actually let enemies act tactically and a level design that felt like one long, connected nightmare. In the best sense.

  • Release: November 19, 1998
  • Platform: PC
  • Genre: First person shooter
  • Metascore: 96

4th place: Tekken 3

Street Fighter had ruled the arcade halls of the early 90s. Tekken 3 took over the throne at the end of the decade – and didn’t give it back anytime soon. Namco’s brawling game in 1998 was faster, smoother and more accessible than anything the competition had to offer. New characters like Jin Kazama, Hwoarang and Eddy Gordo became icons overnight – with Eddy being popular primarily because of how amazingly far he got with wild button mashing. Those who were serious, however, quickly learned that behind the accessible surface lay one of the deepest combat systems of its time. Tekken 3 was the game that ran on every PlayStation. Literally.

  • Release: April 29, 1998
  • Platform: PlayStation
  • Genre: Fighting
  • Metascore: 96

3rd place: GoldenEye 007

» Watch video: GoldenEye 007 – Xbox Game Pass Date Reveal Trailer

Four players. A screen. Divided quarters. And the one unwritten rule that everyone knew: If you vote for Oddjob, you have no friends. GoldenEye 007 wasn’t just one of the best first-person shooters on consoles in 1997 – it was, for many, the very first. Rare proved on the N64 that the genre can work without a mouse and keyboard, and also delivered a multiplayer that put entire friendships to the test. Proximity Mines in the Facility, Golden Gun in the Temple, Slappers Only for the really brave. Anyone who owned an N64 in the late 90s spent at least one evening in these modes. Probably significantly more.

  • Release: August 25, 1997
  • Platform: Nintendo 64
  • Genre: First person shooter
  • Metascore: 96

2nd place: SoulCalibur

Sega’s Dreamcast didn’t have it easy. The console came too early, went too fast and was overrun by the PlayStation 2. But for a moment, anyone who held SoulCalibur in their hands in 1999 no longer knew why they would ever want to play anything else. Bandai Namco’s gunfighter didn’t just look spectacular – it played like one too. The 8-way movement gave you full control over positioning and distance, each fighter felt completely different, and the animations were so fluid that you sometimes forgot you were watching a game and not a martial arts movie. A fighting game that even thrilled people who didn’t really have anything to do with the genre.

  • Release: September 8, 1999
  • Platform: Dreamcast
  • Genre: Fighting
  • Metascore: 98

1st place: The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time

Nintendo / The Legend of Zelda: The Ocarina of Time (Image source: Nintendo)

99 out of 100 points. For over 25 years. No other game in Metacritic history has managed to dethrone Ocarina of Time – not in the 90s, not in the 2000s, not today. What makes Nintendo’s masterpiece so timeless is difficult to put into words. It’s the feeling of stepping onto the plains of Hyrule for the first time and realizing how big this world really is. It’s the moment you play the ocarina and the melody actually changes something in the game world. It’s goosebumps when Ganondorf’s organ booms through the halls of his castle. Composer Koji Kondo created a soundtrack that not only accompanies the game, but is the game itself. If you’ve never played Ocarina of Time, you’re missing a piece of gaming history. It’s that simple.

  • Release: November 21, 1998
  • Platform: Nintendo 64
  • Genre: Action-adventure
  • Metascore: 99